What a great approach and use of technology for language acquisition. I'm tempted to say "revolutionary" given the name of the middle school. -Patricia
By WINNIE HU | NY Times
October 9, 2007
A ban on iPods is so strictly enforced at José Martí Middle School that as many as three a week are confiscated from students -- and returned only to their parents.
But even as students have been told to leave their iPods at home, the school here in Hudson County has been handing out the portable digital players to help bilingual students with limited English ability sharpen their vocabulary and grammar by singing along to popular songs.
Next month, the Union City district will give out 300 iPods at its schools as part of a $130,000 experiment in one of New Jersey's poorest urban school systems. The effort has spurred a handful of other districts in the state, including the ones in Perth Amboy and South Brunswick, to start their own iPod programs in the last year, and the project has drawn the attention of educators from Westchester County to Monrovia, Calif.
The spread of iPods into classrooms comes at a time when many school districts across the country have outlawed the portable players from their buildings -- along with cellphones and DVD players -- because they pose a distraction, or worse, to students. In some cases, students have been caught cheating on tests by loading answers, mathematical formulas and notes onto their iPods.
But some schools are rethinking the iPod bans as they try to co-opt the devices for educational purposes. Last month, the Perth Amboy district bought 40 iPods for students to use in bilingual classes that are modeled after those in Union City. In South Brunswick, 20 iPods were used last spring in French and Spanish classes. And in North Plainfield, N.J., the district has supplied iPods to science teachers to illustrate chemistry concepts, and it is considering allowing students in those classes to use iPods that they have brought from home.
''It's an innovation,'' said Frank Belluscio, a spokesman for the New Jersey School Boards Association, which selected Union City educators to speak about the iPod classes at the group's annual conference in Atlantic City Oct. 24-26. ''Most people think of the iPod as just entertainment.''
At José Martí, the silver iPods, with built-in video screens, cost about $250 each and are passed out at the beginning of class along with headsets and Spanish-to-English dictionaries. The iPods are collected at the end of class, and school officials said that none have disappeared or been broken.
In one recent class, eighth-grade students mouthed the words to the rock song ''Hey There Delilah'' by the Plain White T's as they played the tune on the iPods over and over again. The braver ones sang out loud.
''It speaks to me,'' said Stephanie Rojas, 13, who moved here last year from Puerto Rico and now prefers to sing in English. ''I take a long time in the shower because I'm singing, and my brothers are like, 'Hurry up!'''
Pedro Noguera, a sociology professor at New York University who studies urban schools, said that more districts were using new technologies like iPods to connect with students. For instance, he said, teachers have designed video games around history lessons and assigned students to re-enact novels and plays on YouTube.
''You know the No. 1 complaint about school is that it's boring because the traditional way it's taught relies on passive learning,'' Mr. Noguera said. ''It's not interactive enough.''
In many affluent communities, iPods have evolved into an essential accessory for students. In 2004, Duke University led the way by outfitting its entire freshman class with iPods that were preloaded with orientation information and even the Duke fight song. While Duke no longer gives away iPods, it maintains a pool of them that are lent to students for classes. Last spring, 93 of the 2,000 or so courses at Duke required iPods.
The Brearley School, a private girls school on Manhattan's Upper East Side, has used iPods to supplement foreign-language textbooks and its music, drama and English classes. Every Brearley student in seventh through ninth grades is required to buy or rent an iPod.
Here in Union City, the iPods are a splurge for many of the immigrant families who live in this densely packed urban center, once known for its embroidery factories. About 94 percent of the district's 11,000 students qualify for free or reduced lunches.
The Union City district, which has a $197 million annual budget, places a priority on bilingual classes because more than one-quarter of its students are learning basic English skills. District officials said the stakes are high; 4 of the district's 12 schools have been identified as needing improvement under the federal No Child Left Behind law, largely because not enough bilingual students have passed the state reading and math tests.
Grace Poli, a media specialist at José Martí, said that she approached district officials about buying 23 iPods for an after-school bilingual program in 2004 after being struck by students' passion for them. Spanish-speaking students seemed bored by their English-language textbooks, she said, which they found outdated and irrelevant.
The program became so popular that it was added to the regular school schedule the following year, and in 2006, Ms. Poli received 60 more iPods. Last May, the district decided to buy 300 iPods to expand the program to other schools this fall.
Ms. Poli scoured the music charts for songs that appealed to students, compiling an eclectic mix of tunes by Shania Twain, Barry White, U2 and the Black Eyed Peas. She downloaded their songs to the iPods and typed out the lyrics. Then she deleted all the nouns -- and in turn, the verbs and adjectives -- forcing the students to fill in the missing words and learn their meaning.
In class, they sing or recite the completed lyrics back to her.
''A lot of our bilingual kids are very shy, and they feel like outsiders,'' said Ms. Poli, whose parents immigrated from Ecuador. ''You have kids who never said a word in English, and now they're singing Black Eyed Peas. It was a lot of work, but it was worth it.''
Ms. Poli has also downloaded audio books, including the Harry Potter series, and added recording devices to the iPods so that students can listen to their pronunciation as they read poetry or talk with one another.
While the iPods have been used mainly in bilingual classes, the district plans to try them with students who have learning disabilities and behavioral problems as part of the program's expansion, which is set to begin next month. Last year, Ms. Poli helped an alternative education class create podcasts of test-taking tips that were shared with the entire school.
