Friday, March 29, 2024

After Texas’s DEI Ban, College Students Are Reconsidering State Schools—BUT READ THIS FIRST!

This story in The Nation on how Senate Bill 17 is impacting youth represents a sad state of affairs. Our youth here in Texas are clearly impacted. And negatively so. All I can say is that policy is made by people and not Jesus. Plus, Jesus, I am confident, would never author or support policies that hurt people. What can you do?

Remain informed and get involved. You do have a legislator that represents you. If you don't know who they are, you can find out here

After doing so, reach out to them or their staff to express your sentiments to them. The more that legislators hear from their constituencies that they're supposed to represent, the greater the chance that you will get heard. After all, they want to get re-elected and your vote counts. 

Without a doubt, these are scary and concerning times. However, more than ever, young people impacted need to let these sentiments motivate them. I love how Harvard University pollster John Della Volpe uplifts youth with hard facts in his recently published book titled, Fight: How Gen Z Is Channeling Their Fear and Passion to Save America

From his book, I just learned that Genz and Millennials account for two-fifths of the electorate and they trend progressive. Within that, women more than men are progressive. Now that's electoral power! 

Della Volpe goes into these trends in enormous detail. I encourage all to read this inspiring text. There is a growing literature in this regard, as well. I have, for example, cited Twenge (2023) on this blog before. Also, read this piece by Brownstein (2020) from four years ago in The Atlantic titled, "The GOP’s Demographic Doom: Millennials and Gen Z are only a few years away from dominating the electorate." Oh, my! I think we're "a few years away" now.

All told, the future is yours for the taking, but this can't be an abstraction. It must and can very much be a lived reality. You gotta' have stamina and listen closely and stay attuned to that "generational call" to your generation's "higher purpose" as John Della Volpe terms it. Sí se puede! Yes we can! And we're all the better for it!

In the meantime, consider attending the upcoming May 3, 2024 hearing on SB 17, the very bill in question: Senator Brandon Creighton Announces Oversight on Senate Bill 17 Implementation. You have a voice so use it. There is also power in presence. And always be kind to yourselves, too, and to those around you. Love yourselves. 

As a wise, caring friend once told me when I was your age, a college student, experiencing the gathering clouds of emotion and despair as I contemplated the possibility of dropping out, he said, "Every way in which you are different is every way that you are strong." His perfectly timed uplifting words have been of enduring consequence to me.

Talk to your teachers, professors, ministers, rabbis, parents, community leaders, and trusted elders. Write letters to your local newspapers. Organize with like-minded youth, both in-person and online. Avoid negative, hateful groups and people. Listen to that faint whisper in the ear, that ancestral call to action to make a better world.

My Good Friday energy tells me to tell you that where two or three are gathered, Providence always manifests if done with a good and honorable intention. Struggles like these are not for the faint of heart. And they are always optimally carried out in and with community. It's the only way we can survive this manufactured crisis and organized malaise via the weaponization of policy.

Be well. Be encouraged. Be inspired. 

Love, not hate, is the most powerful force of all. 

Sí se puede! Yes we can! 

-Angela Valenzuela



Brownstein, R. (2020, Oct. 23). The GOP’s Demographic Doom: Millennials and Gen Z are only a few years away from dominating the electorate, The Atlantic.

Della Volpe, J. (2022). Fight: How Gen Z is channeling their fear and passion to save America. St. Martin's Press.

Twenge, J. M. (2023). Generations: The Real Differences Between Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, Boomers, and Silents—and What They Mean for America's Future. Simon and Schuster.

After Texas’s DEI Ban, College Students Are Reconsidering State Schools

In June, Governor Greg Abbott signed a law banning diversity, equity, and inclusion programs in the state university system—including multicultural centers and campus identity groups.

by Aina Marzia | The Nation |  March 26, 2024

A student student sits in a lecture hall while class is being dismissed at the University of Texas at Austin. (Brandon Bell / Getty)

In 2023, the Texas Legislature proposed SB 16, banning the teaching of critical race theory at Texas universities. Among the right, CRT has become a scapegoat, with legislators railing against public schools’ teaching the history and legacy of racial injustice in the United States. 

