In Houston, debate gives way to confrontation of illegal immigrants, their supporters
By JAMES PINKERTON | Houston Chronicle
Nov. 6, 2007
It's become a Saturday morning ritual on a street corner in Spring.
Two dozen U.S. Border Watch volunteers, some wearing combat boots and military-style garb, face off with Hispanic day laborers and a half-dozen of their supporters.
"Stop the hate! Stop the fear! Immigrants are welcome here!" boomed a woman's voice recently over a portable loudspeaker.
"Thou Shall not Steal America," reads a sign waved by a member of Border Watch, a group based in Spring.
A similar scene has unfolded over the past months at the busy intersection of Steubner-Airline and Wimbelton Estates Drive in northwest Harris County. The day laborers, many of them undocumented, gather each morning in the Speedo gas station parking lot.
And nearly every Saturday morning since September, dozens of Border Watch members have attempted to drive them away. They chant slogans, wave signs and film employers who pick up immigrants for work.
Far from the halls of Congress and the front lines of the Southwest border, the divisive immigration debate is being played out in local neighborhoods, including the Houston area. A number of groups have upped the ante by moving from debate to confrontation, attempting to take immigration duties into their own hands.
Since the Minuteman group staged a border surveillance operation in Arizona in 2005, more than 250 new anti-immigrant groups have formed, said Mark Potok, director of Southern Poverty Law Center's intelligence project, which monitors such organizations.
"There's been a prairie fire in the last couple of years — these groups have really exploded," Potok said.
In April, the center listed 144 "Nativist Extremist" organizations that go beyond debate and target individuals, Potok said. There are 13 immigration-related activist groups in Texas, and Border Watch was among three in the Houston area.
"The most significant danger posed by these groups is the poisoning of the democratic debate" about immigration levels, Potok said. Instead, the groups have turned "the discussion into a diatribe about how Mexicans are destroying our culture, bringing diseases to our country and killing dozens of Americans every day," he said.
'It's about being illegal'
The president of Border Watch, Curtis S. Collier, said his members don't have a racist agenda. Their goal is simple: Expel the millions of illegal immigrants in the United States.
"To be racist, you have to target someone because of their race," Collier said. ''We don't care who you are. If you're here illegally we want you to go home. It's not about being brown-skinned, it's about being illegal."
Doris Meissner, who headed the Immigration and Naturalization Service during the Clinton era, said groups such as Border Watch have proliferated due to frustration over the government's inability to control illegal immigration. And while Meissner characterized the groups as "spot outbreaks," she considers them a threat.
"They are dangerous because they do border on vigilante activity," said Meissner, a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute, a think tank based in Washington, D.C.
But groups lobbying for limited immigration see the growing activism differently.
Dan Stein, president of the Federation of Americans for Immigration Reform, said the explosive growth of immigration as a domestic issue — fueled in part by the Internet — and the formation of activist groups was triggered by the Bush administration's failure to crack down on illegal immigration. "It is a truly magnificent populist action, in a way we haven't seen in decades," he said.
They keep close watch
Border Watch was co-founded by Collier, a 47-year-old Spring resident who spent eight years as a U.S. Army policeman before opening a small pest control company. He claims 1,628 members nationwide, with chapters in El Paso, San Antonio and Arkansas. Twice a year, Border Watch tracks illegal immigrants crossing the Texas-Mexico border
Collier, who speaks about border security at events across Texas, repeats claims that 25 Americans citizens are killed each day by undocumented immigrants. Islamic terrorists are slipping across the Southwest border, he says, camouflaged as illegal immigrants.
"There have been reports of Spanish-speaking schools popping up in the Middle East and teaching people in that part of the world to speak Spanish so they can blend in easily," Collier said.
Potok, with the poverty center, said those claims are common to this new breed of anti-illegal immigration activists. ''These are the paranoid fantasies of people with difficulty handling reality," he said.
Border Watch monitors some of what Collier said are 57 day labor sites in the Houston area.
"We do day labor observations ... workplace investigations, undercover operations," Collier said. ''Like, we'll go to day labor sites and pose as employers to figure out if they're here illegally and what their wages are going for."
He has even posted a video on YouTube documenting one of his "investigations."
So when church leaders in the Spring area proposed a center for day workers who use Stuebner-Airline as a gathering place, Collier and his group pounced.
"All hell broke out," recalled pastor Franklin Moore, part of a local-interfaith group working to establish a center.
"All we wanted to do was get a place for day laborers to be safe, to get out of the sun and rain, to get a drink and go to the bathroom," Moore said.
Border Watch volunteers marched on the Chamber of Commerce, and scores of members dominated a September meeting on the proposed center.
After weeks of Saturday demonstrations by Border Watch volunteers, several pro-immigrant organizations have shown up to support the day laborers. One recent Saturday, the two sides again faced off yards apart at the entrance to the Speedo convenience store. Two police cruisers were parked nearby to keep protesters apart.
Facing off on one corner
"Border Watch has been out here for several weeks harassing the day laborers, and we're out here to oppose the racism and harassment," said David Michael Smith, a professor at the College of the Mainland in Texas City. He has helped sponsor protests by the International Socialist Organization and the Progressive Workers Organizing Committee, among others.
Smith's wife, Rona, an elementary school counselor, used a loudspeaker to lead chants. About a dozen day laborers, with nothing to do since only two employers appeared all morning, held up protest signs. ''Racists! Fascists! Hey, hey, Border Watch go away!" Rona chanted.
Collier stood at the head of the Border Watch volunteers and unsuccessfully challenged Smith and his wife to debate. "David, you and Rona look alone over there," he chided.
Soon after the protest began, sheriff's deputies had to intervene when neighbors upset with the noise confronted Rona. With the loudspeaker turned off, confrontations continued.
"You are the real traitors of the country, you are dividing the country. All these people are here to work," shouted Cristobal Hinojosa, with Mexicans in Action, who approached Border Watch volunteers.
The demonstration ended shortly before noon. Moore, the pastor, said both sets of protesters have hurt efforts to find a safe place for day laborers. "It's gotten so convoluted, I don't know how to fix it," he said.
This blog on Texas education contains posts on higher education, as well as preK-12 policy accountability, testing, bilingual education, immigration, school finance, race, class, and gender issues at both the state and national level. It also represents my digital footprint, of life and career, as a community-engaged scholar in Texas.
Saturday, November 10, 2007
What's Going on with High School Dropouts?
No Child Left Behind imposes serious consequences on schools for low test scores, but regarding dropout rates -- where students are literally left behind -- it barely does anything.
Sean Gonsalves | AlterNet
November 6, 2007
The education industry has been abuzz with talk of "dropout factories" in the wake of a recent Johns Hopkins University study that says 12 percent of the nation's high schools have less than 60 percent of its students who start as freshmen and make it to their senior year.
The findings are not too surprising -- students were dropping out at about the same rate a decade ago. But, the attention being given so-called "dropout factories" is important because it underscores a glaring hole in No Child Left Behind law, just as Congress and the White House are wrangling over whether to reauthorize the five-year-old legislation.
"The current law imposes serious consequences on schools that report low scores on math and reading tests, such as having to replace teachers or principals, but it lacks the same kind of teeth when it comes to graduation rates," the AP reports.
The social costs of students not completing high school are steep. Bill Gates Sr., co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation told the United Way of Greater Los Angeles last week, "each year's cohort of dropouts costs us $325 billion in lost wages, taxes, and productivity over their lifetimes. Dropouts are eight times more likely to be in jail or prison than high school graduates. Only a quarter of dropouts vote. The figure for high school graduates is half, and it's three quarters for college graduates."
Counting the cost, Gates is convinced "that solving the high school crisis" is America's "most pressing moral obligation and our most urgent domestic policy priority."
Even as a high school drop-out myself, it's hard to disagree with that, though, as a footnote, a longitudinal study published in the Education Statistics Quarterly indicates "63 percent (of students) who drop out of high school at least once go on to earn a high school diploma or alternative credential within several years, and 43 percent enroll in a postsecondary institution."
Why "dropout?" The fine folks at Gates family foundation actually bothered to survey students about why they chose to leave high school. Nearly half (47 percent) said they left because "classes were not interesting."
Nearly seven in ten -- 69 percent -- said they were "not motivated" or "inspired to work hard," even though two-thirds said they would've worked harder if more was demanded of them.
Many students gave personal reasons for leaving school with 32 percent citing a need for a job or a way to make money; 26 percent said they had kids to support; and another 22 percent said they dropped out to care for a family member.
And check this out: 35 percent said "failing in school" was a major factor for dropping out and 45 percent said they started high school "poorly prepared by their earlier schooling."
The survey ends with a sober observation: "As complex as these individual circumstances may be, for almost all young people, dropping out of high school is not a sudden act, but a gradual process of disengagement; attendance patterns are a clear early sign."
Speaking at a "Dropout Forum" sponsored by the Alliance for Education, Gates Foundation education director Steven Seleznow shared an important insight from the survey. Seleznow said that while making students repeat a grade "makes everybody feel like we've got really tough standards, by and large it destroys the spirit of a student; destroys their inspiration, motivation. And in many cases, if you look at these dropouts, repeating a grade was a big indicator in their decision-making later in high school."
Again, on a purely pragmatic policy level, one of several problems with NCLB is that it punishes schools for low test scores but doesn't effectively address graduation rates. Can't you see the "unintended consequences" coming? As the pressure to avoid being punished for low test scores increases, so too does the pressure to discourage underperforming students to drop out of school.
Testing? All the research I've seen has confirmed what my children have taught me: self-motivated learning is the key to unlocking academic achievement; not coming up with more sophisticated ways of doling out carrots and sticks.
The question isn't: how do we raise test scores? Question is: how do we create schools, not factories, that encourage and enhance students' natural will to learn -- starting long before high school, even before pre-school begins?
Pop quiz: What's more biologically basic than sexual desire? The will to learn. And what's the Latin root for "education?" Educare, which means "to lead out from within."
Sean Gonsalves is a Cape Cod Times staff reporter and a syndicated columnist.
Sean Gonsalves | AlterNet
November 6, 2007
The education industry has been abuzz with talk of "dropout factories" in the wake of a recent Johns Hopkins University study that says 12 percent of the nation's high schools have less than 60 percent of its students who start as freshmen and make it to their senior year.
The findings are not too surprising -- students were dropping out at about the same rate a decade ago. But, the attention being given so-called "dropout factories" is important because it underscores a glaring hole in No Child Left Behind law, just as Congress and the White House are wrangling over whether to reauthorize the five-year-old legislation.
"The current law imposes serious consequences on schools that report low scores on math and reading tests, such as having to replace teachers or principals, but it lacks the same kind of teeth when it comes to graduation rates," the AP reports.
The social costs of students not completing high school are steep. Bill Gates Sr., co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation told the United Way of Greater Los Angeles last week, "each year's cohort of dropouts costs us $325 billion in lost wages, taxes, and productivity over their lifetimes. Dropouts are eight times more likely to be in jail or prison than high school graduates. Only a quarter of dropouts vote. The figure for high school graduates is half, and it's three quarters for college graduates."
Counting the cost, Gates is convinced "that solving the high school crisis" is America's "most pressing moral obligation and our most urgent domestic policy priority."
Even as a high school drop-out myself, it's hard to disagree with that, though, as a footnote, a longitudinal study published in the Education Statistics Quarterly indicates "63 percent (of students) who drop out of high school at least once go on to earn a high school diploma or alternative credential within several years, and 43 percent enroll in a postsecondary institution."
Why "dropout?" The fine folks at Gates family foundation actually bothered to survey students about why they chose to leave high school. Nearly half (47 percent) said they left because "classes were not interesting."
Nearly seven in ten -- 69 percent -- said they were "not motivated" or "inspired to work hard," even though two-thirds said they would've worked harder if more was demanded of them.
Many students gave personal reasons for leaving school with 32 percent citing a need for a job or a way to make money; 26 percent said they had kids to support; and another 22 percent said they dropped out to care for a family member.
And check this out: 35 percent said "failing in school" was a major factor for dropping out and 45 percent said they started high school "poorly prepared by their earlier schooling."
The survey ends with a sober observation: "As complex as these individual circumstances may be, for almost all young people, dropping out of high school is not a sudden act, but a gradual process of disengagement; attendance patterns are a clear early sign."
Speaking at a "Dropout Forum" sponsored by the Alliance for Education, Gates Foundation education director Steven Seleznow shared an important insight from the survey. Seleznow said that while making students repeat a grade "makes everybody feel like we've got really tough standards, by and large it destroys the spirit of a student; destroys their inspiration, motivation. And in many cases, if you look at these dropouts, repeating a grade was a big indicator in their decision-making later in high school."
Again, on a purely pragmatic policy level, one of several problems with NCLB is that it punishes schools for low test scores but doesn't effectively address graduation rates. Can't you see the "unintended consequences" coming? As the pressure to avoid being punished for low test scores increases, so too does the pressure to discourage underperforming students to drop out of school.
Testing? All the research I've seen has confirmed what my children have taught me: self-motivated learning is the key to unlocking academic achievement; not coming up with more sophisticated ways of doling out carrots and sticks.
The question isn't: how do we raise test scores? Question is: how do we create schools, not factories, that encourage and enhance students' natural will to learn -- starting long before high school, even before pre-school begins?
Pop quiz: What's more biologically basic than sexual desire? The will to learn. And what's the Latin root for "education?" Educare, which means "to lead out from within."
Sean Gonsalves is a Cape Cod Times staff reporter and a syndicated columnist.
UT method of teaching teachers is national model
UTeach program recruits math and science majors and gets them in classrooms early.
By Laura Heinauer
AMERICAN-STATESMAN STAFF
Monday, November 05, 2007
Not being all that far removed from grade school themselves, Stephanie Gorss, 19, and Taylor Bethke, 20, two students in a model University of Texas teacher training program, didn't have a tough time coming up with a list of ways to make first-period math at O. Henry Middle School fun.
Pass out dry erase boards to write on instead of paper.
Give lots of positive reinforcement, including heavy use of the word "awesome."
Make paper airplanes.
"I love math. I think it's fun," said Bethke, a math major. "And for me, what has made it even more enjoyable is sparking that interest in kids."
Such words are music to the ears of many who are concerned about the shortage of math and science teachers in the U.S. In the 10 years since the UTeach program began preparing secondary math and science teachers for the classroom, it is revolutionizing how many new math and science teachers will be taught.
"I think we've solved a couple of the problems that have plagued many attempts to prepare teachers for a long time," said Michael Marder, co-director of the UTeach program.