Ms. Poli said her Spanish-speaking students -- known around the school as Pod People -- have been able to move out of bilingual classes after just a year of using the digital devices, compared with an average of four to six years for most bilingual students.
Geri Perez, the principal at José Martí, said parents have requested that their children be enrolled in the iPod-equipped classes. Ms. Perez, who does not speak Spanish, said that bilingual students who once shied away from talking to her have gained self-confidence and now come up to her in the hallways.
Dianelis Cano, 13, who moved here from Cuba less than two years ago, said that she had learned so much English that her mother, a saleswoman in a clothing store, bought her an iPod over the summer as a reward for good grades. Dianelis loads her own songs onto the iPod to practice English outside school, though she also includes Spanish music.
''I'm going to check your iPod to make sure there is English music there,'' Ms. Poli teased her. ''I'm going to make home visits.''
This blog on Texas education contains posts on higher education, as well as preK-12 policy accountability, testing, bilingual education, immigration, school finance, race, class, and gender issues at both the state and national level. It also represents my digital footprint, of life and career, as a community-engaged scholar in Texas.
Thursday, October 18, 2007
High-quality standards, a curriculum based on critical thinking can enlighten our students
Linda Darling-Hammond | SF Gate.com
Sunday, October 14, 2007
One of the central lessons of No Child Left Behind is that if school sanctions are tied to test scores, the testing tail can wag the schooling dog. And a key problem for the United States is that most of our tests aren't measuring the kinds of 21st century skills we need students to acquire and that are at the core of curriculum and assessment in high-achieving countries.
While a debate rages about whether our tests should be created at the national or state level, this argument is focused on the wrong issue.
We need to focus on the quality of our standards and assessments rather than fighting over who administers them. Unless we change the way we think about learning and testing, it won't matter who makes the tests. They will still be a major part of the problem of American education, rather than the solution.
The plain truth is that the United States is falling far behind other nations on every measure of educational achievement. In the latest international assessments, the United States ranked 28th out of 40 countries in math - on par with Latvia - 20th in science, and 19th in reading, even further behind than a few years ago. In addition, these other countries surpass us in graduation rates and, over the last decade, in higher education participation as well.
Although 60 percent of our high school graduates go off to college, only half of these are well-enough prepared to graduate with a degree - far too few for the knowledge economy we now operate. So, while our own youth are often unprepared for modern employment, Silicon Valley lobbies for more H-1B visas to bring in skilled workers to fill high-tech jobs.
Among the highest-achieving countries, some - including Japan and Singapore - have national standards and tests. Others - such as China (where Hong Kong and Macao score well), Australia and Canada - have state-level standards and tests. Top-scoring Finland focuses primarily on local assessment. While these countries manage their systems differently, they have in common a curriculum focused on critical thinking, problem solving and examinations that require students to solve complex real-world problems and defend their ideas orally and in writing.
In most cases, their assessment systems combine centralized (state or national) assessments that use mostly open-ended and essay questions with local assessments given by teachers, which are factored into the final examination scores. These local assessments - which include research projects, science investigations, mathematical and computer models and other products - are mapped to the syllabus and the standards for the subject and are selected because they represent critical skills, topics and concepts. They are generally designed, administered and scored locally.
By contrast, our multiple-choice tests - which focus the curriculum on low-level skills - are helping us to fall further and further behind. Another part of the problem is that the standards used to guide teaching in many states are a mile wide and an inch deep: Most high-achieving countries teach (and test) fewer topics each year and teach them more thoroughly so students build a stronger foundation for their learning.
Whereas students in most parts of the United States are typically asked simply to recognize a single fact they have memorized from a list of answers, students in high-achieving countries are asked to apply their knowledge in the ways that writers, mathematicians, historians and scientists do.
In the United States, a typical item on the 12th grade National Assessment of Educational Progress, for example, asks students which two elements from a multiple choice list are found in the Earth's atmosphere. An item from the Victoria, Australia, high school biology test (which resembles those in Hong Kong and Singapore) describes how a particular virus works, asks students to design a drug to kill the virus and explain how the drug operates (complete with diagrams), and then to design and describe an experiment to test the drug - asking students to think and act like scientists.
Locally, students in other countries also complete required assessments like lab experiments and research papers that help evaluate student learning in the classroom. These assessments, which together count at least half the total examination score, allow the testing of complex skills that cannot be measured in a two-hour test on a single day. They ensure that students receive stronger learning opportunities. And they give teachers timely information they need to help students improve - something that standardized tests that produce scores several months later cannot do.
These assessments in other nations are not used to rank or punish schools, or to deny promotion or graduation to students. (In fact, several countries have explicit proscriptions against such practices.) They are used to evaluate curricula and guide professional learning - in short, to help schools improve.
By asking students to show what they know through real-world applications of knowledge, these other nations' assessment systems promote serious intellectual work that is discouraged in U.S. schools by the tests many states have adopted under No Child Left Behind. Although some states, such as high-scoring Connecticut, Maine, Vermont and Nebraska, have created assessments that resemble those in other countries, the requirements and costs of No Child have led an increasing number of states to abandon their challenging performance assessments for more simplistic machine-scored tests.
A growing body of research has shown that as more stakes become attached to such tests, teachers feel pressured to teach a multiple-choice curriculum that does not produce skills as they are used in the real world. Fully 85 percent of teachers in a recent poll said they feel the tests encourage them to teach in ways that are counterproductive.