Now, Texas politicians have gone even further, targeting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs in state colleges.

SB 17, which went into effect January 1, has been a ticking time bomb since it was signed by Governor Greg Abbott in June. The bill bans DEI and its programs, clubs, and organizations within the University of Texas college system, the largest university system in the state with more than 250,000 enrolled students and 21,000 faculty.

During the months-long transition period, UT schools had to close down multicultural centers and realign their practices to comply with SB 17, remove specialized inclusion programs, and defund campus identity groups. Two months after the law went into effect, prospective students are reconsidering what these universities can do for them.

In an e-mail to students on January 23, the director of the Multicultural Engagement Center, Brandelyn Flunder, said that “our doors remain open (for now at least), our programs do not.” The e-mail also shared the loss of several special campus activities like New Black Student Weekend, Adelante, CultivAsian, and graduation ceremonies for Black, Latinx, and Asian students.

“The MEC, an office where many students of color would go to meet with friends, study, talk to their advisers, and where many of the organizations that garnered safe spaces for students of color would meet and stash their things is now closed,” said Katherine Ospina, a senior at the university studying International Relations, and the director of Latinx Community Affairs. “This was the one place I would go to get work done every day, and there was a collective sentiment of relaxation past those doors. My experience at UT has changed drastically as a result of this bill.”

“It seems as though we are taking a step back in reforming an ideal, equitable society,” says Samantha Alvarez, a freshman at UT Austin studying Public Relations. “Coming from a family of immigrants, knowing UT eliminated a scholarship program for undocumented students is both frustrating and saddening.”

In a joint statement on February 2, five community organizations at UT Austin shared how shutting down the engagement center was “part of a larger pattern of over-compliance of SB 17 at the hands of UT Administration.” According to the statement, the center, which was originally supposed to remain open and to restructure, was “wrongfully” shut down.

“These acts push the idea that our spaces are invalid, that our communities are illegal, and that the people in these organizations exclude anyone,” says Xochimilo Vazquez, a junior at UT studying psychology and government and the community engagement chair of the Native American & Indigenous Collective. “This also endangers my friends, family, and peers. Why should I have to take into consideration my safety when applying to a higher academic institution that boasts about being an intellectually pioneering institution? What intellectually pioneering institution ever led with racism?”

Following the bill’s passage, these organizations were informed that they would no longer be allowed to continue operating as sponsored student organizations. Former UT clubs, which were once reliant on annual funding from the university, have started seeking donations to continue operating.

At UT Dallas, one of the largest UT schools, the bill eliminated the Office of Diversity Equity, and Inclusion and created a new Office of Campus Resources and Support. The ODRS “is entirely separate and will lead activities that are SB 17 compliant,” according to their website. “As a new entity, the entire scope of OCRS is still being determined.”

“These clubs provided a sense of community where I could connect with others who shared similar experiences and cultural backgrounds,” says Sahil Lalani, a freshman studying business administration. “The closure of these vital spaces would have influenced my decision-making when considering Texas colleges.”

“I would not have worked in admissions if the metrics in place were the same two years back,” says Ospina, who also works as a student recruiter. In high school, she says, she would have been reluctant to apply to the university if these bills had been passed. “The idea of staying here postgraduation is extremely narrow.”

For current high school seniors in the state who are considering attending colleges within the UT system, this legislation has clouded their decisions. “I anticipate SB17 definitely affecting the decisions some students make regarding post–secondary education options, especially POC university enrollment in the state, specifically those who seek a more inclusive environment to attain their education,” said Nancy Sutherland, a high school counselor in Texas.

“Eliminating DEI offices as a whole strips away many potential students’ motivation to attend higher education,” says Haala Tariq, a high school senior in Houston. “One of my goals was to explore the cross-sections between marginalized communities and the conventional healthcare system. Senate Bill 17 will make it harder for the university to receive research funding from organizations that consider commitments to diversity when awarding grants.”

“The elimination of DEI on college campuses may lead to less cultural awareness and political participation as well as a decline in resources for people of different backgrounds,” said Sutherland. “Without DEI resources, this could potentially result in a decline in student success, and ability to perform in a global environment, particularly for minority populations.”