A 2005 report, called Rising above the Gathering Storm: Energizing and Employing America for a Brighter Economic Future, focuses on the need in the U.S. for scientists, engineers and other technically skilled workers to remain competitive in the global marketplace. It specifically mentions UTeach as a model program and recommends that colleges use teaching programs that produce math and science majors with teacher certification — a major departure from how most teachers graduate from college.
In the UTeach program, none of the students are education majors, but rather they major in another field, often in the College of Natural Sciences.
Early recruiting of top natural sciences majors is key. UTeach students have SAT scores that are above the average for the College of Natural Sciences and have higher grade-point averages.
The students are given early and continued field experience. Typical education majors wouldn't visit a classroom until the end of their college career; UTeach students are put in front of a class as freshmen.
"We've come up with a revolutionary idea. And that's that you shouldn't teach if you don't like kids," Marder said.
By comparison, the popular Teach for America program recruits students from all majors and asks participants to commit to two years. But UTeach students leave expecting teaching to be a long-term career.
Since UTeach's inception, the university has doubled the number of math and science teachers that it produces, Marder said.
UTeach teachers also appear to stay in the classroom longer, he said. According to information collected from graduates, about 70 percent of UTeach students are still in the classroom five years after they enter the profession, compared with about 50 percent of teachers nationally.
Because of those numbers, many education experts — particularly those concerned about the country's global competitiveness in math and science — have taken notice.
Already, UTeach-influenced programs have been put in place at Louisiana State University and in California.
And this month, more than 10 unspecified colleges and universities around the country will announce that they are replicating the UTeach program at their campuses, using part of a $125 million grant from Exxon Mobil Corp. They agreed to create programs that basically mirror the UT model.
"It's going to revolutionize things with regards to math and science teacher preparation at these universities," said Tracy LaQuey Parker, director of the UTeach Institute.
O. Henry Principal Peter Price said UTeach teachers stand out because of their deep disciplinary grounding. "They're math and science majors taking very advanced classes, so these students really know the content."
In Bethke and Gorss' class at O. Henry, a chorus of "yessss" and "sweeeet" arose from sixth-graders thrilled with having permission to make paper airplanes.
"Just like there are many ways to fold an airplane," Bethke said, "there are many ways to simplify a fraction."
lheinauer@statesman.com; 445-3694
By Laura Heinauer
AMERICAN-STATESMAN STAFF
Monday, November 05, 2007
Not being all that far removed from grade school themselves, Stephanie Gorss, 19, and Taylor Bethke, 20, two students in a model University of Texas teacher training program, didn't have a tough time coming up with a list of ways to make first-period math at O. Henry Middle School fun.
Pass out dry erase boards to write on instead of paper.
Give lots of positive reinforcement, including heavy use of the word "awesome."
Make paper airplanes.
"I love math. I think it's fun," said Bethke, a math major. "And for me, what has made it even more enjoyable is sparking that interest in kids."
Such words are music to the ears of many who are concerned about the shortage of math and science teachers in the U.S. In the 10 years since the UTeach program began preparing secondary math and science teachers for the classroom, it is revolutionizing how many new math and science teachers will be taught.
"I think we've solved a couple of the problems that have plagued many attempts to prepare teachers for a long time," said Michael Marder, co-director of the UTeach program.
A 2005 report, called Rising above the Gathering Storm: Energizing and Employing America for a Brighter Economic Future, focuses on the need in the U.S. for scientists, engineers and other technically skilled workers to remain competitive in the global marketplace. It specifically mentions UTeach as a model program and recommends that colleges use teaching programs that produce math and science majors with teacher certification — a major departure from how most teachers graduate from college.
In the UTeach program, none of the students are education majors, but rather they major in another field, often in the College of Natural Sciences.
Early recruiting of top natural sciences majors is key. UTeach students have SAT scores that are above the average for the College of Natural Sciences and have higher grade-point averages.
The students are given early and continued field experience. Typical education majors wouldn't visit a classroom until the end of their college career; UTeach students are put in front of a class as freshmen.
"We've come up with a revolutionary idea. And that's that you shouldn't teach if you don't like kids," Marder said.
By comparison, the popular Teach for America program recruits students from all majors and asks participants to commit to two years. But UTeach students leave expecting teaching to be a long-term career.
Since UTeach's inception, the university has doubled the number of math and science teachers that it produces, Marder said.
UTeach teachers also appear to stay in the classroom longer, he said. According to information collected from graduates, about 70 percent of UTeach students are still in the classroom five years after they enter the profession, compared with about 50 percent of teachers nationally.
Because of those numbers, many education experts — particularly those concerned about the country's global competitiveness in math and science — have taken notice.
Already, UTeach-influenced programs have been put in place at Louisiana State University and in California.
And this month, more than 10 unspecified colleges and universities around the country will announce that they are replicating the UTeach program at their campuses, using part of a $125 million grant from Exxon Mobil Corp. They agreed to create programs that basically mirror the UT model.
"It's going to revolutionize things with regards to math and science teacher preparation at these universities," said Tracy LaQuey Parker, director of the UTeach Institute.
O. Henry Principal Peter Price said UTeach teachers stand out because of their deep disciplinary grounding. "They're math and science majors taking very advanced classes, so these students really know the content."
In Bethke and Gorss' class at O. Henry, a chorus of "yessss" and "sweeeet" arose from sixth-graders thrilled with having permission to make paper airplanes.
"Just like there are many ways to fold an airplane," Bethke said, "there are many ways to simplify a fraction."
lheinauer@statesman.com; 445-3694
Carlos Guerra: Spend money on what we know really works for schools, students
Carlos Guerra | Express-News
11/03/2007
Writing about Texas' high dropout rates — and about how inadequate school funding contributes to Texas' big share of this national crisis — always packs my mailbox with messages that echo familiar themes.
And so it was Thursday after a column about a national dropout study conducted by Johns Hopkins University researchers.
Those without a high school diploma will be doomed to a life of poverty because they are likely to be stuck in low-wage jobs with few if any benefits, the researchers pointed out.
That makes sense. As our economy is turned from one based on manufacturing to one based on knowledge and technology, educational attainment and earnings are becoming more closely correlated.
Researchers found that nationally, 40 percent of ninth- or 10th-graders were not enrolled during their senior year in one-fifth of the nation's high schools.
There were such schools in various parts of virtually all states, but these "dropout factories" were most concentrated in the cores of large cities.
And just 15 states — Texas among them — account for 80 percent of these schools, where "graduation is not the norm." There are 182 such high schools in Texas, and 15 of them are in San Antonio.
Generally, they also tend to have high enrollments of poor and minority students.
But the researchers also found other schools with similarly high concentrations that were exceptions. They attributed this to their having adequate resources that were being judiciously expended, highly motivated teachers and cultures of high expectations.
For years, demographers have warned that Texas is headed for a steep economic decline because Latinos and blacks are rapidly outpacing Anglos in population growth. If we do not dramatically improve minorities' graduation rates, they warn, it will result in a major decline in earnings, the ripples of which will be felt by the business sector and government, both of whose revenues will plunge.
Such improvements won't happen, I have pointed out, unless we invest more money on our public education system.
"You don't solve problems by throwing money at them," many readers responded. Several also mentioned "Taj Mahal administrative office buildings" and high-dollar junkets taken by educators and school board members to meetings in exotic locales. Others also wrote about the wastefulness of having so many school districts, since each has its own high-dollar administrative structure.
Still others recalled various scandals involving district officials and administrators.
Fair enough. Education money has been wasted in the past, and school districts have not been immune to corruption or from empire builders.
But let's keep things in perspective and remember that we know that some things do work.
Good teachers are critical, but they are also in high demand.
We also know that smaller classes and schools are also better than larger ones, especially for students who aren't English-proficient, or are poor or have other special needs.
Money must be spent judiciously. But all those things that do work will require more money. It's that simple.
The U.S. Census Bureau's latest "Public School Finances" details educational spending in 2005. Of the $427.2 billion spent nationally, 60.5 percent was spent on instruction and only 7.4 percent was spent on administration. The rest went for support services, such as operations and maintenance, pupil transportation, and instructional staff support.
Only 9.1 percent of the revenue was federal money, while 47 percent was from state governments and 43.9 was local.
But there was a huge disparity in how much states spent per pupil. Utah spent only $5,257 while New York spent $14,119. Nationally, the average was $8,701, but Texas spent $7,267.
Only 12 states spent less.
Are we getting what we are paying for, or paying for something we aren't getting?
11/03/2007
Writing about Texas' high dropout rates — and about how inadequate school funding contributes to Texas' big share of this national crisis — always packs my mailbox with messages that echo familiar themes.
And so it was Thursday after a column about a national dropout study conducted by Johns Hopkins University researchers.
Those without a high school diploma will be doomed to a life of poverty because they are likely to be stuck in low-wage jobs with few if any benefits, the researchers pointed out.
That makes sense. As our economy is turned from one based on manufacturing to one based on knowledge and technology, educational attainment and earnings are becoming more closely correlated.
Researchers found that nationally, 40 percent of ninth- or 10th-graders were not enrolled during their senior year in one-fifth of the nation's high schools.
There were such schools in various parts of virtually all states, but these "dropout factories" were most concentrated in the cores of large cities.
And just 15 states — Texas among them — account for 80 percent of these schools, where "graduation is not the norm." There are 182 such high schools in Texas, and 15 of them are in San Antonio.
Generally, they also tend to have high enrollments of poor and minority students.
But the researchers also found other schools with similarly high concentrations that were exceptions. They attributed this to their having adequate resources that were being judiciously expended, highly motivated teachers and cultures of high expectations.
For years, demographers have warned that Texas is headed for a steep economic decline because Latinos and blacks are rapidly outpacing Anglos in population growth. If we do not dramatically improve minorities' graduation rates, they warn, it will result in a major decline in earnings, the ripples of which will be felt by the business sector and government, both of whose revenues will plunge.
Such improvements won't happen, I have pointed out, unless we invest more money on our public education system.
"You don't solve problems by throwing money at them," many readers responded. Several also mentioned "Taj Mahal administrative office buildings" and high-dollar junkets taken by educators and school board members to meetings in exotic locales. Others also wrote about the wastefulness of having so many school districts, since each has its own high-dollar administrative structure.
Still others recalled various scandals involving district officials and administrators.
Fair enough. Education money has been wasted in the past, and school districts have not been immune to corruption or from empire builders.
But let's keep things in perspective and remember that we know that some things do work.
Good teachers are critical, but they are also in high demand.
We also know that smaller classes and schools are also better than larger ones, especially for students who aren't English-proficient, or are poor or have other special needs.
Money must be spent judiciously. But all those things that do work will require more money. It's that simple.
The U.S. Census Bureau's latest "Public School Finances" details educational spending in 2005. Of the $427.2 billion spent nationally, 60.5 percent was spent on instruction and only 7.4 percent was spent on administration. The rest went for support services, such as operations and maintenance, pupil transportation, and instructional staff support.
Only 9.1 percent of the revenue was federal money, while 47 percent was from state governments and 43.9 was local.
But there was a huge disparity in how much states spent per pupil. Utah spent only $5,257 while New York spent $14,119. Nationally, the average was $8,701, but Texas spent $7,267.
Only 12 states spent less.
Are we getting what we are paying for, or paying for something we aren't getting?
RGV schools labeled ‘dropout factories’
Here's another response to the article: "1 in 10 Schools Are 'Dropout Factories'" Quite different in response than the previous post. -Patricia
Ryan Holeywell and Elizabeth Pierson Hernandez
November 1, 2007 - 10:30PM
McALLEN — Nearly two dozen Rio Grande Valley high schools were labeled “dropout factories” by a national study citing them for having substantially fewer seniors enrolled than freshmen — considered by some to be a telltale sign of dropout problems.
The study, released earlier this week, was commissioned by The Associated Press and conducted by Johns Hopkins University’s Center for Social Organization of Schools.
It analyzed “promotion power” — a comparison of the size of a school’s freshmen class to its senior class three years later. The study’s author said he understood the term “dropout factory” might sound strong, but noted the problem is serious.
The promotion power statistic is a way to approximate how many freshmen left the school by their senior years. Schools were labeled “dropout factories” if, over three years, the size of the senior class averaged 60 percent or less of the freshman class from three years earlier.
Sofia Valdez, an education professor at the University of Texas-Pan American and member of Grupo Poder, the Pharr-San Juan-Alamo schools watchdog organization, said the study underscores an issue of which most educators are well aware.
“It’s a complex problem with many stakeholders,” Valdez said. “It’s not just the parents. It’s not just the schools. It’s not just the community.”
‘Disheartening’
The Texas Education Agency and some local school districts, however, said the study’s figures don’t tell the whole story.
Debbie Graves Ratcliffe, TEA’s director of communications, acknowledges that Texas, with a graduation rate of just 61 percent, does have a problem with students dropping out of school. Almost 18 percent of the state’s 1,040 high schools were tagged with the “dropout factory” designation in the Johns Hopkins study.
But Ratcliffe said the numbers don’t take into account Texas students’ high mobility rate. About 17 to 19 percent of students are considered transient, meaning they transfer to another school system within the state or out of state, she said.
Some Valley school officials said the report also contradicts feedback they have received from state and federal education officials who study more precise data than the Johns Hopkins report did.
Harlingen schools Superintendent Linda Wade said the report is misleading because it does not track individual students, unlike data the district sends to the state. Harlingen High School and Harlingen High School South were both named in the report.
The most recent data Wade has shows more than 88 percent of students either finished in four years or continued at the district to pursue a degree after four years, she said.
“It gives a false image to the public of what’s going on in our schools, and it’s disheartening to those of us who work in the schools,” she said.
McAllen Superintendent Yolanda Chapa agreed.
“It makes it seem as though our primary function is producing dropouts. We have many outstanding students who go through our system; they graduate and go on to greater things.”
However, she said the district realizes there is a problem and is working on increase its graduation rate.
“We have implemented many programs designed to curb our dropout population,” she said.
'Kind of unfair'
All five Brownsville high schools made the list.
Raul Vasquez, administrator for assessment, research and evaluation at the district, said district officials have figured a more precise drop-out rate that is closer to 14 percent.
On Thursday, Vasquez said he had not looked at the study. But that when district officials figure their drop-out rate, they consider who moves, finishes high school elsewhere, even who dies before graduating — all factors the Johns Hopkins study didn’t consider.
Mary Maushard, a spokeswoman for the center that conducted the study, said that argument doesn’t necessarily explain the problem with dropouts in the Valley, especially since the area is rapidly growing.
Craig Verley, a spokesman for the Mission school district, of which Veterans Memorial High School was ranked on the list, noted the Valley is home to a significant migrant laborer population. He reiterated that the study was “kind of unfair” since it didn’t examine why students left school.