As one teacher put it: "I have seen more students who can pass the (state test) but cannot apply those skills to anything if it's not in the test format.
I have students who can do the test but can't look up words in a dictionary and understand the different meanings. ... As for higher-quality teaching, I'm not sure I would call it that. Because of the pressure for passing scores, more and more time is spent practicing the test and putting everything in test format."
Studies confirm that as teaching looks more like testing, U.S. students are doing less writing, less science, less history, reading fewer books, and even using computers less in states that will not allow their use on standardized tests.
Indeed, as state test scores have gone up under No Child Left Behind, scores on other tests measuring broader skills have not. Data on the National Assessment of Educational Progress show that the rate of improvement in math achievement has slowed considerably since No Child was passed in 2002, and reading achievement has completely stalled, with declines at the eighth-grade level. This is likely because a test prep curriculum in the early grades does not provide the foundation that students need to do higher-level work later on.
We need to encourage our schools to teach and evaluate the higher-order thinking and performance skills that leading nations emphasize in their systems, and this requires major changes in No Child Left Behind.
The draft House bill for reauthorizing No Child, under the leadership of the chairman, Rep. George Miller, D-Martinez, would begin to rectify this situation by permitting states to use a broader set of assessments and encouraging the development and use of performance assessments, like those used abroad.
These changes, though not yet as far-reaching as they ultimately need to be, are a necessary step in the direction needed to create a globally competitive curriculum in U.S. schools.
As the House bill is revised and the Senate bill is drafted in the coming weeks, creating the incentives for a 21st century education system - rather than one pointed at the factory model of the past - should be a leading priority.
Linda Darling-Hammond is the Charles E. Ducommun professor of education at Stanford University, where she has created the Stanford Educational Leadership Institute and the School Redesign Network. Contact us at insight@sfchronicle.com.
Sunday, October 14, 2007
One of the central lessons of No Child Left Behind is that if school sanctions are tied to test scores, the testing tail can wag the schooling dog. And a key problem for the United States is that most of our tests aren't measuring the kinds of 21st century skills we need students to acquire and that are at the core of curriculum and assessment in high-achieving countries.
While a debate rages about whether our tests should be created at the national or state level, this argument is focused on the wrong issue.
We need to focus on the quality of our standards and assessments rather than fighting over who administers them. Unless we change the way we think about learning and testing, it won't matter who makes the tests. They will still be a major part of the problem of American education, rather than the solution.
The plain truth is that the United States is falling far behind other nations on every measure of educational achievement. In the latest international assessments, the United States ranked 28th out of 40 countries in math - on par with Latvia - 20th in science, and 19th in reading, even further behind than a few years ago. In addition, these other countries surpass us in graduation rates and, over the last decade, in higher education participation as well.
Although 60 percent of our high school graduates go off to college, only half of these are well-enough prepared to graduate with a degree - far too few for the knowledge economy we now operate. So, while our own youth are often unprepared for modern employment, Silicon Valley lobbies for more H-1B visas to bring in skilled workers to fill high-tech jobs.
Among the highest-achieving countries, some - including Japan and Singapore - have national standards and tests. Others - such as China (where Hong Kong and Macao score well), Australia and Canada - have state-level standards and tests. Top-scoring Finland focuses primarily on local assessment. While these countries manage their systems differently, they have in common a curriculum focused on critical thinking, problem solving and examinations that require students to solve complex real-world problems and defend their ideas orally and in writing.
In most cases, their assessment systems combine centralized (state or national) assessments that use mostly open-ended and essay questions with local assessments given by teachers, which are factored into the final examination scores. These local assessments - which include research projects, science investigations, mathematical and computer models and other products - are mapped to the syllabus and the standards for the subject and are selected because they represent critical skills, topics and concepts. They are generally designed, administered and scored locally.
By contrast, our multiple-choice tests - which focus the curriculum on low-level skills - are helping us to fall further and further behind. Another part of the problem is that the standards used to guide teaching in many states are a mile wide and an inch deep: Most high-achieving countries teach (and test) fewer topics each year and teach them more thoroughly so students build a stronger foundation for their learning.
Whereas students in most parts of the United States are typically asked simply to recognize a single fact they have memorized from a list of answers, students in high-achieving countries are asked to apply their knowledge in the ways that writers, mathematicians, historians and scientists do.
In the United States, a typical item on the 12th grade National Assessment of Educational Progress, for example, asks students which two elements from a multiple choice list are found in the Earth's atmosphere. An item from the Victoria, Australia, high school biology test (which resembles those in Hong Kong and Singapore) describes how a particular virus works, asks students to design a drug to kill the virus and explain how the drug operates (complete with diagrams), and then to design and describe an experiment to test the drug - asking students to think and act like scientists.
Locally, students in other countries also complete required assessments like lab experiments and research papers that help evaluate student learning in the classroom. These assessments, which together count at least half the total examination score, allow the testing of complex skills that cannot be measured in a two-hour test on a single day. They ensure that students receive stronger learning opportunities. And they give teachers timely information they need to help students improve - something that standardized tests that produce scores several months later cannot do.
These assessments in other nations are not used to rank or punish schools, or to deny promotion or graduation to students. (In fact, several countries have explicit proscriptions against such practices.) They are used to evaluate curricula and guide professional learning - in short, to help schools improve.
