Translate

Showing posts with label bilingual education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bilingual education. Show all posts

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Bilingualism Is Our Strength: Supporting Our Children, Educators, and Communities, by Angela Valenzuela, Ph.D. Oct. 25, 2026

Bilingualism Is Our Strength: Supporting Our Children, Educators, and Communities

by

Angela Valenzuela, Ph.D.

October 25, 2026


Link
I want to share a few excellent resources from the Texas Association for Bilingual Education (TABE) that speak to an issue very close to my heart: the importance of bilingual education and the fundamental right of children and communities to have their languages, cultures, and identities respected and nurtured in our public schools. Note: 
For readability and ease, I re-cast most of the information in these flyers below.

Throughout my career, I have advocated for educational approaches that build upon, rather than subtract from, the linguistic and cultural resources children bring to school. Indeed, this concern lies at the heart of my 1999 book, Subtractive Schooling: U.S.-Mexican Youth and the Politics of Caring (State University of New York Press). 

Link
When schools treat children's home languages as obstacles to overcome instead of intellectual and cultural resources to cultivate, they risk undermining not only students' educational opportunities but also their relationships with their fellow immigrant peers, families, communities, and cultural histories. We can and must do better.

I am an unwavering supporter of bilingual and dual language education, and of the extraordinarily dedicated teachers, university professors, researchers, and community advocates who have sustained this work, often against considerable political and institutional obstacles. 

I am equally committed to supporting the next generation of bilingual educators, including the students who are future bilingual educators involved in BESO (Bilingual Education Student Organization) at the University of Texas at Austin and various other universities across our state. 

These aspiring educators represent a vital part of our educational future. Their commitment to bilingualism, biliteracy, cultural understanding, and educational justice deserves our recognition, encouragement, and institutional investment.

Link

Our universities have an indispensable role to play in preparing bilingual and dual-language teachers, supporting rigorous research, and strengthening the partnerships with schools, families, and communities that make successful bilingual education possible. At a time when Texas educates more than 1.3 million emergent bilingual students, we should be expanding—not diminishing—our capacity to prepare the educators these children need.

Equally important, our families and communities deserve meaningful opportunities to access high-quality bilingual and dual-language instruction. 

For example, see this TABE flyer on parents knowing their civil rights also provides advice on how parents and community can advocate for bilingual education.

Such opportunities should not depend upon a family's ZIP code, financial circumstances, or whether a school district has chosen to prioritize linguistic diversity. Nor should bilingualism be reserved for privileged students whose families can afford private enrichment or specialized language instruction. The opportunity to become bilingual and biliterate should be widely available to all children, including English-speaking children who can benefit tremendously from learning another language.

Bilingual education is not simply a matter of language instruction. It is about educational equity, cultural continuity, belonging, and the kind of democratic and inclusive society we aspire to build. It is also about recognizing that our multilingual communities are not a problem to be solved but a tremendous public resource. As our world becomes increasingly interconnected, the ability to communicate across languages and cultures should be regarded as an educational achievement and a public good.

Link to PDF
I am grateful to TABE for producing these accessible and informative materials,which challenge persistent misconceptions about bilingual education and help families understand the options available to their children. I encourage parents, teachers, university students, policymakers, and community members to read and share them widely.

Our goal should never be merely to help children learn English at the expense of the languages they already know. Our goal should be to open doors, expand opportunities, and empower them to become fully bilingual, biliterate, and academically successful without sacrificing the identities and relationships that sustain them.

Finally, I want to extend my heartfelt congratulations and appreciation to Dr. Karina Zuno-Chapa and the entire TABE board for their extraordinary leadership and commitment to advancing bilingual education across our state. Their work is helping to fuel not only the growth of bilingual and dual-language education in Texas but also the broader public understanding, appreciation, and support that these programs so richly deserve.

Of course, TABE is part of a larger movement that includes longtime champions such as the Intercultural Development Research Association (IDRA), alongside dedicated educators, researchers, university students, families, and community advocates who have worked tirelessly for generations to defend and expand bilingual education. What makes this collective effort so powerful is its insistence that bilingualism is not a deficit to overcome but a tremendous intellectual, cultural, and societal asset to cultivate.

2026 TABE Board

Particularly in these times when public education is under attack, thank you, Dr. Zuno-Chapa, the TABE board, and all of our educators who are helping to make bilingualism and biliteracy a reality for more Texas children. Your leadership is strengthening our schools, empowering our communities, and helping build a future in which every child has the opportunity to learn, thrive, and take pride in their linguistic and cultural heritage.

¡Adelante con la educación bilingüe!

Links to flyers: https://tabe.org/index.php (English) https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bG0VeVy51W2XND4U4OWIb2h0jnD0zdPd/view (Spanish)

*********************************************************************************************

Adapted from two educational resources developed by the Texas Association for Bilingual Education (TABE): "Myths & Facts About Bilingual Education" and "Empowering Families of Emergent Bilingual Students in Texas."

Texas is one of the most linguistically diverse states in the country. More than 1.3 million Texas public school students are identified as emergent bilinguals—children who are developing English while bringing the knowledge and resources of another language into their classrooms.