He said the district focuses on enrolling dropouts at the beginning of the school year and is now focusing on improving the teacher-to-student ratio in ninth grade, which is critical to a student’s success.
PSJA Superintendent Daniel King said comparing enrollment figures of freshmen to seniors isn’t a perfect way to study dropouts, largely because of a statistical anomaly that artificially inflates the size of a freshman class. Students who enter high school and don’t advance are classified as freshmen, regardless of their age.
But he said he didn’t want to make excuses, either.
“I think we have to admit we have a problem,” King said, noting his district has created programs to try to re-enroll dropouts through partnership programs with South Texas College.
Simply a guideline
Officials at South Texas Independent School District — the state’s only all-magnet school district and widely respected for its students’ academic performance — took issue with the inclusion of two of their high schools on the list.
“They used a very simplistic methodology,” said Andi Atkinson, the district’s marketing specialist.
The district’s Science Academy of South Texas (Sci Tech) and South Texas Business, Education & Technology Academy (BETA) were listed in the university’s report. Figures Atkinson provided showed most of the losses were due to students returning to home districts, moving or entering private school.
Maushard, of Johns Hopkins, said the study strictly focused on enrollment figures because, unlike graduation rates, all districts compile those figures in the same consistent manner.
The study identified specific schools so policymakers and administrators would know where to focus their efforts, she said.
____
Monitor Staff Writer Jennifer L. Berghom contributed to this report.
____
Ryan Holeywell covers PSJA and general assignments for The Monitor. He can be reached at (956) 683-4446.
____
Elizabeth Pierson Hernandez covers the state capital for Valley Freedom Newspapers. She is based in Austin and can be reached at (512) 323-0622.
Ryan Holeywell and Elizabeth Pierson Hernandez
November 1, 2007 - 10:30PM
McALLEN — Nearly two dozen Rio Grande Valley high schools were labeled “dropout factories” by a national study citing them for having substantially fewer seniors enrolled than freshmen — considered by some to be a telltale sign of dropout problems.
The study, released earlier this week, was commissioned by The Associated Press and conducted by Johns Hopkins University’s Center for Social Organization of Schools.
It analyzed “promotion power” — a comparison of the size of a school’s freshmen class to its senior class three years later. The study’s author said he understood the term “dropout factory” might sound strong, but noted the problem is serious.
The promotion power statistic is a way to approximate how many freshmen left the school by their senior years. Schools were labeled “dropout factories” if, over three years, the size of the senior class averaged 60 percent or less of the freshman class from three years earlier.
Sofia Valdez, an education professor at the University of Texas-Pan American and member of Grupo Poder, the Pharr-San Juan-Alamo schools watchdog organization, said the study underscores an issue of which most educators are well aware.
“It’s a complex problem with many stakeholders,” Valdez said. “It’s not just the parents. It’s not just the schools. It’s not just the community.”
‘Disheartening’
The Texas Education Agency and some local school districts, however, said the study’s figures don’t tell the whole story.
Debbie Graves Ratcliffe, TEA’s director of communications, acknowledges that Texas, with a graduation rate of just 61 percent, does have a problem with students dropping out of school. Almost 18 percent of the state’s 1,040 high schools were tagged with the “dropout factory” designation in the Johns Hopkins study.
But Ratcliffe said the numbers don’t take into account Texas students’ high mobility rate. About 17 to 19 percent of students are considered transient, meaning they transfer to another school system within the state or out of state, she said.
Some Valley school officials said the report also contradicts feedback they have received from state and federal education officials who study more precise data than the Johns Hopkins report did.
Harlingen schools Superintendent Linda Wade said the report is misleading because it does not track individual students, unlike data the district sends to the state. Harlingen High School and Harlingen High School South were both named in the report.
The most recent data Wade has shows more than 88 percent of students either finished in four years or continued at the district to pursue a degree after four years, she said.
“It gives a false image to the public of what’s going on in our schools, and it’s disheartening to those of us who work in the schools,” she said.
McAllen Superintendent Yolanda Chapa agreed.
“It makes it seem as though our primary function is producing dropouts. We have many outstanding students who go through our system; they graduate and go on to greater things.”
However, she said the district realizes there is a problem and is working on increase its graduation rate.
“We have implemented many programs designed to curb our dropout population,” she said.
'Kind of unfair'
All five Brownsville high schools made the list.
Raul Vasquez, administrator for assessment, research and evaluation at the district, said district officials have figured a more precise drop-out rate that is closer to 14 percent.
On Thursday, Vasquez said he had not looked at the study. But that when district officials figure their drop-out rate, they consider who moves, finishes high school elsewhere, even who dies before graduating — all factors the Johns Hopkins study didn’t consider.
Mary Maushard, a spokeswoman for the center that conducted the study, said that argument doesn’t necessarily explain the problem with dropouts in the Valley, especially since the area is rapidly growing.
Craig Verley, a spokesman for the Mission school district, of which Veterans Memorial High School was ranked on the list, noted the Valley is home to a significant migrant laborer population. He reiterated that the study was “kind of unfair” since it didn’t examine why students left school.
He said the district focuses on enrolling dropouts at the beginning of the school year and is now focusing on improving the teacher-to-student ratio in ninth grade, which is critical to a student’s success.
PSJA Superintendent Daniel King said comparing enrollment figures of freshmen to seniors isn’t a perfect way to study dropouts, largely because of a statistical anomaly that artificially inflates the size of a freshman class. Students who enter high school and don’t advance are classified as freshmen, regardless of their age.
But he said he didn’t want to make excuses, either.
“I think we have to admit we have a problem,” King said, noting his district has created programs to try to re-enroll dropouts through partnership programs with South Texas College.
Simply a guideline
Officials at South Texas Independent School District — the state’s only all-magnet school district and widely respected for its students’ academic performance — took issue with the inclusion of two of their high schools on the list.
“They used a very simplistic methodology,” said Andi Atkinson, the district’s marketing specialist.
The district’s Science Academy of South Texas (Sci Tech) and South Texas Business, Education & Technology Academy (BETA) were listed in the university’s report. Figures Atkinson provided showed most of the losses were due to students returning to home districts, moving or entering private school.
Maushard, of Johns Hopkins, said the study strictly focused on enrollment figures because, unlike graduation rates, all districts compile those figures in the same consistent manner.
The study identified specific schools so policymakers and administrators would know where to focus their efforts, she said.
____
Monitor Staff Writer Jennifer L. Berghom contributed to this report.
____
Ryan Holeywell covers PSJA and general assignments for The Monitor. He can be reached at (956) 683-4446.
____
Elizabeth Pierson Hernandez covers the state capital for Valley Freedom Newspapers. She is based in Austin and can be reached at (512) 323-0622.
PRESIDENT SIGNS COLLEGE COST REDUCTION ACT LAW PROVIDES LARGEST STUDENT AID INCREASE SINCE GI BILL
By White House | Daily EdNews
11/1/2007
mplementing a proposal from his 2008 budget plan, President George W. Bush on Sept. 27 signed into law the largest increase in federal student aid since the GI Bill of 1944. The College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007 increases funding for the Federal Pell Grant Program by $11.4 billion over the next five years, raising the maximum annual award to $5,400 by 2012. Unlike loans, Pell grants do not have to be repaid. More than 5 million low-income students receive this federal financial aid annually.
"Pell grants send an important message to students in need: If you work hard, and you stay in school, and you make the right choices, the federal government is going to stand with you," said President Bush.
The legislation also makes it easier to repay loans, by:
· Capping loan payments so that borrowers would not have to devote more than 15 percent of their discretionary income to repaying Stafford student loans. Starting July 1, 2009, this applies to both subsidized and unsubsidized Stafford loans, regardless of when the loans were taken out. After 25 years, any remaining balances will be cancelled.
· Forgiving loans for borrowers working in public-sector jobs—such as those held by members of the military, law enforcement agents, firefighters, nurses, librarians and early childhood teachers—after 10 years of service and loan repayment. Furthermore, students serving in the National Reserve who are called to address a national crisis will be able to defer loan payments for up to 13 months at the end of their service.
In addition, the bill may provide tuition assistance of up to $4,000 per year—for a total of $16,000—to undergraduate and graduate students who commit to teaching certain subjects, such as science and math, in low-income public schools for at least four years.
11/1/2007
mplementing a proposal from his 2008 budget plan, President George W. Bush on Sept. 27 signed into law the largest increase in federal student aid since the GI Bill of 1944. The College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007 increases funding for the Federal Pell Grant Program by $11.4 billion over the next five years, raising the maximum annual award to $5,400 by 2012. Unlike loans, Pell grants do not have to be repaid. More than 5 million low-income students receive this federal financial aid annually.
"Pell grants send an important message to students in need: If you work hard, and you stay in school, and you make the right choices, the federal government is going to stand with you," said President Bush.
The legislation also makes it easier to repay loans, by:
· Capping loan payments so that borrowers would not have to devote more than 15 percent of their discretionary income to repaying Stafford student loans. Starting July 1, 2009, this applies to both subsidized and unsubsidized Stafford loans, regardless of when the loans were taken out. After 25 years, any remaining balances will be cancelled.
· Forgiving loans for borrowers working in public-sector jobs—such as those held by members of the military, law enforcement agents, firefighters, nurses, librarians and early childhood teachers—after 10 years of service and loan repayment. Furthermore, students serving in the National Reserve who are called to address a national crisis will be able to defer loan payments for up to 13 months at the end of their service.
In addition, the bill may provide tuition assistance of up to $4,000 per year—for a total of $16,000—to undergraduate and graduate students who commit to teaching certain subjects, such as science and math, in low-income public schools for at least four years.
Youngest inmates tend to serve longer terms in juvenile prisons
I question if communities really are giving up on these youths, or if those communities are left with little, if any, support or means to devise solutions. Sometimes the solution at the local level is to increase policing in these communities, creating yet another layer of problems often left unaddressed. I'm sure those who are members of these communities are familiar with this. -Patricia
The Associated Press | The Houston Chronicle
Nov. 1, 2007
MART, Texas — Juvenile felons sentenced to the Texas Youth Commission at ages 10 to 13 tend to serve longer terms than their older counterparts, according to a newspaper review of agency records.
For the past three years, offenders who start their sentences at ages 10 to 13 have served an average of 34 months. That's 15 months longer than the average term for inmates sentenced at ages 14 to 17, according to the review by the San Antonio Express-News and Houston Chronicle.
Inmates arriving at ages 16 and 17 served terms averaging no more than 18 months. Those who started at age 10, the youngest possible, served an average of five years, according to the records. Some of the older offenders were released because they turned 21, the former mandatory age of release.
Critics blame the longer terms on the difficulty for younger children of completing the system's resocialization program required for release.
"It's so difficult for the smaller kids," said Will Harrell, TYC's youth advocate. "They're supposed to come up with a life story. How much of a life story can you articulate at 11 years of age? They don't have the cognitive abilities."
Commission officials said new reforms will make it easier for inmates to secure their release after serving their minimum sentence.
"The burden of proof is now on us to show why this offender should remain in custody," spokesman Tim Savoy said.
Also, the commission is changing its treatment approach in a way that will distinguish between younger and older offenders. A new program aimed at 10- to 13-year-olds is part of an agency overhaul mandated by state leaders in response to a sex abuse scandal.
The agency plans to confine the younger boys, who make up a relatively small part of the overall inmate population, in a single facility, away from the older inmates. The agency is taking bids from private contractors for "a safe residential setting" for boys ages 10 to 13.
Robert E. Morris, a pediatrics professor at the University of California at Los Angeles, said young offenders shouldn't be separated from their families, almost regardless of the crime.
"You do need your folks more at such a young age," said Morris, a leading national expert on adolescent offenders. "Most kids would do better to just go home and perhaps be monitored by a probation officer," with services provided to their families.
Forrest Novy, TYC's director of special education, said it would be good to place the youngest offenders in community-based programs close to home, but those communities have often given up on the offenders. And the correctional system needs to centralize services.
"The downside is they're so far from home," Novy said.
Novy said it will take months to implement the new treatment program for young offenders.
The agency will start rolling out a new resocialization program for all offenders, called CoNEXTions, in December.
The Associated Press | The Houston Chronicle
Nov. 1, 2007
MART, Texas — Juvenile felons sentenced to the Texas Youth Commission at ages 10 to 13 tend to serve longer terms than their older counterparts, according to a newspaper review of agency records.
For the past three years, offenders who start their sentences at ages 10 to 13 have served an average of 34 months. That's 15 months longer than the average term for inmates sentenced at ages 14 to 17, according to the review by the San Antonio Express-News and Houston Chronicle.
Inmates arriving at ages 16 and 17 served terms averaging no more than 18 months. Those who started at age 10, the youngest possible, served an average of five years, according to the records. Some of the older offenders were released because they turned 21, the former mandatory age of release.
Critics blame the longer terms on the difficulty for younger children of completing the system's resocialization program required for release.
"It's so difficult for the smaller kids," said Will Harrell, TYC's youth advocate. "They're supposed to come up with a life story. How much of a life story can you articulate at 11 years of age? They don't have the cognitive abilities."
Commission officials said new reforms will make it easier for inmates to secure their release after serving their minimum sentence.
"The burden of proof is now on us to show why this offender should remain in custody," spokesman Tim Savoy said.
Also, the commission is changing its treatment approach in a way that will distinguish between younger and older offenders. A new program aimed at 10- to 13-year-olds is part of an agency overhaul mandated by state leaders in response to a sex abuse scandal.
The agency plans to confine the younger boys, who make up a relatively small part of the overall inmate population, in a single facility, away from the older inmates. The agency is taking bids from private contractors for "a safe residential setting" for boys ages 10 to 13.
Robert E. Morris, a pediatrics professor at the University of California at Los Angeles, said young offenders shouldn't be separated from their families, almost regardless of the crime.
"You do need your folks more at such a young age," said Morris, a leading national expert on adolescent offenders. "Most kids would do better to just go home and perhaps be monitored by a probation officer," with services provided to their families.
Forrest Novy, TYC's director of special education, said it would be good to place the youngest offenders in community-based programs close to home, but those communities have often given up on the offenders. And the correctional system needs to centralize services.
"The downside is they're so far from home," Novy said.
Novy said it will take months to implement the new treatment program for young offenders.
The agency will start rolling out a new resocialization program for all offenders, called CoNEXTions, in December.
Our dropout factories aren’t found in schools
The following is a response to an earlier article: "1 in 10 Schools Are 'Dropout Factories'," which you can also access from this blog. It's unfortunate to see the language used in this response, and for parent's "lack of support" being targeted as the cause of student dropout rates. -Patricia
By Chris Lykins | The Gazette-Enterprise
Published November 2, 2007
A national study that branded 1,700 schools in this country as “dropout factories” got a lot of attention from the media this week.