“I wanted to send my child and my nephews to the University of Texas, but now I don’t know,” says Dr. LaShawn Washington, who got her master’s and bachelor’s degrees at UT Austin and worked at the Division of Diversity and Community Engagement as a student. “SB 17 is based on the argument that DEI doesn’t work, but a lot of these people are white conservatives, or it is conservative political think tanks making arguments about something that wasn’t made to serve them,” said Washington.

“I fear Texas has taken a big step away from the celebration of equality,” says Alyssa Perez, a high school senior who was recently accepted into UT Austin and UT El Paso. “And I fear what other freedoms they can take away.”

While Perez is choosing to attend a school in-state because of financial constraints, other high school seniors are willing to take the hit economically for a more fulfilling college experience outside of Texas. “I feel unsafe with our political climate, so much so that I’ve essentially resigned myself to debt and student loan stress,” says Greg Rico, a transgender high school senior from Texas. “I applied to two Texas public schools, but I don’t plan on attending either of them.”

My Good Friday Reflections on Texas Bishop Slams Greg Abbott, Says Christians Have 'Duty to Resist'

The humanitarian crisis happening before our eyes along the U.S.-Mexico border is anguishing. Yes, there are a lot of people coming. No, they are not invaders "attacking" our country. Immigration scholarship always points to "push" and "pull" factors that motivate migration.

Push mechanisms can be significant, including threats to well-being or livelihood, and the impetus to survive difficult conditions and circumstances that individuals and families face back home, be they political, economic, or related to climate change, including factors that turn many families into "climate refugees." 

Pull factors include a need and desire to be with family living in the U.S., the pursuit of opportunities not available in the homeland, as well as work opportunities. Many seek asylum, including safe harbor fleeing violence and the pursuit of religious freedom. The lion's share would rather stay at home were this a viable option.

In virtually all instances, regardless, the treacherous journey into the U.S. is a significant hardship and our Christian values as a nation would seem to dictate mercy, tolerance, and respect for the dignity of all migrants.

After all, the Bible in Exodus 22:21 says "Do not mistreat or oppress a foreigner, for you were foreigners in Egypt. Considering that today is Good Friday should not Galatians 3:28 have special meaning? "There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus."

I'm not Catholic but nevertheless side with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on this one. Governor Abbott's anti-immigrant agenda—which is arguably part and parcel to his anti-diversity campaign, is soulless, cruel, and ungodly. 

When will we as humanity evolve toward a unity consciousness where we observe and honor every single person's right to respect and a life of dignity? Is this not the call for resurrection and renewal that rests at the heart of Easter and Christianity itself? I would certainly hope so. God bless us all.

Peace / paz,

-Angela Valenzuela

Texas Bishop Slams Greg Abbott, Says 

Christians Have 'Duty to Resist'

March 28, 2024 By   | Newsweek

A bishop in El Paso, Texas, a popular U.S. entry point for illegal immigration,

said statewide efforts to villainize migrants is a sad sight and falls on the

shoulders of Governor Greg Abbott.

Abbott has arguably been the most outspoken public official in condemning

the claimed inaction of the federal government surrounding illegal immigra-

tion, which has soared under the Biden administration and hit a record high

during the 2023 fiscal year. He instituted Operation Lone Star in March 2021

to build more border wall and leverage additional National Guard soldiers to

deter migrants from entering unlawfully.

Total border crossings exceeded 988,900 between October and December,

following a record 2.4 million migrant encounters at the U.S.-Mexico border

in fiscal 2023—up from about 1.7 million in 2021.

Texas officials like Abbott are trying to take their own action without federal

intervention, waiting to see if it can enforce its own immigration laws, including

arrests and deportation through legislation known as Senate Bill 4 (S.B. 4), which

was approved last year in an 88-4 vote.

Texas Governor Greg Abbott makes an announcement on the future of the space industry in Texas,

at NASA's Johnson Space Center in Houston on March 26. Abbott is receiving criticism from local clergy

for his migrant policies.

"You have seen the Humvees and the concertina wire and the national guardsmen on the television," Bishop Mark Seitz of the Diocese of El Paso said during a March 18 lecture at Fairfield University, a Jesuit institution in Connecticut, according to the National Catholic Reporter.