For these students, bilingual education is not about correcting a deficiency. It is about building upon an existing strength.

Research demonstrates that children can develop bilingualism, biliteracy, and academic proficiency simultaneously. High-quality bilingual and dual-language programs help make this possible by treating students' languages as educational resources rather than obstacles.

Texas Bilingual Education by the Numbers

According to figures highlighted by TABE and reflected in Texas Education Agency data from the 2024–2025 school year:

  • 1.3 million+ emergent bilingual students attend Texas public schools.

  • 24% of Texas public school students are identified as emergent bilinguals—nearly one in four.

  • 120+ languages are spoken in Texas public schools.

  • 85.7% of emergent bilingual students speak Spanish as their primary language.

  • 95%+ of Texas public school districts and charter school systems serve emergent bilingual students.

  • Nearly one in four emergent bilingual students in the United States is educated in Texas.

These numbers tell an important story: Linguistic diversity is not marginal to Texas public education. It is central to who we are as a state and to the future of our public schools.

Eight Common Myths About Bilingual Education—and What the Evidence Tells Us

Myth 1: Children will learn English faster if they stop speaking their home language.

Fact: Maintaining and developing a child's home language supports additional language learning, including English. Strong literacy skills developed in one language can support learning in another. Children do not need to abandon Spanish or another home language to become proficient in English.

Myth 2: Speaking two languages confuses children.

Fact: Children are fully capable of learning multiple languages. Moving between languages or mixing words is often a normal part of bilingual language development, not evidence of confusion.

Myth 3: Students should leave bilingual programs as quickly as possible.

Fact: Sustained participation in well-designed bilingual and dual-language programs can produce important long-term benefits, including stronger biliteracy and academic achievement. Quickly transitioning students into English-only instruction may interrupt opportunities to develop advanced proficiency in both languages.

Myth 4: Bilingual education is only for students who struggle academically.

Fact: Bilingual education is not remedial education. High-quality programs offer academically rigorous instruction while developing proficiency in two languages. Students can learn challenging academic content and become bilingual and biliterate at the same time.

Myth 5: Speaking Spanish or another language at home will hurt a child's English development.

Fact: Families should continue speaking the languages they know best. Conversations, storytelling, reading, songs, and shared cultural experiences help children develop language, literacy, knowledge, and family connections. These experiences are resources for academic learning.

Myth 6: Dual-language programs are only for Spanish-speaking students.

Fact: Dual-language programs can serve both English-speaking students and students who speak a partner language, including Spanish. Two-way dual-language programs deliberately bring these learners together so that students develop bilingualism, biliteracy, and intercultural understanding.

Myth 7: Being bilingual is useful only for language-related careers.

Fact: Bilingualism is valuable across many professions, including healthcare, law, engineering, business, education, technology, public service, and government. It also strengthens communication across communities and expands opportunities for participation in an increasingly interconnected world.

Myth 8: Losing one's home language is a natural process that does not matter.

Fact: Home-language loss can have serious personal, cultural, and intergenerational consequences. It can weaken communication with family members, diminish access to cultural knowledge, and affect children's sense of identity and belonging. Schools and families can work together to preserve and develop children's linguistic resources.

Why Bilingualism Matters Beyond the Classroom

The benefits of bilingual education extend beyond acquiring a second language.

Academic benefits. Well-designed bilingual programs can strengthen literacy and reading comprehension, support learning across languages, and create opportunities for students to meet demanding academic expectations while developing biliteracy.

Cognitive benefits. Learning and using more than one language provides opportunities to practice cognitive flexibility, language awareness, and adaptation to different communicative settings. Specific cognitive advantages vary across individuals and contexts, but bilingualism itself is not a source of intellectual confusion.

Social and cultural benefits. Bilingualism allows students to communicate across generations and communities, maintain family relationships and cultural traditions, and deepen their understanding of different cultural perspectives.

Economic benefits. Bilingual individuals bring valuable linguistic and intercultural skills to an increasingly multilingual workforce. Their knowledge can expand professional opportunities and improve communication in institutions serving diverse populations.

Perhaps most importantly, bilingual education can help children understand that their languages, families, histories, and identities belong in school.

Understanding Bilingual Education Programs in Texas

Not all programs serving emergent bilingual students are the same. Families benefit from understanding the differences.

1. Dual-Language Immersion

These programs seek to develop proficiency and literacy in two languages while supporting academic achievement and intercultural competence.

One-Way Dual Language: Students generally share a common home language other than English and receive instruction designed to develop both that language and English.

Two-Way Dual Language: Students who speak English and students who speak a partner language learn together, developing proficiency and literacy in both languages.

Dual-language programs are particularly important because their goal is not simply English acquisition but additive bilingualism—developing a new language while maintaining and strengthening another.

2. Transitional Bilingual Education

These programs use students' home language and English for instruction, with the goal of transitioning students toward predominantly English instruction.

Early Exit: Students transition to primarily English instruction sooner.

Late Exit: Students receive home-language instructional support for a longer period before transitioning.