It got a lot of attention here as well, because Seguin High School made the list.
The designation did not sit well with superintendent Irene Garza who said the study ignores students who move to other schools as well as students pulled out for homeschooling or those who go into an alternative program for a GED.
Garza’s not alone. Those criticisms have been common all across the country.
Beyond the study’s numbers — which are so far removed from the Texas Education Agency’s dropout statistics as to render them almost laughable — is the use of mechanical and inflammatory language.
Factory? As if these children are robots, identical mechanisms wheeled in as blameless, perfect creations only to be dented, distorted and destroyed by an educational assembly line.
If there is a “dropout factory” you won’t find it behind the walls of Seguin High School — or any other school in the country.
You’ll find it at home.
If you want to blame the nation’s education system, there are plenty of valid reasons.
It has produced borderline functionally-illiterate students who don’t know where the Pacific Ocean is, can’t balance their own checkbooks and think that Louis Armstrong landed on the moon.
That’s all fair game.
However, over the last few decades it’s become increasingly easy to just heap all of society’s ills at the feet of school districts.
Teen pregnancy, drug abuse, violence and obesity aren’t things created by schools, they are created at home and shipped off every day to become the school district’s problem.
A school district never got a girl pregnant, beat someone to a pulp or drove a group of friends to the lake to get high.
The public education system is not there to be a babysitter, a surrogate parent or a warden, it is there to try and provide the children with the necessary tools and education to become successful adults.
They can’t do it alone — and too often they are being asked to.
The most successful schools are those that have parents involved at every level — and most importantly — parents that support the school’s efforts.
There is nothing more damaging than having a parent constantly undercutting a school.
“Well, I don’t think the teacher likes him” — while ignoring the fact that the kid is a royal pain when he’s at home. What makes you think he’s different from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.?
“Well, if they would spend more time with her she wouldn’t be behind” — while ignoring the fact that she spends two hours on the phone every night talking about the color of lip gloss she plans on wearing tomorrow instead of doing her homework.
Are there bad teachers? Yes.
There are also bad garbage men, bad waiters and waitresses, bad doctors, bad police officers and bad presidents.
If there is a “dropout factory,” it starts in the living rooms and dining rooms of the community’s homes — not in the classrooms at any high school.
It’s time for parents and the rest of us who deal with children on a regular basis to stop making excuses for their failings by blaming our failings on someone else.
It’s time to close the factory.
Chris Lykins is the managing editor of the Seguin Gazette-Enterprise.
By Chris Lykins | The Gazette-Enterprise
Published November 2, 2007
A national study that branded 1,700 schools in this country as “dropout factories” got a lot of attention from the media this week.
It got a lot of attention here as well, because Seguin High School made the list.
The designation did not sit well with superintendent Irene Garza who said the study ignores students who move to other schools as well as students pulled out for homeschooling or those who go into an alternative program for a GED.
Garza’s not alone. Those criticisms have been common all across the country.
Beyond the study’s numbers — which are so far removed from the Texas Education Agency’s dropout statistics as to render them almost laughable — is the use of mechanical and inflammatory language.
Factory? As if these children are robots, identical mechanisms wheeled in as blameless, perfect creations only to be dented, distorted and destroyed by an educational assembly line.
If there is a “dropout factory” you won’t find it behind the walls of Seguin High School — or any other school in the country.
You’ll find it at home.
If you want to blame the nation’s education system, there are plenty of valid reasons.
It has produced borderline functionally-illiterate students who don’t know where the Pacific Ocean is, can’t balance their own checkbooks and think that Louis Armstrong landed on the moon.
That’s all fair game.
However, over the last few decades it’s become increasingly easy to just heap all of society’s ills at the feet of school districts.
Teen pregnancy, drug abuse, violence and obesity aren’t things created by schools, they are created at home and shipped off every day to become the school district’s problem.
A school district never got a girl pregnant, beat someone to a pulp or drove a group of friends to the lake to get high.
The public education system is not there to be a babysitter, a surrogate parent or a warden, it is there to try and provide the children with the necessary tools and education to become successful adults.
They can’t do it alone — and too often they are being asked to.
The most successful schools are those that have parents involved at every level — and most importantly — parents that support the school’s efforts.
There is nothing more damaging than having a parent constantly undercutting a school.
“Well, I don’t think the teacher likes him” — while ignoring the fact that the kid is a royal pain when he’s at home. What makes you think he’s different from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.?
“Well, if they would spend more time with her she wouldn’t be behind” — while ignoring the fact that she spends two hours on the phone every night talking about the color of lip gloss she plans on wearing tomorrow instead of doing her homework.
Are there bad teachers? Yes.
There are also bad garbage men, bad waiters and waitresses, bad doctors, bad police officers and bad presidents.
If there is a “dropout factory,” it starts in the living rooms and dining rooms of the community’s homes — not in the classrooms at any high school.
It’s time for parents and the rest of us who deal with children on a regular basis to stop making excuses for their failings by blaming our failings on someone else.
It’s time to close the factory.
Chris Lykins is the managing editor of the Seguin Gazette-Enterprise.
Kids Joining Parent-Teacher Conferences

In Image: Fifth grade student Melinda Guzman, second from left, talks about her reading with teacher Laurie Humphrey, right, as her mother Yoli Guzman, left, and student teacher Rebecca Anshell, center, look, during a parent-teacher conference held at Halecrest Elementary School in Chula Vista, Calif. Monday, Oct. 29, 2007. (AP Photo/Denis Poroy)
By NANCY ZUCKERBROD | Associated Press
Nov 1, 2007
WASHINGTON (AP) — It's that time of year when moms and dads across the country are squeezing into uncomfortable kid-sized chairs to discuss with teachers whether their children are off to a good start at school. In some places, the conference comes with a wrinkle: The children sit in.
Marguerite Izzo, who teaches fifth grade in Malverne, N.Y., said including students makes kids more accountable for their work and behavior, and ensures that things do not get lost in translation.
"People get different stories," she said. "This alleviates all of that."
Joyce Epstein, director of the Center on School, Family and Community Partnerships at Johns Hopkins University, agrees.
"These are good directions in conferencing because it really lets people know this is not a game of telephone," Epstein said.
The trend is a response to research showing that parents are more likely to attend a conference if their child also has to come, and to studies showing that students benefit from setting goals, she said.
Karen Ernst, a mother of three in Palatine, Ill., likes the new approach. But she says it is important to prepare kids and let them know what is expected. "They can get very shy," said Ernst, whose children range in age from 12 to 17.
Ernst talks with her children before a conference and explains that no one else will be in the room so they do not have to worry about privacy. She reminds them that the session is a rare opportunity for personal attention.
"They never get that moment with their teachers' ear ... without three other kids wanting her ear too," she said.
Being prepared for a parent-teacher conference is important regardless of whether children are included, said Columbia University Teachers College professor Frances Schoonmaker.
Parents without ready questions could lose out on a chance to gain valuable information, Schoonmaker said. Similarly, she said, parents should share information about their kids with the teacher.
"It's this idea that I have a piece of the puzzle and you have a piece the puzzle. Now, how can we work together?" she said.
Schoonmaker urges parents to refrain from becoming defensive and to think of conferences as opportunities.
"When they work, they are absolutely valuable," she said. "When they don't work, everybody is absolutely frustrated."
Kathy Ely, whose daughter is a freshman in high school, said she prepares by talking with her daughter first.
"I'll say to my daughter, 'I'm going next week, are there any things that are bothering you?'" said Ely, of Silver Spring, Md.
Ely said when there are no obvious problems, she tries to ask questions that might reveal new information. "There's always something to talk about and you shouldn't just approach it like, well, good grades — nothing to deal with."
Laurie Humphrey, an elementary school teacher in Chula Vista, Calif., sends letters home ahead of conferences to let parents know what will be addressed. She said that helps make sure parents are prepared.
Humphrey advises parents to ask whether their child is working at the proper grade level and whether they can see any test results. It also is important to ask how a child fits in socially, even if teachers are sometimes less comfortable talking about that.
She said parents should not be caught off guard if they get tough questions from teachers. She asks whether parents read to their children or read in front of children to show that it is a worthwhile activity.
"Sometimes they'll laugh, and say, 'I really don't,' Humphrey said. She said that kind of conversation, though sometimes awkward, can lead to important changes.
Not all teachers have the skills or confidence to do that; many can get nervous at conference time.
"I honestly think it's the part of the profession that teachers tiptoe around because you're never sure how to approach a parent, especially if the news isn't that good," said Rosalind LaRocque, assistant director of the educational issues department at the American Federation of Teachers.
Despite that, educators appear to be working to strengthen parent-teacher conferences by trying new things such as letting students come along. Schools also are increasingly offering baby-sitting during conferences, providing flexible scheduling and making translators available. More than a dozen states let employers know they are expected to allow their workers to attend conferences.
Regular conferences are more common in the early grades than in secondary schools. Typically they take place in the fall and spring, or around report card time.
Humphrey, interviewed recently by phone as she was getting ready for conferences, said she thinks conferences at the start of the year are especially important.
"Building a relationship with the parents from the first day of school is something I really try hard to work at," she said, adding that it can be a challenge to affect a student's learning process. "It's even more difficult without the parents buying in."
Johns Hopkins Center on School, Family, and Community Partnerships: http://www.csos.jhu.edu/P2000/center.htm
Friday, November 09, 2007
Texas study finds 39 model high schools in math, science
I think information on the fallen number of students who took the TAKS over time within these schools might give more insight on the "significant gains" indicated. -Patricia
Common traits include larger class sizes, more certified teachers
TERRENCE STUTZ / The Dallas Morning News
October 31, 2007
AUSTIN – A select group of Texas high schools – including eight in the Dallas area – is chalking up impressive results in math and science by utilizing slightly larger classes and paying teachers in those subjects more money than other teachers, according to a report released Wednesday.
The study by the Texas Public Policy Foundation, a conservative think tank, examined scores on several major tests – the TAKS, ACT, SAT and Advanced Placement exams – to come up with 39 high schools that have been largely successful in teaching math and science to their students.
Many of the schools have a large percentage of low-income students and enrollments range from rural and small (148 pupils) to urban and very large (4,872 pupils).
Researchers for the foundation, which is influential with state Republican leaders, conducted the study to identify the "best practices" that the high schools have in common so they can be shared with other schools.
Citing lackluster math and science performance in Texas high schools, the report said it is fortunate that "a number of Texas high schools are shining examples of places where students are achieving success in math and science."
Using standardized test and college entrance exam data from the Texas Education Agency, researchers noted that the 39 schools not only scored well in math and science, but also demonstrated "significant gains" over time. A total of 28 campuses were cited for math achievement and 29 for science achievement – including 18 that did well in both subjects.
Jamie Story, lead researcher, said the test score results also were adjusted for student body demographics, percentage of limited English-speaking students and geographic location. One of the "best practice" high schools has a student body that is nearly 85 percent low income.
Two Dallas high schools on the list – Carter and Wilson – have student bodies that are about 55 percent low income. Turner High School in Carrollton, also on the list, is 56 percent low income.
Among the common characteristics of the 39 best practice schools are:
•Class size – all had slightly larger classes in math and science – about 10 percent more students – than the average high school class in those subjects. That translated into an extra two to three students per class.
•Teacher pay – Math and science teachers at best practice schools typically earned about $3,000 a year more than other teachers at their schools. School districts paid those supplements using incentive pay or special stipend programs.
•Teacher certification – all had a high percentage of teachers certified in math and science. Only 3.8 percent of math teachers were teaching out of their field – compared with 14.3 percent statewide – and only 1 percent of science teachers were out of field – compared with 28 percent statewide.
•Spending per student – The best practice schools annually spent an average of $994 per student less than the state average – cited in the study as $7,229. The schools also spent more of their funds on instruction (68.4 percent) than the statewide average (57.8 percent).
•TAKS preparation – time spent preparing for the annual Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills was about half that of the average school in Texas. Best practice schools also targeted TAKS preparation to low-performing students.
The foundation also made a series of recommendations that researchers said can be implemented by school districts under current law. They included greater use of stipends to pay math and science teachers, and new district policies that reduce the amount of class time spent on TAKS preparation.
Richard Kouri of the Texas State Teachers Association said the finding that most of the schools have a high percentage of certified math and science teachers may be the most critical of all the best practices cited in the report.
"It all starts with having certified math and science teachers," he said.
BEST PRACTICE HIGH SCHOOLS, DALLAS AREA
School, District, Subject
Carter, Dallas, Math
Science & Engineering, Dallas, Math
Wilson, Dallas, Science
Creekview, Carrollton-FB, Math
Turner, Carrollton-FB, Math and Science
Berkner, Richardson, Science
Richardson, Richardson, Math and Science
Lewisville, Lewisville, Math
*Based on test scores on TAKS, ACT, SAT and AP exams
SOURCE: Texas Public Policy Foundation
Common traits include larger class sizes, more certified teachers
TERRENCE STUTZ / The Dallas Morning News
October 31, 2007
AUSTIN – A select group of Texas high schools – including eight in the Dallas area – is chalking up impressive results in math and science by utilizing slightly larger classes and paying teachers in those subjects more money than other teachers, according to a report released Wednesday.
The study by the Texas Public Policy Foundation, a conservative think tank, examined scores on several major tests – the TAKS, ACT, SAT and Advanced Placement exams – to come up with 39 high schools that have been largely successful in teaching math and science to their students.
Many of the schools have a large percentage of low-income students and enrollments range from rural and small (148 pupils) to urban and very large (4,872 pupils).
Researchers for the foundation, which is influential with state Republican leaders, conducted the study to identify the "best practices" that the high schools have in common so they can be shared with other schools.
Citing lackluster math and science performance in Texas high schools, the report said it is fortunate that "a number of Texas high schools are shining examples of places where students are achieving success in math and science."
Using standardized test and college entrance exam data from the Texas Education Agency, researchers noted that the 39 schools not only scored well in math and science, but also demonstrated "significant gains" over time. A total of 28 campuses were cited for math achievement and 29 for science achievement – including 18 that did well in both subjects.
Jamie Story, lead researcher, said the test score results also were adjusted for student body demographics, percentage of limited English-speaking students and geographic location. One of the "best practice" high schools has a student body that is nearly 85 percent low income.
Two Dallas high schools on the list – Carter and Wilson – have student bodies that are about 55 percent low income. Turner High School in Carrollton, also on the list, is 56 percent low income.