By asking students to show what they know through real-world applications of knowledge, these other nations' assessment systems promote serious intellectual work that is discouraged in U.S. schools by the tests many states have adopted under No Child Left Behind. Although some states, such as high-scoring Connecticut, Maine, Vermont and Nebraska, have created assessments that resemble those in other countries, the requirements and costs of No Child have led an increasing number of states to abandon their challenging performance assessments for more simplistic machine-scored tests.
A growing body of research has shown that as more stakes become attached to such tests, teachers feel pressured to teach a multiple-choice curriculum that does not produce skills as they are used in the real world. Fully 85 percent of teachers in a recent poll said they feel the tests encourage them to teach in ways that are counterproductive.
As one teacher put it: "I have seen more students who can pass the (state test) but cannot apply those skills to anything if it's not in the test format.
I have students who can do the test but can't look up words in a dictionary and understand the different meanings. ... As for higher-quality teaching, I'm not sure I would call it that. Because of the pressure for passing scores, more and more time is spent practicing the test and putting everything in test format."
Studies confirm that as teaching looks more like testing, U.S. students are doing less writing, less science, less history, reading fewer books, and even using computers less in states that will not allow their use on standardized tests.
Indeed, as state test scores have gone up under No Child Left Behind, scores on other tests measuring broader skills have not. Data on the National Assessment of Educational Progress show that the rate of improvement in math achievement has slowed considerably since No Child was passed in 2002, and reading achievement has completely stalled, with declines at the eighth-grade level. This is likely because a test prep curriculum in the early grades does not provide the foundation that students need to do higher-level work later on.
We need to encourage our schools to teach and evaluate the higher-order thinking and performance skills that leading nations emphasize in their systems, and this requires major changes in No Child Left Behind.
The draft House bill for reauthorizing No Child, under the leadership of the chairman, Rep. George Miller, D-Martinez, would begin to rectify this situation by permitting states to use a broader set of assessments and encouraging the development and use of performance assessments, like those used abroad.
These changes, though not yet as far-reaching as they ultimately need to be, are a necessary step in the direction needed to create a globally competitive curriculum in U.S. schools.
As the House bill is revised and the Senate bill is drafted in the coming weeks, creating the incentives for a 21st century education system - rather than one pointed at the factory model of the past - should be a leading priority.
Linda Darling-Hammond is the Charles E. Ducommun professor of education at Stanford University, where she has created the Stanford Educational Leadership Institute and the School Redesign Network. Contact us at insight@sfchronicle.com.
Small's best - tale from the Bronx
John Crace, Guardian
October 15, 2007
In the school size debate, the New York model is instructive, writes John Crace.
IT MAY not have the burnt-out tenements of Bonfire of the Vanities but the north Bronx is still the kind of neighbourhood that looks to have seen much better days.
Then again, it's hard to know if the Kennedy High School campus ever had a good day; surrounded by high wire fencing and with a vast, eight-storey concrete structure at its core, it looks more like a correction centre. In fact, Kennedy has its own force of more than 160 full-time police officers, and all students go through airport-style security at the entrance, creating long queues and delays.
Yet education policy advisers are now wondering if this could be a model for other secondary schools. So what's going on?
The only clue is a series of five Hogwarts-style heraldic shields high up on the front wall. Kennedy isn't one school; it's five.
Ten years ago, the city's high schools, with few exceptions, were magnets for violence and under-achievement. And Kennedy was up there with the very worst. With more than 4000 students from one of the most deprived areas in New York, it was rife with gang warfare and survival was often a higher priority than education.
Fewer than 40 per cent ever managed to graduate with even the lowest, local diploma.
Since the 1980s, the New York education department priority was to improve pre-kindergarten, elementary and middle schools - the theory being that if children got the basics right early on, then the problems in high school would start to sort themselves out. Yet the key issues of low expectations, few learning supports, student alienation and a curriculum lacking relevance to post-secondary were completely neglected - seen as too difficult.
Then, about 2000, several wealthy charitable organisations, including the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Carnegie Corporation, got involved, putting up big bucks to support those committed to changing failing high schools.
In 2001 New Visions, a New York-based education reform organisation, joined forces with the New York City department of education to launch the New Century High Schools Initiative (NCHSI).
Throughout the 1990s, New Visions had helped to create about 30 small elementary, middle and high schools across the city and the NCHSI was the ideal platform to develop 200 more. "There's no set curriculum," says Lili Brown, one of its vice-presidents. "Instead we prefer to think of disciplined innovation. There are core performance and attendance targets and each school must adhere to our principles of effectiveness but, within these parameters, there is flexibility for educators, administrators and non-profit organisations to create schools that fit in with the aspirations of the local community."
The idea that students might do better in a small school, where it is easier to implement personalised learning programs, is a bit of a no-brainer. Making it a reality is more of a headache. You can't just bulldoze a concrete campus and build five new ones, because it's too expensive and time-consuming even for the Bill Gates squillions. Iris Zucker was head of Morris High School in south Bronx when she and her deputy, Kirsten Larson, decided to join the project. "We set out to give it (their school) an international identity by taking 50 per cent English language speakers and 50 per cent English language learners."
The result, Marble Hill School for International Studies, began in September 2002 but missed the city's deadline for students in 8th grade making their high school applications, so none of its first cohort of roughly 100 had selected the school. It wasn't easy for the teaching staff, either; the school was initially just five rooms on the top floor of the Kennedy campus. The other teachers in the main Kennedy school refused to let them eat in their canteen. "I suppose it felt to them as if we were unwanted lodgers who had turned up uninvited," says Larson, who this year took over from Zucker as Marble Hill head, trying to be diplomatic. "They just felt a bit threatened by us."