Unlike dual-language immersion, transitional programs generally do not aim to sustain biliteracy in both languages throughout students' schooling.

3. English as a Second Language (ESL)

ESL programs focus on developing English proficiency and ensuring access to academic content.

ESL Pull-Out: Students receive targeted English-language instruction, often outside their regular classroom or core instructional setting.

ESL Content-Based: Students receive academic content instruction in English using approaches designed to support English-language development.

Although ESL programs can provide essential support, they differ from bilingual programs that intentionally develop academic proficiency and literacy in both English and students' home languages.

Why Program Quality and Duration Matter

Not all bilingual programs produce the same outcomes. Strong programs need appropriately prepared educators, meaningful home-language instruction, rigorous academic content, sustained support, and opportunities for students to continue developing both languages over time.

TABE also highlights the expansion of two-way dual-language programs in Texas, reporting growth of more than 70% over the preceding decade. This reflects growing recognition of the value of developing two languages rather than replacing one with another.

What Families and Communities Can Do

Parents and caregivers are children's first language teachers. Their participation is vital.

Families can support their children's development by continuing to speak and read in their home languages, encouraging storytelling and intergenerational conversations, learning about available bilingual and dual-language programs, and asking whether those programs provide sustained opportunities for biliteracy.

Community members can advocate for qualified bilingual educators, stronger teacher preparation, sufficient instructional resources, and access to high-quality programs.

School leaders and policymakers can support this work by investing in bilingual educator recruitment and retention, meaningful family engagement, and programs that treat multilingualism as a lasting educational goal.

The larger lesson is clear: Children should never have to choose between academic success and their linguistic and cultural identities.

A quality education should make it possible for them to retain, develop, and celebrate both.

Source: Texas Association for Bilingual Education (TABE), www.tabe.org. Adapted from its bilingual education myths-and-facts and family advocacy resources. Figures reflect the data presented in the materials; statistics may change over time.

Bilingual Education: Research and Resources

Cashiola, L. (2024, Dec. 16). Bilingualism is a strength Texas is failing to nurture for hundreds of thousands of students. Kinder Institute for Urban Research, Rice University. https://kinder.rice.edu/urbanedge/bilingualism-strength-texas-failing-nurture-students

Fibla, L., Kosie, J. E., Kircher, R., Lew-Williams, C., & Byers-Heinlein, K. (2022). Bilingual language development in infancy: What can we do to support bilingual families? Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 9(1), 35–43. https://doi.org/10.1177/23727322211069312

García, O., & Kleyn, T. (Eds.). (2016). Translanguaging with multilingual students: Learning from classroom moments. Routledge. https://www.routledge.com/Translanguaging-with-Multilingual-Students-Learning-from-Classroom-Mom/Garcia-Kleyn/p/book/9781138906976

Howard, E. R., Lindholm-Leary, K. J., Rogers, D., Olague, N., Medina, J., Kennedy, B., Sugarman, J., & Christian, D. (2018). Guiding principles for dual language education (3rd ed.). Center for Applied Linguistics. https://www.cal.org/publications/guiding-principles-3/

Intercultural Development Research Association. (2026, May 11). Texas policy for serving bilingual students: Texas Must Expand Excellent Education for Emergent Bilingual Students–IDRA 2025 Policy Digest for Texas. https://www.idra.org/education_policy/texas-policy-for-serving-bilingual-students/

King, K., & Fogle, L. (2006). Raising bilingual children: Common parental concerns and current research [CAL Digest]. Center for Applied Linguistics. https://www.cal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/RaisingBilingualChildrenEnglishSpanish.pdf

Lehtonen, M., Fyndanis, V., & Jylkkä, J. (2023). The relationship between bilingual language use and executive functions. Nature Reviews Psychology, 2, 360–373. https://doi.org/10.1038/s44159-023-00178-9

Moncada-Cummings, C. (n.d.). Bilingualism. Ventris Learning. https://www.ventrislearning.com/linguistic-anthropologic-considerations/bilingualism/

National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2017). Promoting the educational success of children and youth learning English: Promising futures. National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/24677

Office of English Language Acquisition. (2018). English learner family toolkit. U.S. Department of Education. https://ncela.ed.gov/educator-support/toolkits/family-toolkit

Office of English Language Acquisition. (2024). Dual language immersion playbooks. U.S. Department of Education. https://www.ncela.ed.gov/resources/ncela-resources/playbooks/dual-language-immersion-playbook

Piñón, L., Carreón-Sánchez, S., & Bishop, S. (2022). Emergent bilingual learner education—Literature review. Intercultural Development Research Association. https://www.idra.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Emergent-Bilingual-Learner-Education-%E2%80%93-Literature-Review-IDRA.pdf

Rolstad, K., Mahoney, K., & Glass, G. V. (2005). The big picture: A meta-analysis of program effectiveness research on English language learners. Educational Policy, 19(4), 572–594. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904805278067

Steele, J. L., Slater, R. O., Zamarro, G., Miller, T., Li, J., Burkhauser, S., & Bacon, M.  (2017). Effects of dual-language immersion programs on student achievement: Evidence from lottery data. American Educational Research Journal, 54(1_suppl), 282S–306S. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831216634463