Among the common characteristics of the 39 best practice schools are:
•Class size – all had slightly larger classes in math and science – about 10 percent more students – than the average high school class in those subjects. That translated into an extra two to three students per class.
•Teacher pay – Math and science teachers at best practice schools typically earned about $3,000 a year more than other teachers at their schools. School districts paid those supplements using incentive pay or special stipend programs.
•Teacher certification – all had a high percentage of teachers certified in math and science. Only 3.8 percent of math teachers were teaching out of their field – compared with 14.3 percent statewide – and only 1 percent of science teachers were out of field – compared with 28 percent statewide.
•Spending per student – The best practice schools annually spent an average of $994 per student less than the state average – cited in the study as $7,229. The schools also spent more of their funds on instruction (68.4 percent) than the statewide average (57.8 percent).
•TAKS preparation – time spent preparing for the annual Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills was about half that of the average school in Texas. Best practice schools also targeted TAKS preparation to low-performing students.
The foundation also made a series of recommendations that researchers said can be implemented by school districts under current law. They included greater use of stipends to pay math and science teachers, and new district policies that reduce the amount of class time spent on TAKS preparation.
Richard Kouri of the Texas State Teachers Association said the finding that most of the schools have a high percentage of certified math and science teachers may be the most critical of all the best practices cited in the report.
"It all starts with having certified math and science teachers," he said.
BEST PRACTICE HIGH SCHOOLS, DALLAS AREA
School, District, Subject
Carter, Dallas, Math
Science & Engineering, Dallas, Math
Wilson, Dallas, Science
Creekview, Carrollton-FB, Math
Turner, Carrollton-FB, Math and Science
Berkner, Richardson, Science
Richardson, Richardson, Math and Science
Lewisville, Lewisville, Math
*Based on test scores on TAKS, ACT, SAT and AP exams
SOURCE: Texas Public Policy Foundation
Thursday, November 08, 2007
Report: California dropouts increase in first year of exit exam
By JULIET WILLIAMS, Associated Press Writer
SF Gate.com
Wednesday, November 7, 2007
(11-07) 18:12 PST SACRAMENTO, (AP) --
The number of California high school dropouts spiked in 2006, the first year seniors were required to pass the state's exit exam to graduate, according to a report presented Wednesday to the state Board of Education.
California's high school graduation rate also fell by about 4 percent from the previous year.
The analysis found that 24,000 high school seniors dropped out in 2006, about 10,000 more than just four years earlier.
The information could give ammunition to lawmakers and others who have criticized the exam, as well as those who have lobbied for alternative assessments.
The firm that prepared the report, Human Resources Research Organization of Alexandria, Va., made seven recommendations to the board, including a suggestion that California explore other ways for high school seniors to demonstrate proficiency. In Massachusetts and Washington state, for example, students can be judged on a portfolio of their high school work.
Superintendent of Public Instruction Jack O'Connell has consistently opposed such an option. His chief deputy, Gavin Payne, told the board that the superintendent thought all but one of the recommendations was "extremely good."
The report's findings validate the position of exit exam opponents who say the test is hardest on students who do not have access to good schools or good teachers, said Liz Guillen, director of legislative and community affairs for Public Advocates. That applies mostly to poor and minority students, she said.
The San Francisco-based law firm has sued the state over the exam and sought alternatives.
"As a moral and constitutional matter, before every student can be required to pass the state's new hurdle, the state and its schools must first ensure that ... all of those students have had an opportunity to learn what is tested," she told the board.
The report also highlighted California's persistent achievement gap and found an even more worrisome problem: Students who are black, Hispanic, poor or learning English did even worse when they were in schools with high concentrations of similar students.
That poses a challenge for policymakers trying to address the achievement gap, since the vast majority of underachieving students are concentrated in such schools.
O'Connell has said he is determined to narrow that divide and is hosting an "Achievement Gap Summit" of education leaders next week in Sacramento.
Most students are able to pass the exam in time for graduation, although critics note that as graduation day approaches more students drop out of school and stop being counted.
In the class of 2007, for example, 93 percent of the senior class had passed the test by last May. Students begin taking the test during their sophomore year and have multiple chances to pass the exam, which measures ninth-grade English and ninth-grade math and algebra skills.
To settle a class-action lawsuit, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger signed legislation last month in which the state agreed to provide two more years of remedial tutoring to high school students who can't pass the exam.
The 2007-08 state budget includes $72.4 million for supplemental instruction and $188 million for after-school and summer tutoring to help students pass.
He vetoed a bill that would have forced O'Connell to come up with alternative graduation requirements for students who are proficient but can't pass the exam. The governor said O'Connell already has that authority under existing state law.
The most recent exit exam results showed that more than 88 percent of black and Hispanic students passed the test, with both groups increasing their success rates but still lagging behind whites and Asians.
The report presented to the board on Wednesday is compiled annually as part of the law that established the exit exam. It also included some demographic information about the state's senior class, including the finding that California's schools fail many students who arrive at school knowing very little English.
"Many students are still classified as English-learners after as many as 10 years of education in this country," the report said.
Among the other recommendations:
• The state should do a better job tracking the students who don't pass the exam in time to graduate and don't keep taking it, as a way to see what happens to them. The state has said it does not have sufficient data systems to do this.
• School districts should consider moving more students with disabilities into regular classrooms so they have more exposure to the material tested on the exit exam and a greater opportunity to pass it.
SF Gate.com
Wednesday, November 7, 2007
(11-07) 18:12 PST SACRAMENTO, (AP) --
The number of California high school dropouts spiked in 2006, the first year seniors were required to pass the state's exit exam to graduate, according to a report presented Wednesday to the state Board of Education.
California's high school graduation rate also fell by about 4 percent from the previous year.
The analysis found that 24,000 high school seniors dropped out in 2006, about 10,000 more than just four years earlier.
The information could give ammunition to lawmakers and others who have criticized the exam, as well as those who have lobbied for alternative assessments.
The firm that prepared the report, Human Resources Research Organization of Alexandria, Va., made seven recommendations to the board, including a suggestion that California explore other ways for high school seniors to demonstrate proficiency. In Massachusetts and Washington state, for example, students can be judged on a portfolio of their high school work.
Superintendent of Public Instruction Jack O'Connell has consistently opposed such an option. His chief deputy, Gavin Payne, told the board that the superintendent thought all but one of the recommendations was "extremely good."
The report's findings validate the position of exit exam opponents who say the test is hardest on students who do not have access to good schools or good teachers, said Liz Guillen, director of legislative and community affairs for Public Advocates. That applies mostly to poor and minority students, she said.
The San Francisco-based law firm has sued the state over the exam and sought alternatives.
"As a moral and constitutional matter, before every student can be required to pass the state's new hurdle, the state and its schools must first ensure that ... all of those students have had an opportunity to learn what is tested," she told the board.
The report also highlighted California's persistent achievement gap and found an even more worrisome problem: Students who are black, Hispanic, poor or learning English did even worse when they were in schools with high concentrations of similar students.
That poses a challenge for policymakers trying to address the achievement gap, since the vast majority of underachieving students are concentrated in such schools.
O'Connell has said he is determined to narrow that divide and is hosting an "Achievement Gap Summit" of education leaders next week in Sacramento.
Most students are able to pass the exam in time for graduation, although critics note that as graduation day approaches more students drop out of school and stop being counted.
In the class of 2007, for example, 93 percent of the senior class had passed the test by last May. Students begin taking the test during their sophomore year and have multiple chances to pass the exam, which measures ninth-grade English and ninth-grade math and algebra skills.
To settle a class-action lawsuit, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger signed legislation last month in which the state agreed to provide two more years of remedial tutoring to high school students who can't pass the exam.
The 2007-08 state budget includes $72.4 million for supplemental instruction and $188 million for after-school and summer tutoring to help students pass.
He vetoed a bill that would have forced O'Connell to come up with alternative graduation requirements for students who are proficient but can't pass the exam. The governor said O'Connell already has that authority under existing state law.
The most recent exit exam results showed that more than 88 percent of black and Hispanic students passed the test, with both groups increasing their success rates but still lagging behind whites and Asians.
The report presented to the board on Wednesday is compiled annually as part of the law that established the exit exam. It also included some demographic information about the state's senior class, including the finding that California's schools fail many students who arrive at school knowing very little English.
"Many students are still classified as English-learners after as many as 10 years of education in this country," the report said.
Among the other recommendations:
• The state should do a better job tracking the students who don't pass the exam in time to graduate and don't keep taking it, as a way to see what happens to them. The state has said it does not have sufficient data systems to do this.
• School districts should consider moving more students with disabilities into regular classrooms so they have more exposure to the material tested on the exit exam and a greater opportunity to pass it.
Vouchers go down in crushing defeat [Utah]
Byrne's commentary about Utah voters is very offensive and says more about him than it says about anyone or anything else. Americans, over and over again, manifest support for public schools (and improving them). Could ALL Americans have low IQs as he suggest? If so, is he not an American? Also, his hostility to the addition of new students is also telling as many of the new Utah students happen to be Mexican immigrants at increasing rates. Could this be covert racism under the cloak of expanding opportunity? Just some thoughts.... -Angela
Vouchers go down in crushing defeat
Vouchers' money man says Utahns 'don't care enough about their kids'
By Glen Warchol / The Salt Lake Tribune
Voters decisively rejected the will of the Utah Legislature and governor Tuesday, defeating what would have been the nation's most comprehensive education voucher program in a referendum blowout.
"Tonight, with the eyes of the nation upon us, Utah has rejected this flawed voucher law," said Kim Campbell, president of the Utah Education Association. "We believe this sends a clear message. It sends a message that Utahns believe in, and support, public schools."
More than 60 percent of voters were rejecting vouchers, with about 95 percent of the precincts reporting, according to unofficial results. The referendum failed in every county, including the conservative bastion of Utah County.
Voucher supporter Overstock.com chief executive Patrick Byrne - who bankrolled the voucher effort - called the referendum a "statewide IQ test" that Utahns failed.
"They don't care enough about their kids. They care an awful lot about this system, this bureaucracy, but they don't care enough about their kids to think outside the box," Byrne said.
Doug Holmes, a key voucher advocate and contributor, said, "We started hugely in the hole and it's always been the case. The unions have done this in four different states, where they take the strategy of confusion to the people."
But Holmes said, "You don't run away from something because the odds are stacked against you."
Utah's voucher program, supported by Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. and Republican legislative leaders, attracted national attention because it would have provided tax-funded subsidies to any student, rich or poor, to enroll in a private school.
The law passed by a single vote in the Legislature, but voucher opponents, led by the Utah Education Association teachers' union, gathered 124,000 signatures to force it into a voter referendum.
The resulting public opinion campaign included thousands of TV and radio spots and burned through $8.5 million for a program the state estimated would cost $5.5 million in its first year.
The tidal wave of cash changed few minds, however. As far back as January - before the Legislature approved the voucher program - a Tribune poll showed voters opposing vouchers 57 percent to 33 percent.
Had it passed, the plan would have offered tax-supported subsidies of $500 to $3,000 - depending on family income - for each newly enrolled private school student. It would have been the country's broadest voucher program because it would have had no income ceiling - all Utah students would be eligible as the program phased in over 13 years. By the end of the phase in, the program was projected to cost taxpayers $430 million.
Most of the opposition's $4.4 million came from the National Education Association and state teachers' unions from Florida to Alaska. Voucher supporters countered with more than $4 million, nearly three-quarters of that from Byrne and his family. Byrne says vouchers are the only way America's "broken" public education system can stay competitive with other industrialized nations.
"What's got to happen and it might take Utah five to 10 years to understand," Byrne said, "they are at the bottom of the heap [educationally] and the heap is at the bottom of the international heap."
He shrugged off the fortune he poured into the referendum, saying he leads a fairly modest life as far as CEOs go. "The fortune that I'm making is all going toward educating lower income and especially African-American and Hispanic kids," Byrne said. "So this is not a terribly big deal to me."
Supporters argued the program would help Utah absorb a tide of 150,000 children expected over the next 10 years by diverting students into private academies.
The clash quickly became superheated, with voucher opponents warning the program would bleed needed money from the public system, which already ranks last in the nation for per pupil spending and teacher pay. In television and radio spots, they hammered home a message that the program had "too many loopholes and unknowns."
Supporters fired back, connecting their opposition to liberal icons such as the American Civil Liberties Union, Sens. Hillary Clinton and Ted Kennedy and out-of-state unions. Meanwhile, other media thrusts implied that good Mormons should support vouchers.
Both sides, at one point, embraced the governor, who Byrne blasted Tuesday for his lukewarm backing.
"When he asked for my support [for governor] he told me he is going to be the voucher governor. Not only was it his No. 1 priority, it was what he was going to be all about," Byrne said. "He did, I think, a very tepid job, and then when the polls came out on the referendum, he was pretty much missing in action."
Byrne said the referendum defeat may have killed vouchers in Utah, but "There are other freedom oriented groups in other states - African-Americans in South Carolina are interested in it."
---
* Lisa Schencker and Robert Gehrke contributed to this report.
http://origin.sltrib.com/ci_7392263
Vouchers go down in crushing defeat
Vouchers' money man says Utahns 'don't care enough about their kids'
By Glen Warchol / The Salt Lake Tribune
Voters decisively rejected the will of the Utah Legislature and governor Tuesday, defeating what would have been the nation's most comprehensive education voucher program in a referendum blowout.
"Tonight, with the eyes of the nation upon us, Utah has rejected this flawed voucher law," said Kim Campbell, president of the Utah Education Association. "We believe this sends a clear message. It sends a message that Utahns believe in, and support, public schools."
More than 60 percent of voters were rejecting vouchers, with about 95 percent of the precincts reporting, according to unofficial results. The referendum failed in every county, including the conservative bastion of Utah County.
Voucher supporter Overstock.com chief executive Patrick Byrne - who bankrolled the voucher effort - called the referendum a "statewide IQ test" that Utahns failed.
"They don't care enough about their kids. They care an awful lot about this system, this bureaucracy, but they don't care enough about their kids to think outside the box," Byrne said.
Doug Holmes, a key voucher advocate and contributor, said, "We started hugely in the hole and it's always been the case. The unions have done this in four different states, where they take the strategy of confusion to the people."
But Holmes said, "You don't run away from something because the odds are stacked against you."
Utah's voucher program, supported by Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. and Republican legislative leaders, attracted national attention because it would have provided tax-funded subsidies to any student, rich or poor, to enroll in a private school.
The law passed by a single vote in the Legislature, but voucher opponents, led by the Utah Education Association teachers' union, gathered 124,000 signatures to force it into a voter referendum.