Seitz called Texas officials' efforts "transparently political" and part of a "broader, brutal, historical project in Texas to criminalize and police people who migrate."

"People of faith have a duty to resist these racist projects," he added.

Seitz is the chairman of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' (USCCB) Office of Migration, which sets broad policies and direction for the church's work in areas including advocacy, education, refugee resettlement, and providing specialized services to at-risk and vulnerable populations including victims of trafficking and unaccompanied minors.

The Diocese of El Paso was instituted on March 3, 1914, and covers roughly 26,700 square miles including nine Texas counties, 56 parishes, 18 missions and a Catholic population of 686,000.

Newsweek reached out to Abbott, the diocese and the USCCB via email for comment.

Abbott and other Texas officials received bad news on Wednesday, when the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals denied Texas' request to allow S.B. 4 to go into effect while the court considers its legality. It is being praised by civil rights groups as a victory in what has become a contentious court battle that has extended to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Chief Judge Priscilla Richman wrote in the ruling that "for nearly 150 years, the Supreme Court has held that the power to control immigration—the entry, admission, and removal of noncitizens—is exclusively a federal power."

The ruling allows a lower-court decision to remain in place. The Fifth Circuit will hear arguments on April 3 in New Orleans about whether the injunction should be upheld.

"The court did the right thing in preventing the implementation of S.B. 4," El Paso County attorney Jo Anne Bernal said in a statement shared with Newsweek. "We will continue seeking a court decision permanently enjoining this law that has already caused so much fear and divisiveness in our community."

Seitz also reportedly rebuked Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton for his office's efforts to defund Annunciation House, a decades-old Catholic migrant shelter in El Paso that was alleged by the AG to have facilitated illegal entry to the United States, harboring illegal migrants, human smuggling, and operating a stash house.

This month, a district court judge in Texas said Paxton's efforts were presented "without regard to due process or fair play."

"The attack on Annunciation House represents an escalation in Texas' efforts in recent years to militarize the border and to enact legislation criminalizing migration and people who migrate," Seitz said.

The bishop told Crux, an online newspaper that focuses on news related to the Catholic Church, that the hypothetical situation of Texas officials deporting migrants without properly allowing for the asylum process to play out "saddens" him.

"I'm very disappointed in the narrative that is being promoted to this day that people who are fleeing to our border are a threat to us in the first place," Seitz said. "It's just a tremendous misunderstanding of what's happening."

Thursday, March 28, 2024

How Texas Law was Manipulated to Orchestrate the HISD Takeover

 [en español aqui


Sharing here the timeline of the Texas Education Agency (TEA) Takeover of HISD (2015-2023) authored by Houston Community Voices for Public Education (HCVPE), a group that has taken TEA and the installed Superintendent Mike Miles to task.

How did the HISD state takeover happen? Here you go. As you can see from the photo, HCVPE is a large community-based organization that is fighting the brave and noble fight against the de-democratization of public education. What's playing out in Houston is a travesty, a calculated harm by those that want to seed public displeasure to not only further the privatization agenda, but to also curb the political efficacy of a community, and in so doing, the franchise. Yes, the disenfranchisement of Black and Brown youth and their families and grassroots leaders.

If you see the slides, you'll note that this was a policy ambush, a manufactured, very much contrived "crisis." HCVPE need everybody's support, my friends.

-Angela Valenzuela

How Texas Law was Manipulated to Orchestrate the HISD Takeover

HoustonCVPE HoustonCVPE | July 18, 2023

Timeline of Changes since HISD State Takeover

Here's a 10-slide story that summarizes how Texas law and the Texas Education Code were used to take over Houston ISD, the largest school district in Texas. The state takeover of Houston ISD is not really about helping our schoolchildren at all. It is part of a broader attack on public education occurring across the country.

In Texas, the takeover has been orchestrated by the Republican-led Texas state government working hand in hand with individuals on both sides of the aisle. Their harmful reform agenda promotes using teacher and school accountability almost entirely based on high-stakes testing at the expense of our children, teachers and schools.