Texas Association for Bilingual Education. (n.d.-a). Journal of Bilingual Education Research & Instruction [Peer-reviewed journal]. https://tabejournal.org/index.php/JBERI/index

Texas Association for Bilingual Education. (n.d.-b). Professional development services. https://tabe.org/index.php/services/pd-services

Texas Education Agency. (n.d.). Bilingual education: Bilingual and English as a second language education programs. https://tea.texas.gov/special-populations-and-support/english-learner-support/bilingual-education-bilingual-and-english-second-language-education-programs

TXEL. (n.d.). LPAC framework: Parent resources. https://www.txel.org/lpac/parentresources/

U.S. Department of Education, Office of English Language Acquisition. (2016). English learner toolkit for state and local education agencies (SEAs and LEAs). https://www.ed.gov/teaching-and-administration/lead-and-manage-my-school/state-support-network/ssn-resources/english-learner-toolkit-for-state-and-local-education-agencies-seas-and-leas

Valentino, R. A., & Reardon, S. F. (2015). Effectiveness of four instructional programs designed to serve English learners: Variation by ethnicity and initial English proficiency. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 37(4), 612–637. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373715573310

Valenzuela, A. (1999). Subtractive schooling: U.S.-Mexican youth and the politics of caring. State University of New York Press. https://sunypress.edu/Books/S/Subtractive-Schooling

WIDA. (n.d.). Engaging families and communities. https://wida.wisc.edu/teach/engagement

Zelasko, N. F. (n.d.). Bilingual education. Education Encyclopedia. https://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1788/Bilingual-Education.html

Wednesday, June 04, 2025

Gen-Z Latino-Americans are reclaiming their culture through language, By Emily Schutz | ABC News

Friends,

This ABC News piece by Emily Schutz beautifully captures a quiet but powerful cultural renaissance unfolding within Gen-Z Latino communities. The stories of Alex Del Dago and Mia Hernandez reflect a broader trend of reclamation—of language, heritage, and intergenerational connection—that is both personal and political. 

As someone deeply involved in education and community-based work, I see firsthand how language is not just a tool for communication but a vessel for identity, memory, and belonging. It’s especially moving to witness young people bridging the silences created by assimilation—not out of obligation, but out of love for their families, their roots, and themselves.

As a third-generation Mexican American/Tejana/Chicana, I carry my own story of linguistic loss. Hard as I tried, I know I missed so much with my Spanish-speaking grandfather, who was from the state of Guerrero, Mexico—something I regret deeply. But it wasn’t by choice. Like so many others in Texas and across the country, I was forced to assimilate through an English-only schooling system in my hometown of San Angelo, Texas.

This is still the norm, not the exception. And it wasn’t just about language—it was about identity. That painful erasure is what informed my book Subtractive Schooling, which is now marking its 25th anniversary.

Thankfully, I had a passive understanding of Spanish growing up—I could comprehend more than I could speak, an experience familiar to many in our community. Over time, with much effort, I regained enough fluency to hold meaningful conversations with my Mexican family. Still, I’ve never quite shaken that lingering sense of loss and longing. So I’m especially heartened to see young people reclaiming what was once taken. 

It's also what we're all about at Academia Cuauhtli, a Saturday school that I and others co-founded 11 years ago in order to honor and nurture children's identities, sense of self, and heritage. We do not teach the Spanish language; rather, we teach in the language. It's a school that I wish I could have attended as a young person.

Mia’s reminder is critical: reclaiming culture doesn’t require fluency or perfection. It requires intention, openness, and care. Whether through food, music, stories, or language—every act of connection is a quiet form of resistance against cultural erasure.

Gracias to Emily Schutz for highlighting this powerful resurgence.

—Angela Valenzuela

Gen-Z Latino-Americans are reclaiming their culture through language

Learning Spanish is bringing together the generations.

By Emily Schutz | ABC News


September 20, 2022, 3:16 PM


Alex Del Dago was in the seventh grade when he attended a Spanish class. It was the first time he was focused on learning his father’s native language. The class also served as the gateway for meaningful communication with his grandmother, who he calls abuela, who speaks only Spanish.

Del Dago’s abuela tells him that she’s glad he learned the language and that his ability to speak Spanish has improved their relationship.

“I knew that if I didn't put in the work or put in the practice to learn it, I may never be, never be able to actually have like a real substantial conversation with her,” Del Dago said.

Mia Hernandez is pictured at age four alongside her Abuela, who was born and raised in Cuba. At the time, Hernandez only knew how to say basic phrases in Spanish. 
Courtesy of Mia Hernandez

According to a 2017 report by the Pew Research Center, 11% of American adults with Hispanic ancestry do not identify as Hispanic. Similarly, while there is widespread support for the language among Hispanics, the more generations a family has been in the United States, the less likely they are to teach their children Spanish.

MORE: Why Spanish-language voting ballots are critical for democracy, advocates say


But some Gen-Z Latino-Americans like Del Dago are reclaiming their culture via language and learning it later in life.