The resulting public opinion campaign included thousands of TV and radio spots and burned through $8.5 million for a program the state estimated would cost $5.5 million in its first year.
The tidal wave of cash changed few minds, however. As far back as January - before the Legislature approved the voucher program - a Tribune poll showed voters opposing vouchers 57 percent to 33 percent.
Had it passed, the plan would have offered tax-supported subsidies of $500 to $3,000 - depending on family income - for each newly enrolled private school student. It would have been the country's broadest voucher program because it would have had no income ceiling - all Utah students would be eligible as the program phased in over 13 years. By the end of the phase in, the program was projected to cost taxpayers $430 million.
Most of the opposition's $4.4 million came from the National Education Association and state teachers' unions from Florida to Alaska. Voucher supporters countered with more than $4 million, nearly three-quarters of that from Byrne and his family. Byrne says vouchers are the only way America's "broken" public education system can stay competitive with other industrialized nations.
"What's got to happen and it might take Utah five to 10 years to understand," Byrne said, "they are at the bottom of the heap [educationally] and the heap is at the bottom of the international heap."
He shrugged off the fortune he poured into the referendum, saying he leads a fairly modest life as far as CEOs go. "The fortune that I'm making is all going toward educating lower income and especially African-American and Hispanic kids," Byrne said. "So this is not a terribly big deal to me."
Supporters argued the program would help Utah absorb a tide of 150,000 children expected over the next 10 years by diverting students into private academies.
The clash quickly became superheated, with voucher opponents warning the program would bleed needed money from the public system, which already ranks last in the nation for per pupil spending and teacher pay. In television and radio spots, they hammered home a message that the program had "too many loopholes and unknowns."
Supporters fired back, connecting their opposition to liberal icons such as the American Civil Liberties Union, Sens. Hillary Clinton and Ted Kennedy and out-of-state unions. Meanwhile, other media thrusts implied that good Mormons should support vouchers.
Both sides, at one point, embraced the governor, who Byrne blasted Tuesday for his lukewarm backing.
"When he asked for my support [for governor] he told me he is going to be the voucher governor. Not only was it his No. 1 priority, it was what he was going to be all about," Byrne said. "He did, I think, a very tepid job, and then when the polls came out on the referendum, he was pretty much missing in action."
Byrne said the referendum defeat may have killed vouchers in Utah, but "There are other freedom oriented groups in other states - African-Americans in South Carolina are interested in it."
---
* Lisa Schencker and Robert Gehrke contributed to this report.
http://origin.sltrib.com/ci_7392263
Wednesday, November 07, 2007
Texas high school grads less prepared for college than others in U.S., panel says
I recommend checking out the website for the Commission for a College Ready Texas. I hope that this conversation gets opened up more broadly to include various sectors of the community. The Texas Center for Education Policy at UT had just such a conversation that was statewide and inclusive. Check out our report, too. -Angela
Texas high school grads less prepared for college than others in U.S., panel says
Remediation often needed; panel to urge higher standards
08:25 AM CST on Tuesday, November 6, 2007
By TERRENCE STUTZ / The Dallas Morning News
tstutz@dallasnews.com
AUSTIN – Texas high school graduates are far less prepared for college-level courses than their counterparts across the nation – with nearly half of college freshmen in Texas needing remediation – according to a state panel appointed by Gov. Rick Perry.
The Commission for a College Ready Texas, which was charged with finding ways to better prepare students for college, also said in a draft report released Monday that the state's curriculum standards are too flimsy, and that a passing score on the state's high school graduation test gives no assurance that a student is ready for college.
Further, the panel said that Texas schools need to quit allowing students to blow off their senior year of high school, arguing that valuable time is wasted when students should be acquiring more of the skills and knowledge they need for college and workplace success.
"We have a big hill to climb in Texas," said Austin lawyer Sandy Kress, chairman of the commission and former education adviser to President Bush. "We want our kids to come out of high school ready for college and a good job, but we have a long way to go to reach that goal."
Mr. Kress, former president of the Dallas school board, said the current curriculum in the public schools doesn't provide for many of the skills considered necessary in college.
"The curriculum has to be stronger, and the standards have to be more rigorous," he said. "While we've made some academic gains in our elementary schools over the last decade, we have not seen gains in our secondary schools."
The commission was appointed by Mr. Perry earlier this year to make recommendations to the State Board of Education and Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board. Among the recommendations will be new, college-oriented curriculum standards for English, math, science and social studies courses taught in the public schools.
Commission members – including business, civic and education leaders from across the state – are scheduled to finalize their recommendations at a meeting in Austin on Wednesday.
The panel's report spells out problems that Texas faces in trying to improve the college readiness of its high school graduates.
"A variety of data confirm that high school graduates across the United States are ill-prepared for the rigors of college coursework, and Texas students fare even worse than their counterparts nationally," the report said.
"The vast majority of Texas public school graduates who intend to acquire post-secondary certification or a degree are less prepared to succeed than most of their peers throughout the nation."
College readiness was defined as having "the core knowledge and skills necessary to succeed in the first year of education after high school without the need for remedial or developmental education."
By that definition, Texas is not making the grade, according to the report.
Data cited by the commission indicated that 50 percent of college freshmen in Texas are enrolled in remedial or developmental classes, compared with 28 percent across the U.S.
In addition, the study noted that only 18 percent of Texas students who took the ACT – one of the leading college entrance exams – met college readiness benchmarks in English, math, science and social studies. The percentages were even smaller for black and Hispanic students.
The report also said the passing standard on the high school graduation exam, the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills, is so low that it masks the academic weaknesses of many students who actually lack the skills to do well in freshman courses in college.
Regarding the tendency of many high school students to breeze through their senior year, the report said: "Students, faculty, counselors and administrators can no longer view the senior year in high school as a let-down or 'marking-time' interval.
"Academic intensity must continue through 12th grade if students are to obtain the knowledge and skills necessary for college and workplace success."
Texas high school grads less prepared for college than others in U.S., panel says
Remediation often needed; panel to urge higher standards
08:25 AM CST on Tuesday, November 6, 2007
By TERRENCE STUTZ / The Dallas Morning News
tstutz@dallasnews.com
AUSTIN – Texas high school graduates are far less prepared for college-level courses than their counterparts across the nation – with nearly half of college freshmen in Texas needing remediation – according to a state panel appointed by Gov. Rick Perry.
The Commission for a College Ready Texas, which was charged with finding ways to better prepare students for college, also said in a draft report released Monday that the state's curriculum standards are too flimsy, and that a passing score on the state's high school graduation test gives no assurance that a student is ready for college.
Further, the panel said that Texas schools need to quit allowing students to blow off their senior year of high school, arguing that valuable time is wasted when students should be acquiring more of the skills and knowledge they need for college and workplace success.
"We have a big hill to climb in Texas," said Austin lawyer Sandy Kress, chairman of the commission and former education adviser to President Bush. "We want our kids to come out of high school ready for college and a good job, but we have a long way to go to reach that goal."
Mr. Kress, former president of the Dallas school board, said the current curriculum in the public schools doesn't provide for many of the skills considered necessary in college.
"The curriculum has to be stronger, and the standards have to be more rigorous," he said. "While we've made some academic gains in our elementary schools over the last decade, we have not seen gains in our secondary schools."
The commission was appointed by Mr. Perry earlier this year to make recommendations to the State Board of Education and Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board. Among the recommendations will be new, college-oriented curriculum standards for English, math, science and social studies courses taught in the public schools.
Commission members – including business, civic and education leaders from across the state – are scheduled to finalize their recommendations at a meeting in Austin on Wednesday.
The panel's report spells out problems that Texas faces in trying to improve the college readiness of its high school graduates.
"A variety of data confirm that high school graduates across the United States are ill-prepared for the rigors of college coursework, and Texas students fare even worse than their counterparts nationally," the report said.
"The vast majority of Texas public school graduates who intend to acquire post-secondary certification or a degree are less prepared to succeed than most of their peers throughout the nation."
College readiness was defined as having "the core knowledge and skills necessary to succeed in the first year of education after high school without the need for remedial or developmental education."
By that definition, Texas is not making the grade, according to the report.
Data cited by the commission indicated that 50 percent of college freshmen in Texas are enrolled in remedial or developmental classes, compared with 28 percent across the U.S.
In addition, the study noted that only 18 percent of Texas students who took the ACT – one of the leading college entrance exams – met college readiness benchmarks in English, math, science and social studies. The percentages were even smaller for black and Hispanic students.
The report also said the passing standard on the high school graduation exam, the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills, is so low that it masks the academic weaknesses of many students who actually lack the skills to do well in freshman courses in college.
Regarding the tendency of many high school students to breeze through their senior year, the report said: "Students, faculty, counselors and administrators can no longer view the senior year in high school as a let-down or 'marking-time' interval.
"Academic intensity must continue through 12th grade if students are to obtain the knowledge and skills necessary for college and workplace success."
Tuesday, November 06, 2007
Toward a World Without Borders
By Onto Aporia
From the October 29, 2007 issue of The Indypendent
What is a border? First off, it’s war. Literally, the border is a relic of the Mexican-American War of 1848, when America “bought” half of Mexico’s territory (about 500,000- square miles) at gunpoint. The Treaty of Guadalupe-Hidalgo still stands, marking the Rio Grande as the “line” which “separates” us from them. The border is a monument without a museum, doused with techno-media and military machines in order to revive its symbolism with a vengeance. Yet the war never really ended, only moving underground, in shadows, in stealth. Bodies still pile up at the edges, and governments still negotiate new treaties (trade agreements) all the time.
Through such agreements, the border becomes a form of property. It is enclosure, forming the body proper of the country, its outline, its image in the sand. Once this illusion becomes solidified in the minds of the citizens, its defense becomes unquestionable. Who wouldn’t want to defend their property? The border becomes the consensual hallucination of an imagined community of “citizens” who share nothing but a relationship to what’s “outside.” We’re not them, they say, those are ‘aliens’. If to be an alien means to embody the subversion of their entire system of property, then by all means indict us! Property does not make the border possible, but on the contrary, the border makes all property possible. And with that, capital as well.
Property, we know, is theft. And theft, capture and control are the main functions of any state. Besides cops, prisons, and government buildings, the border is the closest thing you’ll get to the material manifestation of the state in all its naked force. The collusion between capitalists, militarists, racist libertarians and “pluralist” democrats to “contain the state of emergency”, i.e., the loss of their profit, is blatant at every border site. Every “border zone” is chaos, and so the state tries to covers it up with a thousand bureaucracies, rules and technologies. The state tries to organize the chaos from above, but we all know how that goes: more resistance from below.
To contain resistance, the border becomes a prison. With 17 federal detention centers, hundreds of county ones and thousands of private ones, the border escapes its geography and encroaches inland. By the fall of 2007 the Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) will spend an estimated $1 billion per year to detain more than 27,500 immigrants. ICE operates eight Service Processing Centers and seven contract detention facilities. Additionally, immigration detainees are being held in local jails and private prisons across the United States.
To guard this mobile prison, they need police. But how can the border also be a police force? By militarizing itself, and distributing the mindset of militarization to everyone it can. Everyone becomes a border guard, with ICE being just the last step in the long chain of control. Neighbors, colleagues, workers, friends — no one is safe. With a little help from the fear-mongering media, the virus of the bordermind sets in and spreads. Migrants — living in hiding, working in backrooms — are killed coming in and killed getting out.
DECONSTRUCTING ALL BORDERS
How do we escape from this long border war? Where they have ideology, we must have Imagination. In some sense, we know the border is an imagined act, albeit an enforced one. To overcome this, we must imagine as well, and we must enforce our imaginations too. A world without borders is not a dream, it is how you live. Some say that migrants are the most victimized social class in the world. Others say that the global movement of migrants is the largest social movement in the world. Both are exaggerations, yet both are somewhat true.
Resistance doesn’t begin at the fence because the border doesn’t begin there either. Borders are massive investments, they are literally their own economies, and every economy, in the end, is based on debt, credit and the faith that everything will be paid back in full. Resisting the border means breaking that faith, that credit in the ideology of exclusion. This resistance is as layered as the border itself, and hence is inconsistent, contradictory and unpredictable.
From underground railroads to class solidarity, lobbying to strikes, boycotts to riots, childcare to legal defense, noborder camps to farmworker rights, the resistance is as open as the air. There is no “resistance” itself, only resistances which could link up to tear down, break away and immunize the border regime wherever it emerges.
This article was excerpted from a longer version published in the New York Rat, Issue #8, May 2007.
From the October 29, 2007 issue of The Indypendent
What is a border? First off, it’s war. Literally, the border is a relic of the Mexican-American War of 1848, when America “bought” half of Mexico’s territory (about 500,000- square miles) at gunpoint. The Treaty of Guadalupe-Hidalgo still stands, marking the Rio Grande as the “line” which “separates” us from them. The border is a monument without a museum, doused with techno-media and military machines in order to revive its symbolism with a vengeance. Yet the war never really ended, only moving underground, in shadows, in stealth. Bodies still pile up at the edges, and governments still negotiate new treaties (trade agreements) all the time.
Through such agreements, the border becomes a form of property. It is enclosure, forming the body proper of the country, its outline, its image in the sand. Once this illusion becomes solidified in the minds of the citizens, its defense becomes unquestionable. Who wouldn’t want to defend their property? The border becomes the consensual hallucination of an imagined community of “citizens” who share nothing but a relationship to what’s “outside.” We’re not them, they say, those are ‘aliens’. If to be an alien means to embody the subversion of their entire system of property, then by all means indict us! Property does not make the border possible, but on the contrary, the border makes all property possible. And with that, capital as well.
Property, we know, is theft. And theft, capture and control are the main functions of any state. Besides cops, prisons, and government buildings, the border is the closest thing you’ll get to the material manifestation of the state in all its naked force. The collusion between capitalists, militarists, racist libertarians and “pluralist” democrats to “contain the state of emergency”, i.e., the loss of their profit, is blatant at every border site. Every “border zone” is chaos, and so the state tries to covers it up with a thousand bureaucracies, rules and technologies. The state tries to organize the chaos from above, but we all know how that goes: more resistance from below.
To contain resistance, the border becomes a prison. With 17 federal detention centers, hundreds of county ones and thousands of private ones, the border escapes its geography and encroaches inland. By the fall of 2007 the Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE ) will spend an estimated $1 billion per year to detain more than 27,500 immigrants. ICE operates eight Service Processing Centers and seven contract detention facilities. Additionally, immigration detainees are being held in local jails and private prisons across the United States.
