The Reality Check: SAN QUENTIN VIGIL SAYS INCARCERATION HAS BECOME A DEATH SENTENCE by David Bacon

Cries for justice for the prisoners in San Quentin who are experiencing massively high rates of COVID infections. Key quote:

According to the CDCR, the concentration of confirmed cases at San Quentin is 621.9 per 1000. By comparison, for California (a hot spot state) as a whole, the confirmed case rate is 11.1 per 1000. (source:  

https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/covid19/population-status-tracking/)

As I read this, I think of all the people, children, too, in detention. All so distressing. But for poor leadership on the coronavirus pandemic, this would have never happened.

Thanks, David Bacon, for your many years of social justice journalism.

-Angela Valenzuela

The Reality Check: SAN QUENTIN VIGIL SAYS INCARCERATION HAS BECOME A DEATH SESENTENCE

Photo Essay by David Bacon
San Quentin State Prison, San Rafael, CA
Capital & Main, 7/27/20

Vigil participants hold cardboard tombstones bearing the names of San Quentin prisoners 

who have died.

On Sunday, July 19, about a hundred people gathered at the gate of San Quentin State 

Prison in San Rafael, to call for the release of prisoners because of the terrifying spread of 

COVID-19 inside the facility. On May 30th the state Department of Corrections and 

Rehabilitation transferred 121 prisoners from the California Institution for Men prison in 

Chino into San Quentin. At the time there were no known cases of the virus in San Quentin, 

while Chino was a recognized hot spot.

The coronavirus infection spread rapidly through San Quentin. According to the California 

Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation [CDCR], as of the date of the vigil there were 

928 active cases and eleven prisoners had died.

Less than half of the prison's current 3,524 population had been tested in the two weeks 

prior to the vigil. According to the CDCR, the concentration of confirmed cases at San Quentin

is 621.9 per 1000. By comparison, for California (a hot spot state) as a whole, the confirmed

case rate is 11.1 per 1000. (source:  

https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/covid19/population-status-tracking/)

The vigil organizers include the Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity and the Stop 

San Quentin Outbreak Coalition, which describes itself as "a collective of formerly 

incarcerated folks, loved ones with direct connections to San Quentin State Prison, 

community organizers, and currently incarcerated folks at San Quentin State Prison." 

Other participants came from the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights, Re:Store Justice 

and the Asian Prisoner Support Committee. The speeches and placards they carried 

demanded that Governor Newsom come to the prison, that the state grant large-scale 

releases without categorical exclusions (a 50% reduction in the prison population), and 

an immediate stop to all transfers between prisons and from prisons to ICE detention centers.

The day following the vigil a twelfth prisoner, Troy Ashmus, died of the coronavirus 

according to prison authorities. Five more prisoners have died in the past week, 

bringing the total number of deaths at San Quentin to 17. In just 25 days, the number 

of incarcerated people at San Quentin with COVID-19 went from zero to over a thousand 

active cases. As the numbers rise, demonstrations by desperate families have become 

increasingly frequent. 

According to the CDCR, the state prison system now has 7,672 confirmed cases, of which 

1,025 were reported in the last two weeks. Governor Newsom has announced that he 

will release 8,000 prisoners by the end of August, but over the next six weeks the 

infected will likely number in the tens of thousands. With a prison population of 

104,725 (123% of its designed capacity) there isn't adequate space for isolation.

Laura Mondragon, wife of a prisoner, told the vigil participants that Newsom had to act 

more quickly to prevent more deaths. "Getting sent to San Quentin shouldn't be an 

automatic death sentence," she said. "But with the virus there is a terrible risk that

it will be for people like my husband."

Armando Nuñez Salgado, a former prisoner, holds a sign he made 

remembering someone he knew inside.

 While the names of some of the San Quentin prisoners who have died are public, others are not.  

Participants held tombstones in their memory nevertheless.

 The vigil called on Governor Gavin Newsom to release prisoners from San Quentin, and some 

held a banner saying "Release Them All!"  Many speakers denounced what they called a 

"virtual death sentence" imposed on prisoners because of the COVID contagion.

 Austin Tam. an activist from Buenavista United Methodist Church in Alameda.

 Pastor Allison Tanner leads participants in a prayer ritual outside the San Quentin gates. 

Rev. Deborah Lee, behind her, told the vigil that over 7,000 people in the state prison system 

have now tested positive for COVID-19.

 A line of participants stretches out alongside a banner on Sir Francis Drake Blvd.

 A vigil participant

 A vigil participant

 Danny Thongsy, a former prisoner, faced deportation to Laos by Immigration and Customs 

Enforcement after he was released from San Quentin, but community pressure won his release.

 Participants pray for the prisoners who have died.

 Dr. Art Chen, a doctor at Asian Health Services in Oakland, tells vigil participants, "There is no 

"safe" way to social distance in overcrowded prisons, operating well above 100% capacity. 

There is no safe way to transfer incarcerated folks from one prison to another without risking 

a new hot spot."  He asked Governor Newsom, "How many more incarcerated folks will face 

death during this pandemic before you begin mass releases?" 

Laura Mondragon is the wife of a prisoner, and talked about the trauma of not knowing what 

was happening to him.  Phone calls between prisoners and family members were cut off 

five days before the vigil.

Lillian Galedo, director (ret) of Filipino Advocates for Justice, holds a sign and the banner.

Saabir Lockett, special projects coordinator at East Bay Alliance for a Sustainable Economy, 

read a passage from the Koran at the vigil.

Dr. Sue Chan, a founder of Asian Health Services, came to support her son, a San Quentin prisoner.


To see a full set of images of the protest, click here:  https://www.flickr.com/photos/56646659@N05/albums/72157715250290036