From seventh grade through college, Del Dago studied Spanish through courses at school. His dad was born in Cuba and immigrated to the United States when he was 4 years old, along with his younger brother and parents. The family left Cuba during the Freedom Flights of the late 1960s and early 1970s.

Del Dago’s dad had a difficult time learning English without a program for non-native speakers and he didn’t feel like his son fit in with the other students in class, which influenced his decision to speak to Del Dago exclusively in English.

“At the time [my parents] decided it would be better just to raise me speaking English because they thought it would be easier for me to fit in and adjust and make friends quickly,” Del Dago said.

Del Dago’s experience is not unusual. With each generation, the number of Hispanic heritage parents who speak to their children in Spanish decreases. Seventy-one percent of U.S.-born second-generation Latino parents speak to their children in Spanish and fewer than half of all third- or higher-generation Latino parents do, according to the Pew Research Center.

“One of the main proponents of allowing children or creating more dual language programs is Dr. Kim Potoski, and she has found no evidence that just growing up in these bilingual settings will take away from your ability to speak English. On the contrary -- it helps you,” said Anel Brandl, a professor at Florida State University who teaches Spanish to students with Hispanic heritage.

Mia Hernandez celebrates her second birthday with her Abuela, and brother, Micheal.
Courtesy of Mia Hernandez

Mia Hernandez is a former student of Brandl’s and has a similar upbringing to Del Dago. Her dad is also from Cuba. Growing up, her parents worried that teaching her Spanish would hinder her ability to speak English, although Brandl says that recent research has disproven that.

Hernandez recently graduated from Florida State University with a minor in Spanish. Now she’s fluent in a language she barely spoke growing up.

“I feel a lot closer to my Cuban heritage now that I speak Spanish than before when I almost completely rejected it in favor of learning English so that I could fit in with my English-speaking American friends,” Hernandez said.Just like Del Dago, learning Spanish transformed her relationships with her family members.

“I think the difference has just been getting to know my grandmother a lot more and about her life growing up in Cuba,” Hernandez said.

Now, Hernandez is training to teach Spanish speakers abroad English, and Del Dago is getting his Ph.D. in art history, focusing on queer Latin artists. Both have worked to connect to their familial heritage through the power of language.

Alex Del Dago stands with his Abuela and father just before his high school graduation. At this point, he had taken four years of Spanish and was able to have substantial conversations with his Abuela, who was born and raised in Cuba. Courtesy of Alex Del Dago

Hernandez emphasized that you don’t need to speak Spanish in order to feel connected to your culture.

“I don't think that it's something that there should be any guilt or shame around not learning, but I think it's also up to us to figure out how to move forward, as Cuban Americans, deciding how we want to raise our children, and so whether we want to teach our children Spanish, we want to teach them about maybe the culture and the food,” she said.


Friday, October 18, 2024

Ninth-grade ethnic studies helped students for years, Stanford researchers find

Friends:

To know why Ethnic Studies works, read these articles that explain why. I'm so glad that Dr. Eliza Epstein shared it with me and others while reminding us of our own struggle in Texas to advance Ethnic Studies citing, "'Never Without a Fight': How Texas Has Stood Up for Ethnic Studies, by Maribel Falcón.

Dr. Epstein also shares this in-depth, authoritative piece published by the National Education Association authored by leading scholar Dr. Christine Sleeter titled, What the Research Says About Ethnic Studies that is also great for the college classroom, together with works cited herein.


Why does it work? The short answer to this question is that all of these pieces collectively speak to the importance of a curriculum that not only fosters positive pro-social and communitarian values but as importantly, speaks to the situated experiences of the children and youth in the classroom.

The jury is in. Ethnic Studies changes lives and promotes college-going. The reason we have to struggle for it is therefore less about evidence than it is about politics. This is the story for quality, well-funded, and staffed Bilingual Education, too. Yet both offer such potential and richness to culture and society.

I remain encouraged by the ongoing activism around it.

This morning I read a Bible verse that says, "God blesses those who hunger and thirst for justice, for they will be satisfied." (Matthew 5:6)

Regardless of religion, faith, or creed, this is who we are in the Ethnic Studies struggle. We hunger and thirst for justice. We advocate for our children, youth, and communities. We care deeply about the future. This shouldn't even be a struggle to begin with. 

It's a lifelong quest that will most certainly continue until we are satisfied. In some sense, for those of us knee-deep into the movement, it already is. We love the work we do in our communities like we do at Academia Cuauhtli, our Saturday school in Austin, Texas, to offer a nurturing, culturally resonant pedagogy and vision for the future. At this school, we combine Ethnic Studies, Bilingual Education, and Indigenous pedagogy into a beautiful curriculum for elementary school youth that motivates and inspires. There needs to be more Academia Cuauhtlis in the world.

I've always said that someday, Ethnic Studies will just be called a "good education." Thanks, Dr. Epstein. I always appreciate a fresh reminder of why we do what we do.

-Angela Valenzuela


Ninth-grade ethnic studies helped students for years, Stanford researchers findStanford ReportSeptember 6, 2021

A new study shows that students assigned to an ethnic studies course had longer-term improvements in attendance and graduation rates.