To guard this mobile prison, they need police. But how can the border also be a police force? By militarizing itself, and distributing the mindset of militarization to everyone it can. Everyone becomes a border guard, with ICE being just the last step in the long chain of control. Neighbors, colleagues, workers, friends — no one is safe. With a little help from the fear-mongering media, the virus of the bordermind sets in and spreads. Migrants — living in hiding, working in backrooms — are killed coming in and killed getting out.
DECONSTRUCTING ALL BORDERS
How do we escape from this long border war? Where they have ideology, we must have Imagination. In some sense, we know the border is an imagined act, albeit an enforced one. To overcome this, we must imagine as well, and we must enforce our imaginations too. A world without borders is not a dream, it is how you live. Some say that migrants are the most victimized social class in the world. Others say that the global movement of migrants is the largest social movement in the world. Both are exaggerations, yet both are somewhat true.
Resistance doesn’t begin at the fence because the border doesn’t begin there either. Borders are massive investments, they are literally their own economies, and every economy, in the end, is based on debt, credit and the faith that everything will be paid back in full. Resisting the border means breaking that faith, that credit in the ideology of exclusion. This resistance is as layered as the border itself, and hence is inconsistent, contradictory and unpredictable.
From underground railroads to class solidarity, lobbying to strikes, boycotts to riots, childcare to legal defense, noborder camps to farmworker rights, the resistance is as open as the air. There is no “resistance” itself, only resistances which could link up to tear down, break away and immunize the border regime wherever it emerges.
This article was excerpted from a longer version published in the New York Rat, Issue #8, May 2007.
Non-profit Corp.: One-economy.com
Want to let everybody know about a non-profit, called One Economy Corporation (www.one-economy.com ) whose mission is to help low-income people use technology to connect with information, both in their daily lives and in times of need. We manage a self help web portal called the Beehive (/www.thebeehive.org).
In response to the recent fires in southern California, the Beehive will be featuring an online resource called Southern California Wildfire Resource Center (www.SoCalHelp.org), beginning on November 5. This resource will be dedicated to helping the lower income and Spanish speaking communities rebuilding their lives after the fires. Online California residents can find also information about:
Temporary housing
Financial assistance
Finding the right job
Staying healthy
In response to the recent fires in southern California, the Beehive will be featuring an online resource called Southern California Wildfire Resource Center (www.SoCalHelp.org), beginning on November 5. This resource will be dedicated to helping the lower income and Spanish speaking communities rebuilding their lives after the fires. Online California residents can find also information about:
Temporary housing
Financial assistance
Finding the right job
Staying healthy
Monday, November 05, 2007
1 in 10 Schools Are 'Dropout Factories'

Dontike Miller, 23, works on math problems at the YouthBuild Public Charter School's GED program in Washington, Thursday Oct. 25, 2007. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
This is a really tragic situation. I quote: "Nationally, about 70 percent of U.S. students graduate on time with a regular diploma. For Hispanic and black students, the proportion drops to about half." Also check out a state-by-state look at dropouts based on John Hopkins Professor Balfanz's national analysis of dropout factories.
-Angela
1 in 10 Schools Are 'Dropout Factories'
Federal Government Puts New Focus on High Schools; Boosting Graduation Rates Top Goal
By NANCY ZUCKERBROD
The Associated Press
WASHINGTON
It's a nickname no principal could be proud of: "Dropout Factory," a high school where no more than 60 percent of the students who start as freshmen make it to their senior year. That dubious distinction applies to more than one in 10 high schools across America.
"If you're born in a neighborhood or town where the only high school is one where graduation is not the norm, how is this living in the land of equal opportunity?" asks Bob Balfanz, the researcher at Johns Hopkins University who defines such a school as a "dropout factory."
There are about 1,700 regular or vocational high schools nationwide that fit that description, according to an analysis of Education Department data conducted by Johns Hopkins for The Associated Press. That's 12 percent of all such schools, no more than a decade ago but no less, either.
While some of the missing students transferred, most dropped out, Balfanz says. The data tracked senior classes for three years in a row 2004, 2005 and 2006 to make sure local events like plant closures weren't to blame for the low retention rates.
The highest concentration of dropout factories is in large cities or high-poverty rural areas in the South and Southwest. Most have high proportions of minority students. These schools are tougher to turn around, because their students face challenges well beyond the academic ones the need to work as well as go to school, for example, or a need for social services.
Utah, which has low poverty rates and fewer minorities than most states, is the only state without a dropout factory. Florida and South Carolina have the highest percentages. About half of high schools in those states classify as dropout factories.
"Part of the problem we've had here is we live in a state that culturally and traditionally has not valued a high school education," said Jim Foster, a spokesman for South Carolina's Department of Education. He noted that South Carolina residents once could get good jobs in textile mills without a high school degree, but that those jobs are now much harder to come by.
Federal lawmakers haven't focused much attention on the problem. The No Child Left Behind education law, for example, pays much more attention to educating younger students. But that appears to be changing.
House and Senate proposals to renew the five-year-old No Child law would give high schools more federal money and put more pressure on them to improve, and the Bush administration supports the idea.
The current law imposes serious consequences on schools that report low scores on math and reading tests, such as having to replace teachers or principals, but it lacks the same kind of teeth when it comes to graduation rates.
Nationally, about 70 percent of U.S. students graduate on time with a regular diploma. For Hispanic and black students, the proportion drops to about half.
The legislative proposals would:
Make sure schools report their graduation rates by racial, ethnic and other subgroups and are judged on those. That's to ensure schools aren't just graduating white students in high numbers, but also are working to ensure minority students get diplomas.
Get states to build data systems to keep track of students throughout their school years and more accurately measure graduation and dropout rates.
Ensure states count graduation rates in a uniform way. States have used a variety of formulas, including counting the percentage of entering seniors who get a diploma. That measurement ignores the fact that kids who drop out typically do so before their senior year.
Create strong progress goals for graduation rates and impose sanctions on schools that miss them. Most states currently lack meaningful goals, according to The Education Trust, a nonprofit that advocates for poor and minority children.
The current law requires testing in reading and math once in high school, and those tests take on added importance because of serious consequences for a school that fails. Critics say that creates a perverse incentive for schools to encourage kids to drop out before they bring down a school's scores.
"The vast majority of educators do not want to push out kids, but the pressures to raise test scores above all else are intense," said Bethany Little, vice president for policy at the Alliance for Excellent Education, an advocacy group focused on high schools. "To know if a high school is doing its job, we need to consider test scores and graduation rates equally."
Little said some students pushed out of high schools are encouraged to enroll in programs that prepare them to take the GED exam. People who pass that test get certificates indicating they have high-school level academic skills. But the research shows getting a GED doesn't lead to the kind of job or college success associated with a regular diploma.
Loretta Singletary, 17, enrolled in a GED program after dropping out of a Washington, D.C., high school that she describes as huge, chaotic and violent. "Girls got jumped, boys got jumped, teachers (were) fighting and hitting students," she said.
She said teachers had low expectations for students, which led to dull classes. "They were teaching me stuff I already knew ... basic nouns, simple adjectives."
Singletary said she loved science but wasn't offered it and her complaints to administrators went unanswered. "I was interested in experiments," she said. "I didn't have science in 9th or 10th grade."
A GED classmate of Singletary's is 23-year-old Dontike Miller, who attended and left two D.C. high schools on the dropout factory list. Miller was brought up by a single mother who used drugs, and he said teachers and counselors seemed oblivious to what was going on in his life.
He would have liked for someone to sit him down and say: "You really need to go to class. We're going to work with you. We're going to help you," Miller said. Instead, "I had nobody."
Teachers and administrators at Baltimore Talent Development High School, where 90 percent of kids are on track toward graduating on time, are working hard to make sure students don't have an experience like Miller's.
The school, which sits in the middle of a high-crime, impoverished neighborhood two miles west of downtown Baltimore, was founded by Balfanz and others four years ago as a laboratory for getting kids out on time with a diploma and ready for college.
Teachers, students and administrators at the school know each other well.
"I know teachers that have knocked on people's doors. They want us to succeed," 12th-grader Jasmine Coleman said during a lunchtime chat in the cafeteria.
Fellow senior Victoria Haynes says she likes the way the school organizes teachers in teams of four, each assigned to a group of 75 students. The teachers work across subject areas; English and math teachers, for example, collaborate on lessons and discuss individual students' needs.
"They all concentrate on what's best for us together," Haynes said. "It's very family-oriented. We feel really close to them."
Teachers, too, say it works.
"I know the students a lot better, because I know the teachers who teach them," said 10th-grade English teacher Jenni Williams. "Everyone's on the same page, so it's not like you're alone in your mission."
That mission can be daunting. The majority of students who enter Baltimore Talent Development in 9th grade are reading at a 5th or 6th grade level.
To get caught up, students have 80-minute lessons in reading and math, instead of the typical 45 minutes. They also get additional time with specialists if needed.
The fact that youths are entering high schools with such poor literacy skills raises questions about how much catch-up work high schools can be expected to do, say some high-school principals.
"We're at the end of the process," says Mel Riddile, principal of T.C. Williams High School, a large public school in Alexandria, Va., which is not on the dropout factory list. "People don't walk into 9th grade and suddenly have a reading problem."
Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 2007 ABC News Internet Ventures
Sunday, November 04, 2007
House Resolution Honors the Lifelong Dedication
For Immediate Release Contacts: Javier Dominguez & Elisavet Garcia (202) 833-6130
October 26, 2007
Washington, DC The League of United Latin American Citizens, the largest and oldest Hispanic civil rights organization proudly endorses H.R. 37, a resolution sponsored by Congresswoman Hilda Solis (D-CA) that honors Dolores Huerta’s enduring dedication for fair and safe working conditions for farm workers and their families.
“This bill fittingly entrusts that all workers deserve fair and safe working conditions,” said LULAC National President Rosa Rosales. “Dolores Huerta demonstrates a fearless commitment to fight for safe and healthy working conditions for all farm workers. In addition, she has also been a strong advocate for the rights of women and children. We applaud Congresswoman Solis for her noble sponsorship of this bill.”
Dolores Huerta’s contributions to the betterment of the Latino community are invaluable. Along with Cesar Chavez and many other Latino activists, she improved the lives of millions of farm workers by empowering them to fight for their rights. She was a cofounder to the National Farm Workers Association, a precursor to the United Farm Workers.
To date, fifty-five representatives have signed on to co-sponsor the resolution. LULAC urges Congress to pass this resolution and commemorate the courageous contributions of Dolores Huerta and farm workers of the United States.
The League of the United Latin American Citizens, the largest and oldest Hispanic membership organization in the country, advances the economic conditions, educational attainment, political influence, health and civil rights of Hispanic Americans through community-based programs operating at more than 700 LULAC councils nationwide.
October 26, 2007
Washington, DC The League of United Latin American Citizens, the largest and oldest Hispanic civil rights organization proudly endorses H.R. 37, a resolution sponsored by Congresswoman Hilda Solis (D-CA) that honors Dolores Huerta’s enduring dedication for fair and safe working conditions for farm workers and their families.
“This bill fittingly entrusts that all workers deserve fair and safe working conditions,” said LULAC National President Rosa Rosales. “Dolores Huerta demonstrates a fearless commitment to fight for safe and healthy working conditions for all farm workers. In addition, she has also been a strong advocate for the rights of women and children. We applaud Congresswoman Solis for her noble sponsorship of this bill.”
Dolores Huerta’s contributions to the betterment of the Latino community are invaluable. Along with Cesar Chavez and many other Latino activists, she improved the lives of millions of farm workers by empowering them to fight for their rights. She was a cofounder to the National Farm Workers Association, a precursor to the United Farm Workers.
To date, fifty-five representatives have signed on to co-sponsor the resolution. LULAC urges Congress to pass this resolution and commemorate the courageous contributions of Dolores Huerta and farm workers of the United States.
The League of the United Latin American Citizens, the largest and oldest Hispanic membership organization in the country, advances the economic conditions, educational attainment, political influence, health and civil rights of Hispanic Americans through community-based programs operating at more than 700 LULAC councils nationwide.
Undocumented Immigrants: The Unseen Victims of California's Wildfires

By Amanda Martinez, New American Media
October 26, 2007
The relief efforts in the Southern California fires have been praised as effective, but they've missed a population that has long been in the shadows: undocumented workers living along San Diego's hillsides and canyons. These men, who represent some of the most essential workers in one of the biggest local industries, have slipped through the cracks in the county's relief and evacuation efforts - so much so that Mexican government officials are filling in the gaps.
"The Mexican Consulate are the ones who have led the relief effort to the farm workers in the canyons," says Eddie Preciado, director of La Posada de Guadalupe, the only homeless shelter for male farm workers in San Diego County. He says the consulate has organized partnerships with groups like his in order to conduct searches and provide supplies to the canyon dwellers.
Immigrant advocacy groups are uncertain how these workers are surviving. They say the fires have left the workers scattered and unaccounted for. Evacuation orders have closed off access to these communities, making it very difficult for support teams to assess the population's needs and nearly impossible to determine how many living quarters have been destroyed in the fires.
The farm workers are hard to reach physically, living in the remote areas of the canyon, but they are also linguistically isolated. Many are members of Mexico's indigenous Mixtec and Zapotec communities and do not speak English or Spanish.
"Indigenous Mexicans who speak languages such as Mixteco are at high risk of being in danger because they don't understand warnings being given in English or Spanish and they are not likely to trust people unless they are approached speaking their language," says photojournalist David Bacon, who has documented farm worker communities in rural California.
It has been estimated that there are more than 1,600 agricultural workers and day laborers living in the area in makeshift settlements, according to the Regional Task Force on the Homeless in San Diego. This is probably a low estimate of those affected by the fires because it is impossible to know exactly how many workers live this way. Described as "rural homeless," they scrape by without electricity, a water supply, or sanitation systems in order to be close to the farms where they work.
These workers make up an essential agricultural labor force in San Diego County, which is one of the top agricultural producers in California and ranks second in the nation in its number of farms, according to the Regional Task Force on the Homeless.
Yet despite the industry's reliance on these laborers, they could be left out of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)'s relief aid because, without papers, they have very limited access to FEMA funds.
Konane Martinez of the National Latino Research Center anticipates that documentation will be a requirement for most federal government agencies providing relief in the area. As a result, Martinez is collaborating with 18 different organizations to collect money and resources for displaced farm workers looking for aid once the fires subside.
"I don't think anyone will be turned away from immediate assistance," says Dorothy Johnson, an attorney with California Legal Rural Assistance, which provides farm workers with legal support. And though no one has reported being denied help, many undocumented immigrants are not seeking aid because they do not know which rescue workers they can trust. Many see the risk of deportation as more dangerous than the fires themselves.