By the end of first year, Marble Hill students were outperforming their expected academic and attendance rates and the school had more than 600 for applications for its second intake.
The small school movement had made its point, and five years on, there are now three other schools of roughly 430 students each co-existing with the Kennedy High School and Marble Hill on the same site.
Marble Hill now has a graduation rate of 94 per cent but Zucker insists it's not just size that matters. "What you have to do is use the advantages size brings; roughly half of all our students are following their own personalised learning plans - a percentage that would be almost unachievable in a larger setting."
It is also raised expectations.
"Virtually none of our students had ever been to an off-Broadway show in Manhattan before they came here," Larson says. "We have now been on trips to Senegal and China and the kids can't wait for the next one.
"We're also beginning to make a name for ourselves outside the city; we have a student who was moving to the Bronx from North Carolina and picked us because we offered Japanese, and one of our graduates was recently awarded a Fulbright scholarship to a top college."
First-year student Diana Ryan chose Marble Hill for its opportunities - "I wanted an education with a global perspective. Marble Hill seemed more interesting and challenging than other schools and I want to join the peace corps when I leave" - while 12th-grader Wahdah al Shugaa, who has been there since the second year, finds peace enough at school. "Here I can get on with my work with no interruptions."
While Marble Hill is working, the other schools on the Kennedy campus don't look nearly as inviting, and few other small schools across the city are getting quite such spectacular results, though they are still consistently out-performing the huge, 4000-student high schools.
No-one is pretending it's all perfect. Gang culture hasn't been entirely eliminated, though principals keep the schools apart by staggering start, lesson and meal times and banning students from each other's premises.
Even so, all the evidence suggests small schools work. -- GUARDIAN
October 15, 2007
In the school size debate, the New York model is instructive, writes John Crace.
IT MAY not have the burnt-out tenements of Bonfire of the Vanities but the north Bronx is still the kind of neighbourhood that looks to have seen much better days.
Then again, it's hard to know if the Kennedy High School campus ever had a good day; surrounded by high wire fencing and with a vast, eight-storey concrete structure at its core, it looks more like a correction centre. In fact, Kennedy has its own force of more than 160 full-time police officers, and all students go through airport-style security at the entrance, creating long queues and delays.
Yet education policy advisers are now wondering if this could be a model for other secondary schools. So what's going on?
The only clue is a series of five Hogwarts-style heraldic shields high up on the front wall. Kennedy isn't one school; it's five.
Ten years ago, the city's high schools, with few exceptions, were magnets for violence and under-achievement. And Kennedy was up there with the very worst. With more than 4000 students from one of the most deprived areas in New York, it was rife with gang warfare and survival was often a higher priority than education.
Fewer than 40 per cent ever managed to graduate with even the lowest, local diploma.
Since the 1980s, the New York education department priority was to improve pre-kindergarten, elementary and middle schools - the theory being that if children got the basics right early on, then the problems in high school would start to sort themselves out. Yet the key issues of low expectations, few learning supports, student alienation and a curriculum lacking relevance to post-secondary were completely neglected - seen as too difficult.
Then, about 2000, several wealthy charitable organisations, including the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Carnegie Corporation, got involved, putting up big bucks to support those committed to changing failing high schools.
In 2001 New Visions, a New York-based education reform organisation, joined forces with the New York City department of education to launch the New Century High Schools Initiative (NCHSI).
Throughout the 1990s, New Visions had helped to create about 30 small elementary, middle and high schools across the city and the NCHSI was the ideal platform to develop 200 more. "There's no set curriculum," says Lili Brown, one of its vice-presidents. "Instead we prefer to think of disciplined innovation. There are core performance and attendance targets and each school must adhere to our principles of effectiveness but, within these parameters, there is flexibility for educators, administrators and non-profit organisations to create schools that fit in with the aspirations of the local community."
The idea that students might do better in a small school, where it is easier to implement personalised learning programs, is a bit of a no-brainer. Making it a reality is more of a headache. You can't just bulldoze a concrete campus and build five new ones, because it's too expensive and time-consuming even for the Bill Gates squillions. Iris Zucker was head of Morris High School in south Bronx when she and her deputy, Kirsten Larson, decided to join the project. "We set out to give it (their school) an international identity by taking 50 per cent English language speakers and 50 per cent English language learners."
The result, Marble Hill School for International Studies, began in September 2002 but missed the city's deadline for students in 8th grade making their high school applications, so none of its first cohort of roughly 100 had selected the school. It wasn't easy for the teaching staff, either; the school was initially just five rooms on the top floor of the Kennedy campus. The other teachers in the main Kennedy school refused to let them eat in their canteen. "I suppose it felt to them as if we were unwanted lodgers who had turned up uninvited," says Larson, who this year took over from Zucker as Marble Hill head, trying to be diplomatic. "They just felt a bit threatened by us."
By the end of first year, Marble Hill students were outperforming their expected academic and attendance rates and the school had more than 600 for applications for its second intake.
The small school movement had made its point, and five years on, there are now three other schools of roughly 430 students each co-existing with the Kennedy High School and Marble Hill on the same site.