A ninth-grade ethnic studies class has a remarkably prolonged and strong positive impact on students, increasing their overall engagement in school, probability of graduating and likelihood of enrolling in college, according to a new study of a curriculum offered at the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD).




A new Stanford study found that students assigned to an ethnic studies course had longer-term improvements in attendance and graduation rates. (Image credit: Getty Images)

The findings, which follow up on earlier research by two of the authors indicating short-term academic benefits of the course, appeared in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences on Sept. 6.

The study provides “compelling and causally credible evidence on the power of this course to change students’ life trajectories,” said Thomas S. Dee, a professor at Stanford Graduate School of Education (GSE) and senior fellow at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research (SIEPR).

Dee co-authored the study with former GSE doctoral student Sade Bonilla, now an assistant professor at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, and Emily K. Penner, an assistant professor at the University of California at Irvine and former postdoctoral researcher at the GSE.

Lasting gains

The study was done in collaboration with SFUSD as part of a research-practice partnership with the GSE that began in 2009. In 2010, SFUSD launched a pilot program in which students were automatically assigned to an ethnic studies course as their first-year social studies requirement if they had a GPA of 2.0 or less. About nine in 10 were Hispanic, Black or Asian.

In 2017, Dee and Penner published a study showing academic gains at the end of ninth grade (e.g., higher attendance, grade-point averages and credits) among students encouraged to take the course. The researchers weren’t sure the gains would last over time, as countless promising academic interventions fade quickly.

But this one stuck. For one thing, attendance improved: Students who participated in the course came to school more often during their remaining time in high school, for a total of one additional day of school every two weeks.

By their fourth year of high school, the students had also passed six more courses than a comparison group. More than 90 percent graduated within five years, versus 75 percent of their peers. They were also 15 percent more likely to enroll in college within six years. (At the time of the study, they were not yet old enough to graduate college.)

Parallels with psychological interventions

How could one class in ninth grade have such a large effect? While there are many theoretical perspectives on the academic impact of ethnic studies, Dee underscored its parallels with recent insights from social psychology. Targeted psychological interventions that promote a sense of belonging in school, affirm personal values and forewarn about stereotypes have all shown promise in improving student engagement and motivation.

Dee noted that ethnic studies share these features and resemble “an unusually sustained and intensive social-psychological intervention.”

In SFUSD’s ethnic studies class, for example, students examine the role that their ancestors played in history, getting into the experiences of groups that have been literally pushed to the margins of textbooks. They study, in-depth, discrimination against various groups of people based on their race, social group, ethnicity or country of origin.

“The biggest thing that happens in an ethnic studies course, I believe, is that students get to approach an academic course from the perspective of their own experience,” said Bill Sanderson, assistant superintendent of high schools at SFUSD. “Everything is approached in the course from the experience of the students.”

Though the principles of the class remain set, teachers tailor the content to the ethnic and racial communities at their school in order to “to bring relevant curriculum that these students can identify with,” Sanderson said.

Critiquing history cultivated students’ analytical abilities across classes, and the focus on anti-racism catalyzed their idealism. But the work of the course goes far deeper than that, the researchers said.

“There’s long-standing evidence that many historically underserved students experience school environments as unwelcoming, or even hostile,” said Dee. Those in this pilot, particularly, hadn’t done well academically and didn’t feel like they belonged. And ninth grade can be a nerve-wracking, transitional year.

Ethnic studies gave students “the opportunity to see their community reflected in the curriculum,” said Bonilla. Learning about their ancestors’ contributions made them feel proud and made school feel relevant, contributing to a sense of belonging. Learning about oppression and stereotypes in action reminded students that not every failure is an individual’s fault. Students conducted research projects out in the community and connected school with their lives.

Beyond ethnic studies

From there, once a student starts doing well, you’re “starting a stone rolling downhill,” Dee said, catalyzing greater motivation.

“There’s a basis in the science of learning for why courses like this can change students’ learning trajectories,” Dee said. “And if the mechanisms we’re describing are really valid, then this goes well beyond ethnic studies,” encouraging schools to make their teaching culturally relevant across subjects.

Education policymakers have focused recently on “curricula as the low-hanging fruit of education reform,” or something comparatively simple to change, Dee said.

Nevertheless, the results might not be easy to replicate. The district honed the curriculum over several years with faculty at San Francisco State University, home of the nation’s first ethnic studies college program. Many of the initial set of teachers had studied in that department and learned how to manage debate on sensitive subjects, Sanderson said.

Efforts to replicate this success without similar teacher supports and careful implementation are unlikely to be successful, Dee said, and may even trigger unintended and negative consequences. “Consider the potential educational and political fallout of asking teachers to discuss unusually sensitive topics in the classroom without the proper training to do so effectively.”

This is an especially pertinent consideration now, in the middle of a new wave of political controversy about history curriculum. While states and school districts are increasingly adopting requirements and standards for K-12 ethnic studies, some state legislatures are debating bills to ban the 1619 Project or critical race theory, a scholarly academic analysis of structural racism.