"I wouldn't be surprised if they avoided firefighters," says Bacon, adding that many undocumented workers are wary of law enforcement for fear of being detained or deported.
"Many of these workers have experienced intense situations of danger just to get into the United States," and earn money to send to their families back home, explains Bacon. They are willing to endure very harsh conditions, he says, to avoid being caught by Border Patrol or ICE agents.
The Spanish-language publication Enlace, in San Diego, reported on Monday that some farm workers have chosen to remain in the canyons despite warnings to evacuate because they do not want to leave.
Meanwhile some who do are not being allowed to leave. "Some farmers are not following evacuation orders and have kept workers in the fields despite orders being given to evacuate," says Christian Ramirez of the American Friends Service Committee.
But if they stay they should know that, as Ramirez explains, "the atmosphere conditions are not safe to be working in." His organization has been sending volunteers into the fields to supply farm workers with eye drops, facemasks and goggles.
Apparently unconcerned that the use of Border Patrol agents might discourage undocumented residents from seeking help, the San Diego County Office of Emergency Management called on the U.S. Border Patrol to help with the emergency relief efforts. Matthew Johnson says about 300 agents are now "watching for looters, monitoring affected neighborhoods and safety control" during the fire relief efforts.
Some agents were working alongside local police when six undocumented immigrants were arrested Wednesday outside of Qualcomm Stadium, one of the main fire relief sites.
Those arrested were reportedly seen stealing relief supplies consisting of fold-up cots and bottles of water from Qualcomm. Police Sgt. Jesse Cesena told the San Diego Union-Tribune that "they were stealing from the people in need." The police turned the immigrants over to Border Patrol agents.
Although they are busy with local relief efforts, Johnson says the Border Patrol is still watching the border. Since the start of the fires, he says, they have apprehended 200 immigrants trying to cross into the United States.
Ironically, Dr. Leo Estrada, professor of Urban Planning at UCLA, believes the undocumented workers shouldn't worry. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) won't be conducting raids anytime soon, he says.
In fact, he predicts, immigrant workers will be needed in reconstruction efforts after the fire. More than 410,000 acres of land have burned, and clean-up efforts will be critical. "With more than 1000 homes being demolished," he notes, "contractors will be looking to immigrant labor forces to demolish, cart away, and rebuild houses."
"We saw it New Orleans," says Estrada. Undocumented immigrants from Mexico and Central America were among the largest groups employed in rebuilding the city after Hurricane Katrina.
"At the time of reconstruction, nobody bothered them. It will be interesting to see," says Estrada. "They will be bringing back a labor force they have been trying to get rid of."
Photo by David Bacon
Friday, November 02, 2007
School Activist's Next Assignment
Board Member Picked for Ombudsman, Praised for Commitment
By David Nakamura
Washington Post
Friday, October 26, 2007
Mayor Adrian M. Fenty has selected a longtime school activist who serves on the D.C. State Board of Education to become the city's first public education ombudsman, a critical role in Fenty's plan to improve the troubled system.
Tonya Vidal Kinlow, 46, whose children have attended D.C. public schools, would be responsible for investigating and responding to complaints from parents and school employees, Fenty (D) said yesterday at a news conference.
Kinlow is "well regarded in the community, cognizant of education issues locally and nationally and brings a fervor and passion for reform," Fenty said at Leckie Elementary School in Southwest Washington.
Kinlow's appointment is subject to confirmation by the D.C. Council. If confirmed, she would start in December and be paid about $135,000 a year. She would be based in the city government building at 441 Fourth Street NW.
As part of his takeover of the 49,000-student school system, Fenty promised to appoint an ombudsman with the power to help parents resolve complaints, in part because the school board's role was being diminished. The mayor took months to fill the job.
Kinlow is vice president for government relations at the D.C. Hospital Association and was appointed by Fenty in the spring to serve as vice president of the new D.C. State Board of Education. She had previously served as an elected school board member, and she is the vice chairman of DC Voice, a school advocacy group.
Kinlow said she intends to resign from the hospital association and the school board. As ombudsman, she would be responsible for issuing monthly reports and suggesting policy changes to Fenty and Schools Chancellor Michelle A. Rhee. She would have the authority to investigate all aspects of the system, Fenty said, including instruction and facilities. When parents file complaints, she will determine the validity of the complaints and respond.
Kinlow said she would act without fear of retribution from the mayor or chancellor.
"How I will maintain my independence is to just tell the truth," she said. "I asked the mayor to at least let me tell what I'm seeing: 'You are the one who will make the final decision, but I've got to lay out the picture of what the problem is.' "
Jeff Smith, director of DC Voice and a former D.C. school board member, said Kinlow knows firsthand the frustration of parents.
"She can be very aggressive for a positive cause, whatever she's trying to advance," Smith said. "She always sat at the table as a parent. . . . That led her to be so involved."
Of Fenty's five top education appointees, Kinlow is the only African American. She lives in Ward 8 and is among a handful of mayoral appointees who live east of the Anacostia River. Fenty has been criticized for not having more African Americans or more residents of the eastern part of the city among his top-ranking officials.
To select an ombudsman, Fenty aides said, they considered 80 resumes during a national search and brought in a half-dozen candidates for interviews. Kinlow did not initially apply. But when Robert C. Bobb, the school board president and a member of the ombudsman search committee, was unable to attend one interview session, Kinlow filled in for him.
Rhee, Bobb and Deputy Mayor for Education Victor A. Reinoso said they were so impressed by Kinlow's performance -- the questions she asked and the report she later gave to Bobb -- that they asked her to apply.
"She's a quiet revolutionary," Bobb said.
By David Nakamura
Washington Post
Friday, October 26, 2007
Mayor Adrian M. Fenty has selected a longtime school activist who serves on the D.C. State Board of Education to become the city's first public education ombudsman, a critical role in Fenty's plan to improve the troubled system.
Tonya Vidal Kinlow, 46, whose children have attended D.C. public schools, would be responsible for investigating and responding to complaints from parents and school employees, Fenty (D) said yesterday at a news conference.
Kinlow is "well regarded in the community, cognizant of education issues locally and nationally and brings a fervor and passion for reform," Fenty said at Leckie Elementary School in Southwest Washington.
Kinlow's appointment is subject to confirmation by the D.C. Council. If confirmed, she would start in December and be paid about $135,000 a year. She would be based in the city government building at 441 Fourth Street NW.
As part of his takeover of the 49,000-student school system, Fenty promised to appoint an ombudsman with the power to help parents resolve complaints, in part because the school board's role was being diminished. The mayor took months to fill the job.
Kinlow is vice president for government relations at the D.C. Hospital Association and was appointed by Fenty in the spring to serve as vice president of the new D.C. State Board of Education. She had previously served as an elected school board member, and she is the vice chairman of DC Voice, a school advocacy group.
Kinlow said she intends to resign from the hospital association and the school board. As ombudsman, she would be responsible for issuing monthly reports and suggesting policy changes to Fenty and Schools Chancellor Michelle A. Rhee. She would have the authority to investigate all aspects of the system, Fenty said, including instruction and facilities. When parents file complaints, she will determine the validity of the complaints and respond.
Kinlow said she would act without fear of retribution from the mayor or chancellor.
"How I will maintain my independence is to just tell the truth," she said. "I asked the mayor to at least let me tell what I'm seeing: 'You are the one who will make the final decision, but I've got to lay out the picture of what the problem is.' "
Jeff Smith, director of DC Voice and a former D.C. school board member, said Kinlow knows firsthand the frustration of parents.
"She can be very aggressive for a positive cause, whatever she's trying to advance," Smith said. "She always sat at the table as a parent. . . . That led her to be so involved."
Of Fenty's five top education appointees, Kinlow is the only African American. She lives in Ward 8 and is among a handful of mayoral appointees who live east of the Anacostia River. Fenty has been criticized for not having more African Americans or more residents of the eastern part of the city among his top-ranking officials.
To select an ombudsman, Fenty aides said, they considered 80 resumes during a national search and brought in a half-dozen candidates for interviews. Kinlow did not initially apply. But when Robert C. Bobb, the school board president and a member of the ombudsman search committee, was unable to attend one interview session, Kinlow filled in for him.
Rhee, Bobb and Deputy Mayor for Education Victor A. Reinoso said they were so impressed by Kinlow's performance -- the questions she asked and the report she later gave to Bobb -- that they asked her to apply.
"She's a quiet revolutionary," Bobb said.
Texas enrollment shift continues
Universities' cost big reason for more rapid growth at community colleges
By MATTHEW TRESAUGUE | Houston Chronicle
October 26, 2007
Texas community colleges grew twice as rapidly as the state's public universities this fall, continuing an enrollment shift that coincides with rising tuition costs, according to preliminary numbers released Thursday.
The state's Higher Education Coordinating Board attributed 60 percent of the new enrollment to community colleges. Overall, 1,225,817 students are attending classes statewide, or 24,421 more than last year — a 2 percent increase.
The growth of community colleges has outpaced that of the four-year schools since the Legislature allowed public universities to set their own tuition rates four years ago.
"There is no question that cost is a factor," said Raymund Paredes, the state's higher education commissioner. "But it's not strictly an issue of economics. It's also, where is the best fit?"
Increasingly, that's community colleges, which now enroll 48 percent of students statewide while public universities enroll 41 percent.
More Texas students attended public universities than two-year schools until the middle 1990s.
The coordinating board projects that as much as 70 percent of Texas' higher education enrollment will be at community colleges by 2015.
The strains already can be seen throughout the fast-growing North Harris Montgomery Community College District. At Cy-Fair College, the district's five-year-old campus in the northwest suburbs, enrollment soared 10 percent to 11,826 students this fall.
Montgomery College, in The Woodlands, has seen its enrollment increase by 8 percent to 8,810 students. To handle the surge, the campus has added portable classrooms and used storage space for faculty offices.
"Everyone would rather go to a university," said Garrett Anderson, who plans to transfer from Montgomery College to a four-year school next year. "But you can do your basics here for a fraction of the cost."
The cost of attending the state's public universities has increased steadily since the Legislature deregulated tuition. Texans now pay an average of $6,437 a year at the four-year schools, compared with $6,185 nationally.
Meanwhile, Texas community colleges charge $1,695 on average, which is less than those in all but three other states and well below the national average.
Before tuition deregulation, Brazosport College charged about a third the average published price of the state's public universities. It's now about a fifth the cost, said Millicent Valek, the college's president.
"Most families in Texas are being priced out of higher education," said Valek, who also chairs the Texas Association of Community Colleges. "Beginning at a community college is becoming more and more common."
Hispanic students now account for more than half the new college students statewide.
A recent national report found that highly qualified Hispanic students often give cost, proximity to home and campus atmosphere priority over prestige in choosing their schools. Thus, they typically enroll first at community colleges.
Natalia Castillo, a 20-year-old Colombia native, said she chose Houston Community College to sharpen her English skills before pursuing an advertising degree elsewhere.
"I'm happy with my education," Castillo said. "HCC is a good school."
Its enrollment, however, declined 3 percent to 36,032 students this fall. This week, HCC launched a new marketing campaign and pledged to become the nation's "most relevant community college" by adding more academic programs, among other improvements.
According to 12th-day fall figures, enrollment increased at Prairie View A&M University, Sam Houston State University, Texas A&M University and the University of Texas at Austin. The University of Houston held at 34,540 students.
Texas Southern University, in Houston, saw enrollment decrease by 10 percent, most of any state public university, according to the coordinating board's figures. But school officials acknowledged a 15 percent drop. Many students left after the 12th day.
matthew.tresaugue@chron.com
By MATTHEW TRESAUGUE | Houston Chronicle
October 26, 2007
Texas community colleges grew twice as rapidly as the state's public universities this fall, continuing an enrollment shift that coincides with rising tuition costs, according to preliminary numbers released Thursday.
The state's Higher Education Coordinating Board attributed 60 percent of the new enrollment to community colleges. Overall, 1,225,817 students are attending classes statewide, or 24,421 more than last year — a 2 percent increase.
The growth of community colleges has outpaced that of the four-year schools since the Legislature allowed public universities to set their own tuition rates four years ago.
"There is no question that cost is a factor," said Raymund Paredes, the state's higher education commissioner. "But it's not strictly an issue of economics. It's also, where is the best fit?"
Increasingly, that's community colleges, which now enroll 48 percent of students statewide while public universities enroll 41 percent.
More Texas students attended public universities than two-year schools until the middle 1990s.
The coordinating board projects that as much as 70 percent of Texas' higher education enrollment will be at community colleges by 2015.
The strains already can be seen throughout the fast-growing North Harris Montgomery Community College District. At Cy-Fair College, the district's five-year-old campus in the northwest suburbs, enrollment soared 10 percent to 11,826 students this fall.
Montgomery College, in The Woodlands, has seen its enrollment increase by 8 percent to 8,810 students. To handle the surge, the campus has added portable classrooms and used storage space for faculty offices.
"Everyone would rather go to a university," said Garrett Anderson, who plans to transfer from Montgomery College to a four-year school next year. "But you can do your basics here for a fraction of the cost."
The cost of attending the state's public universities has increased steadily since the Legislature deregulated tuition. Texans now pay an average of $6,437 a year at the four-year schools, compared with $6,185 nationally.
Meanwhile, Texas community colleges charge $1,695 on average, which is less than those in all but three other states and well below the national average.
Before tuition deregulation, Brazosport College charged about a third the average published price of the state's public universities. It's now about a fifth the cost, said Millicent Valek, the college's president.
"Most families in Texas are being priced out of higher education," said Valek, who also chairs the Texas Association of Community Colleges. "Beginning at a community college is becoming more and more common."
Hispanic students now account for more than half the new college students statewide.
A recent national report found that highly qualified Hispanic students often give cost, proximity to home and campus atmosphere priority over prestige in choosing their schools. Thus, they typically enroll first at community colleges.
Natalia Castillo, a 20-year-old Colombia native, said she chose Houston Community College to sharpen her English skills before pursuing an advertising degree elsewhere.
"I'm happy with my education," Castillo said. "HCC is a good school."
Its enrollment, however, declined 3 percent to 36,032 students this fall. This week, HCC launched a new marketing campaign and pledged to become the nation's "most relevant community college" by adding more academic programs, among other improvements.
According to 12th-day fall figures, enrollment increased at Prairie View A&M University, Sam Houston State University, Texas A&M University and the University of Texas at Austin. The University of Houston held at 34,540 students.
Texas Southern University, in Houston, saw enrollment decrease by 10 percent, most of any state public university, according to the coordinating board's figures. But school officials acknowledged a 15 percent drop. Many students left after the 12th day.
matthew.tresaugue@chron.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)