Marble Hill now has a graduation rate of 94 per cent but Zucker insists it's not just size that matters. "What you have to do is use the advantages size brings; roughly half of all our students are following their own personalised learning plans - a percentage that would be almost unachievable in a larger setting."
It is also raised expectations.
"Virtually none of our students had ever been to an off-Broadway show in Manhattan before they came here," Larson says. "We have now been on trips to Senegal and China and the kids can't wait for the next one.
"We're also beginning to make a name for ourselves outside the city; we have a student who was moving to the Bronx from North Carolina and picked us because we offered Japanese, and one of our graduates was recently awarded a Fulbright scholarship to a top college."
First-year student Diana Ryan chose Marble Hill for its opportunities - "I wanted an education with a global perspective. Marble Hill seemed more interesting and challenging than other schools and I want to join the peace corps when I leave" - while 12th-grader Wahdah al Shugaa, who has been there since the second year, finds peace enough at school. "Here I can get on with my work with no interruptions."
While Marble Hill is working, the other schools on the Kennedy campus don't look nearly as inviting, and few other small schools across the city are getting quite such spectacular results, though they are still consistently out-performing the huge, 4000-student high schools.
No-one is pretending it's all perfect. Gang culture hasn't been entirely eliminated, though principals keep the schools apart by staggering start, lesson and meal times and banning students from each other's premises.
Even so, all the evidence suggests small schools work. -- GUARDIAN
Tuesday, October 16, 2007
Youths Air Grievances at City Hall Forum
By Nikita Stewart
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, October 14, 2007; Page C12
Dozens of young people ages 11 to 21 painted a bleak picture of the District's public school system yesterday during the D.C. Council's first hearing on youth issues, a monthly free-for-all allowing those 21 and younger to talk about topics that affect them.
The council chambers at the John A. Wilson Building was so packed that people spilled out into the hallway during the seven-hour hearing. Another room was opened to accommodate the overflow.
Youths focused overwhelmingly on the school system, describing students who disrupt classes and teachers who don't teach. They also worried about violence in their neighborhoods and a lack of extracurricular and after-school activities.
Hezekiel Gregory, 11, told council members that "someone came to school with a knife" when he was enrolled at Harriet Tubman Elementary School. He now attends a public charter school, where he said he learns more and feels safer.
Council Chairman Vincent C. Gray (D) said he held the session, televised live on cable in the city, because he was so inspired by the number of young people who showed up for a hearing in February on the mayor's school takeover plan. All told, 59 youths testified yesterday.
The council approved the takeover, allowing Mayor Adrian M. Fenty (D) to take the helm of public schools. Although some facilities are improving, most students said their education is not.
Francisco Velasquez, 17, a senior at Dunbar Senior High School, said he had a teacher who gave only two tests during an entire semester, both of which were "open notes." Victoria Cortez, 16, a junior at Wilson Senior High School, said one of her teachers "has his days when he doesn't feel like teaching."
"That's usually every Friday," she said.
Bright spots included testimony about nonprofits that are working with young people. Some students smiled and giggled about teachers who had reached out to them or made learning fun. Velasquez lit up when he talked about the history teacher he had last year. "He was really a good teacher," he said.
When Tiara Brawner, 17, testified about her education at H.D. Woodson Senior High School, she said "Mr. P" was her favorite teacher. "If you're watching, Mr. P, don't say I didn't acknowledge you," she said.
Mr. P is math teacher Aris Pangilinan; none of the students could pronounce his last name.
But some students said that there are not enough teachers and support staff at their schools and that the good instructors can't do their jobs because of troublesome students.
Donnell Kie, a junior at Ballou Senior High School, said there is only one counselor for more than 300 students. Other speakers said they need guidance on how to find decent housing, jobs and higher education options after graduation.
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, October 14, 2007; Page C12
Dozens of young people ages 11 to 21 painted a bleak picture of the District's public school system yesterday during the D.C. Council's first hearing on youth issues, a monthly free-for-all allowing those 21 and younger to talk about topics that affect them.
The council chambers at the John A. Wilson Building was so packed that people spilled out into the hallway during the seven-hour hearing. Another room was opened to accommodate the overflow.
Youths focused overwhelmingly on the school system, describing students who disrupt classes and teachers who don't teach. They also worried about violence in their neighborhoods and a lack of extracurricular and after-school activities.
Hezekiel Gregory, 11, told council members that "someone came to school with a knife" when he was enrolled at Harriet Tubman Elementary School. He now attends a public charter school, where he said he learns more and feels safer.
Council Chairman Vincent C. Gray (D) said he held the session, televised live on cable in the city, because he was so inspired by the number of young people who showed up for a hearing in February on the mayor's school takeover plan. All told, 59 youths testified yesterday.
The council approved the takeover, allowing Mayor Adrian M. Fenty (D) to take the helm of public schools. Although some facilities are improving, most students said their education is not.
Francisco Velasquez, 17, a senior at Dunbar Senior High School, said he had a teacher who gave only two tests during an entire semester, both of which were "open notes." Victoria Cortez, 16, a junior at Wilson Senior High School, said one of her teachers "has his days when he doesn't feel like teaching."
"That's usually every Friday," she said.
Bright spots included testimony about nonprofits that are working with young people. Some students smiled and giggled about teachers who had reached out to them or made learning fun. Velasquez lit up when he talked about the history teacher he had last year. "He was really a good teacher," he said.