SFUSD, for one, isn’t going back. Its board voted this spring to make ethnic studies a high school graduation requirement.

“Ethnic studies is an important part of every young person’s education,” SFUSD board president Gabriela Lopez said in a statement issued by the district in March, which pointed to research showing the curriculum’s impact on GPA across disciplines, high school graduation rates, college-going rates and sense of belonging.


Media Contacts

Thomas S. Dee, Stanford Graduate School of Education: tdee@stanford.edu

Carrie Spector, Stanford Graduate School of Education: cspector@stanford.edu

Monday, October 14, 2024

The Texas Bilingual Education Story: Celebrating our Legacy [video]

Friends, 

Re-posting this video and blog from 2019. History doesn't go stale after all. In contrast, it's very much alive and must be re-told to each generation so that we do not take for granted the sacrifices, wishes, desires, and accomplishments of our forbears to whom we owe so very much. 🙂

-Angela Valenzuela


Thanks to Dr. Rudy Rodriguez who reminds us that 2019 is the 50th anniversary
 of the original Federal ESEA Title VII legislation.  Texas A & M University Professor Carlos Blanton cites the importance of bilingual education to European-origin groups like Czechs, Germans, and Poles in Texas, dispelling the myth that bilingual education was or is only for Latinas/os in Texas.  

Dr. Rodriguez' email correspondence explains the importance of the original Federal ESEA Title VII legislation:

Why is this legislation important???  This federal act provided the impetus for the implementation of the original federally funded 76 bilingual programs in the U.S.  Fort Worth, Houston, San Antonio, El Paso were among the 17 original programs in Texas. It also led states such as Texas to repeal the English-only laws approved as early as 1918. 
In the 1976, the legislation was amended to include federal funds for teacher training, including the fellowships for master’s & doc study in bil ed- related specialty areas.  For more on the history of the legislation & Texas bilingual ed, click video link below: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AWbN_Y8aa5k Please distribute further to interested colleagues.  RudyR Rodriguez

Glad to see the late Senator Carlos Truán, the late Dr, George I. Sanchez,  the late Senator Ralph Yarborough, Maria Seidner, Dr. Guadalupe San Miguel, José Ángel Gutierrez,  Dr. Ángel Noé Gonzalez, Dr. Cuca Robledo Montecel, Dr. María Gonzalez Baker, among others, in the video, too. Crystal City also gets featured as a pivotal point in the bilingual education movement.  The Intercultural Development Research Association (IDRA) is another important institution that has been instrumental in leading the struggle for bilingual education.

You will also hear expressed support for culturally relevant curriculum, too—which is what we term, Ethnic Studies today.  Pride in one's heritage, as well as Spanish language maintenance is what the Mexican American community has sought after forever and a day.

Great video!  Thanks to Rudy Rodriguez for this important reminder of our embattled history for bilingual education.

-Angela Valenzuela


Sunday, February 18, 2024

A Bilingual Educator’s Critique of the Science of Reading (SoR) Movement, by Jill Kerper Mora, Ph.D.

Dr. Jill Kerper Mora is the author of Spanish Language Pedagogy for Biliteracy Programs (2016) and thusly abundantly qualified to critique was is regarded today as the "Science of Reading (SoR)." Currently, an associate professor emeritus at San Diego State University, Dr. Kerper Mora is a credible voice in this contentious debate on literacy considering that she has over 40 years of experience in the field as a teacher, researcher, and scholar in these very areas of literacy, including biliteracy, instruction (also see Bowers, 2020; Johnston & Scanlon, 2021; Reinking, Hruby, & Risko, 2023; Thomas, 2022).

Of great concern to Dr. Kerper Mora is that what is not science at all is actually a movement that politicizes, as opposed to professionalizes, the teaching of reading and writing in schools. She encourages teachers to debunk the false claims of this movement which is particularly led by journalist Emily Hanford.

With respect to multilingual literacy, it is clear that the SoR approach compounds an already flawed model for monolingual speakers of English. Dr. Kerper Mora not only debunks various claims that Hanford and others make, but also draws on research from Spanish-speaking countries to make her case. She further shares this pertinent review of Spanish literacy research as part of her evidentiary base for her detailed response to this arguably harmful, and ill-informed movement.

-Angela Valenzuela

References


Bowers, J. S. (2020). Reconsidering the evidence that systematic phonics is more effective than alternative methods of reading instruction. Educational Psychology Review, 32(3), 681-705. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10648-019-09515-y.pdf


Johnston, P., & Scanlon, D. (2021). An Examination of Dyslexia Research and Instruction With Policy Implications. Literacy Research: Theory, Method, and Practice, 70(1), 107-128. https://doi.org/10.1177/23813377211024625

Mora, J. K. (2016). Spanish language pedagogy for biliteracy programs. Montezuma Publishing. 

Reinking, D., Hruby, G. G., & Risko, V. J. (2023). Legislating Phonics: Settled Science or Political Polemics?. Teachers College Record, 125(1), 104-131.

Thomas, P. (2022). The Science of Reading Movement: The Never-Ending Debate and the Need for a Different Approach to Reading Instruction. National Education Policy Center. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED625611.pdf


Mora, J. K. (2016). Spanish language pedagogy
for biliteracy programs
. Montezuma Publishing.





Science of Reading: A Critique

A Bilingual Educator’s Critique of the Science of Reading Movement

Jill Kerper Mora

The Science of Reading is a hot topic on the internet and in the media these days. A plethora of Facebook groups and other social media venues advertising themselves as Science of Reading for XYZ group of educators have sprung up recently. These groups are drawing considerable interest and lots of members with hundreds of comments daily. One example is a Facebook group that calls itself Science of Reading for Bilingual Education. Many of the posts in this group are by dual language teachers who are seeking information about whether the instructional programs they are using in their classrooms are “Science of Reading-aligned.” These queries reflect a genuine concern among teachers who seek confirmation and validation that their instructional approaches are maximally effective for the students they teach.

The issue with these social media that tout their bilingual credentials is that there is often no way for teachers to verify the bona fide expertise of group administrators or participants who comment in the group on the Science of Reading (SoR) research. This is especially problematic for teachers in dual language programs who implement instruction for bilingual and biliteracy learners. This concern is what prompts me to post this analysis and critique of the SoR. My purpose is to challenge the claims made in these groups by self-proclaimed “experts” regarding the research on literacy instruction in Spanish/English dual language programs. I present this critique of the SoR as it applies to bilingual learners based on my 40 years of experience as a bilingual teacher, teacher educator and researcher.

This analysis makes an important distinction between the Science of Reading and the Science of Reading Movement (SoRM).  Bilingual educators who visit my website do so with trust in my advocacy for biliteracy learners and their teachers, families, and communities. The term Science of Reading is a global descriptor of research from multiple academic disciplines that informs literacy program design and instruction (reading and writing). In and of itself, the term is not problematic. However, determining the extent to which research meets the criteria for claiming that it is “science” or “scientific” very quickly becomes problematic. Much of what is touted as the Science of Reading does not meet the criteria that the research community sets for itself to ensure the credibility and legitimacy of research and the interpretation and application of research findings. A concern is that the term “science” is being used as a cudgel to marginalize and discredit certain theoretical perspectives and bodies of data that have a track record confirming their legitimacy and credibility, while some other research frameworks claim to be “more scientific than thou.” When we go below the surface, we discover misuse and abuse of the notion of scientific research in service of ideological and political agendas. 

Purpose of the Critique of SoR

The purpose of this critique of the Science of Reading is to accomplish the following:

  • Review criteria for judging the legitimacy and credibility of claims made in the name of science.
  • Identify misrepresentations, misinterpretations, and misapplications of scientific research that lead away from, rather than toward, effective literacy instruction.
  • Examine what neuroscience research tells us about the bilingual brain and literacy learning to articulate the implications of bilingual brain research for effective instruction for multilingual learners. 
  • Present the research that documents the “common thread” of metalinguistic skills between decoding and language comprehension that challenges the SoR proponents’ arguments against “cueing” from the applied linguistics and psycholinguistic perspectives on the relationship between the two components of the Simple View of Reading. 
  • Debunk false claims that are unscientific and without a credible evidence base in the research literature made by proponents of the Science of Reading to avoid perpetuating inequities in language and literary education for multilingual learners. 

The format for this analysis is a presentation of a summary of an argument that I make with a link to further elaboration of the argument on a separate webpage. I begin with an analysis of the media’s portrayal of the Science of Reading perspective of the Reading Wars. I elaborate on how journalists are framing an argument around particular teaching strategies for the purpose of promoting fear and distrust of teachers and publishers of instructional programs to promote policies and regulation to mandate more teaching of phonics in the public schools. I present the reasons why this media campaign is detrimental to public education, and specifically to language minority students. I point out that despite claims of “science” as the basis for the policies that the Science of Reading Movement promotes, the media’s portrayal of reading research and the effectiveness, or lack thereof, of certain instructional practices do not qualify as scientific. The SoR Movement seeks to politicize rather than professionalize the teaching of reading and writing in the public schools. The purpose of this analysis is to empower teachers to combat the abuse of the term “science” and to respond with knowledge and expertise to false claims and misrepresented research from the SoR Movement. 

Here I list the related webpages that together present a thorough analysis and critique of the applications of the Science of Reading to language and literacy instruction for multilingual learners. 

Neuroscience Research: Literacy Learning in the Bilingual Brain

Miscue Analysis Research: The Ghost of Whole Language

The Structured Literacy Approach: Implications for Multilingual Learners

Lexical Inferencing: The Truth About Cueing

Science as Metaphor: Debunking the More-Scientific-Than-Thou Argument

Simple View of Reading

Is Reading Natural? A Metalinguistic Perspective

California’s Reading Wars: A Brief History

Science of Reading Legislation: Unconstitutional Laws and Indecipherable Policy

So, without further ado, let us examine together the claims and counterclaims that arise from the new battlefront in the Reading Wars.

CLICK HERE TO CONTINUE READING