When Tiara Brawner, 17, testified about her education at H.D. Woodson Senior High School, she said "Mr. P" was her favorite teacher. "If you're watching, Mr. P, don't say I didn't acknowledge you," she said.
Mr. P is math teacher Aris Pangilinan; none of the students could pronounce his last name.
But some students said that there are not enough teachers and support staff at their schools and that the good instructors can't do their jobs because of troublesome students.
Donnell Kie, a junior at Ballou Senior High School, said there is only one counselor for more than 300 students. Other speakers said they need guidance on how to find decent housing, jobs and higher education options after graduation.
Capitol security at issue in court fight over videotapes
This is very interesting. This is a case that might makeit to the Texas Supreme Court. Access to the tapes has become a looming issue despite the fact that what started all this was a request for the tapes in order to see if philanthropist, pro-voucher supporter and funder, James Leininger, violated the law during the 2003 legislative session. We should all stay tuned to see how all of this develops.
A larger issue, of course, is freedom of the press, a constitutional right.
-Angela
Capitol security at issue in court fight over videotapes
DPS has spent $165,000 in effort to keep information from the public.
By Mark Lisheron
AMERICAN-STATESMAN STAFF
Sunday, October 14, 2007
Over the past two years, the Department of Public Safety has sent more than $165,000 of taxpayer money on attorney's fees to keep videotapes recorded by security cameras in a back hall of the Capitol secret. The case could go to the Texas Supreme Court — despite rulings by the attorney general and a state district judge that the tapes should be made public.
The agency has insisted from the start that it will not give the tapes to the Texas Observer, a small-circulation, nonprofit investigative newspaper, because they reveal details that would compromise security at the Capitol. Attorney General Greg Abbott and District Judge Stephen Yelenosky have ruled that argument baseless.
Undaunted, the DPS is pressing on. Its attorneys are scheduled to make their case again Oct. 24 before a panel of three judges at the 3rd Court of Appeals.
The department's persistence in the matter has infuriated the chairman of the state Senate's Transportation and Homeland Security Committee. Sen. John Carona has promised his committee will find out how the case has been allowed to go on this long. The committee is expected to meet in November.
"The DPS is simply wrong on this issue," said Carona, R-Dallas. "This has nothing to do with security. I can think of no conceivable reason why DPS should be using taxpayer funds to hire private attorneys. This is simply an agency giving political cover for the Legislature. This is a misuse of public funds."
DPS Director Tommy Davis declined to comment because the case is pending, a spokesman for the department said. Raymond White, the attorney representing DPS, did not return telephone calls.
Ernest Angelo Jr., chairman of the Public Safety Commission, a panel of appointees overseeing the department, defended the decision to hire private counsel with tax dollars.
"Security is the issue," Angelo said last week. "Obviously, we decided there was a principle to defend the agency's security measures. Any time you hire lawyers, it's going to cost big bucks."
Gov. Rick Perry, who appointed Angelo and is responsible for the other four appointments to the Public Safety Commission, has taken no position on the case because it is still being argued, spokeswoman Krista Moody said. Perry believes DPS has followed proper procedures in the case, Moody said.
The saga began on May 26, 2005, when the Austin-based Texas Observer made a formal request to the DPS, which oversees Capitol security, under the Texas Public Information Act, for tapes recorded on May 23, 2005.
Jake Bernstein, executive editor of the biweekly newspaper, was trying to verify rumors that on that day James Leininger, one of the state's wealthiest Republican campaign donors, was in the hall behind the House chamber lobbying lawmakers to pass a pilot school voucher program. Such lobbying just outside the chamber is against House rules.
An amendment to launch the pilot program failed in the House, and the DPS denied the Observer's request, citing the Texas Homeland Security Act.
The videotapes "contain critical, sensitive information that relates to many specifications, operating procedures and locations of the Capitol security system, of which they are an integral part," according to a DPS brief filed with the appellate court. A terrorist could capitalize on such information, compromising the ability of the department to protect people who work in or visit the Capitol.
After reviewing the tapes, Assistant Attorney General Ramsey Abarca wrote to DPS staff counsel on Aug. 26, 2005, that their contents had nothing to do with security.
"The department has not adequately shown how the submitted video taken from Capitol security cameras relates to the specifications, operating procedures, or location of a security system used to protect public property from an act of terrorism," Abarca wrote in a letter to DPS counsel. The department, Abarca said, must release the video to the Observer.
The department responded by asking the attorney general for permission to hire private lawyers to get the opinion of a district judge. On April 12, Yelenosky ruled that the DPS had five days to turn over the tapes. DPS attorneys immediately filed an appeal.
Bernstein said he thinks that speculation by Carona and others that the DPS is perpetrating some kind of political cover-up is off-base. Bernstein said he believes the department is convinced that giving up the tapes will set a precedent that will leave security vulnerable to increasingly intrusive open records requests.
The case for the Observer has become far less about Leininger's whereabouts and much more about the DPS abusing homeland security law at considerable expense to taxpayers, Bernstein said. When the Observer made an open records request to obtain invoices for its legal fees, the DPS complied, and the newspaper posted them on its Web site in late September.
"Beyond this being a frivolous lawsuit, what I find a little depressing is the DPS is proceeding like there is this bottomless bag of money from which to draw," Bernstein said. "It just never occurred to us that they would carry this as far as they have."
Should the department lose its appeal, Angelo said, he expects to take and supports taking the case before the Texas Supreme Court. Not only could taxpayer-funded legal fees double by then, but attorneys for the Observer could demand reimbursement from the state if the Supreme Court were to side with the newspaper.
So far, Kator, Parks & Weiser, an Austin law firm, has represented the Observer for no charge, in sympathy with the newspaper's open records argument, said Jeremy Wright, the lawyer assigned to the case. The firm will have rung up more than $75,000 in fees by the time the appeal is completed and could easily top $100,000 if the case reaches the state Supreme Court, he said.
"Their argument has been the same from the beginning," Wright said. "What you have is the government using the Homeland Security Act as an excuse to keep from the public basic information they are entitled to."
Carona said he is impatient with an increasing tendency of state agencies to go to court rather than give up materials the attorney general deems public. The number of lawsuits filed challenging an attorney general's ruling that records be made public was 88 in 2006, up from 76 in 2005 and 64 in 2004, according to the attorney general's records.
Whether the Public Safety Commission will continue to support the legal blockade cannot be determined because the commission lacks a quorum. Last session, the Legislature approved adding two seats to the three-member commission. Angelo continues as chairman, and Perry recently appointed San Antonio attorney Allan Polunsky to replace Louis Sturns, who stepped down to take an appointment as judge in Tarrant County District Court. The three other commission appointments remain unfilled.
The DPS position continues to have support from the top. "I'm a taxpayer too, but with the importance of homeland security, I think we have an obligation to follow this case to the end," Angelo said. "A lot of cases don't get resolved until you take them to the top."
mlisheron@statesman.com; 445-3663
Find this article at:
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/region/legislature/stories/10/14/1014tape.html
A larger issue, of course, is freedom of the press, a constitutional right.
-Angela
Capitol security at issue in court fight over videotapes
DPS has spent $165,000 in effort to keep information from the public.
By Mark Lisheron
AMERICAN-STATESMAN STAFF
Sunday, October 14, 2007
Over the past two years, the Department of Public Safety has sent more than $165,000 of taxpayer money on attorney's fees to keep videotapes recorded by security cameras in a back hall of the Capitol secret. The case could go to the Texas Supreme Court — despite rulings by the attorney general and a state district judge that the tapes should be made public.
The agency has insisted from the start that it will not give the tapes to the Texas Observer, a small-circulation, nonprofit investigative newspaper, because they reveal details that would compromise security at the Capitol. Attorney General Greg Abbott and District Judge Stephen Yelenosky have ruled that argument baseless.
Undaunted, the DPS is pressing on. Its attorneys are scheduled to make their case again Oct. 24 before a panel of three judges at the 3rd Court of Appeals.
The department's persistence in the matter has infuriated the chairman of the state Senate's Transportation and Homeland Security Committee. Sen. John Carona has promised his committee will find out how the case has been allowed to go on this long. The committee is expected to meet in November.
"The DPS is simply wrong on this issue," said Carona, R-Dallas. "This has nothing to do with security. I can think of no conceivable reason why DPS should be using taxpayer funds to hire private attorneys. This is simply an agency giving political cover for the Legislature. This is a misuse of public funds."
DPS Director Tommy Davis declined to comment because the case is pending, a spokesman for the department said. Raymond White, the attorney representing DPS, did not return telephone calls.
Ernest Angelo Jr., chairman of the Public Safety Commission, a panel of appointees overseeing the department, defended the decision to hire private counsel with tax dollars.
"Security is the issue," Angelo said last week. "Obviously, we decided there was a principle to defend the agency's security measures. Any time you hire lawyers, it's going to cost big bucks."
Gov. Rick Perry, who appointed Angelo and is responsible for the other four appointments to the Public Safety Commission, has taken no position on the case because it is still being argued, spokeswoman Krista Moody said. Perry believes DPS has followed proper procedures in the case, Moody said.
The saga began on May 26, 2005, when the Austin-based Texas Observer made a formal request to the DPS, which oversees Capitol security, under the Texas Public Information Act, for tapes recorded on May 23, 2005.
Jake Bernstein, executive editor of the biweekly newspaper, was trying to verify rumors that on that day James Leininger, one of the state's wealthiest Republican campaign donors, was in the hall behind the House chamber lobbying lawmakers to pass a pilot school voucher program. Such lobbying just outside the chamber is against House rules.
An amendment to launch the pilot program failed in the House, and the DPS denied the Observer's request, citing the Texas Homeland Security Act.
The videotapes "contain critical, sensitive information that relates to many specifications, operating procedures and locations of the Capitol security system, of which they are an integral part," according to a DPS brief filed with the appellate court. A terrorist could capitalize on such information, compromising the ability of the department to protect people who work in or visit the Capitol.
After reviewing the tapes, Assistant Attorney General Ramsey Abarca wrote to DPS staff counsel on Aug. 26, 2005, that their contents had nothing to do with security.
"The department has not adequately shown how the submitted video taken from Capitol security cameras relates to the specifications, operating procedures, or location of a security system used to protect public property from an act of terrorism," Abarca wrote in a letter to DPS counsel. The department, Abarca said, must release the video to the Observer.
The department responded by asking the attorney general for permission to hire private lawyers to get the opinion of a district judge. On April 12, Yelenosky ruled that the DPS had five days to turn over the tapes. DPS attorneys immediately filed an appeal.
Bernstein said he thinks that speculation by Carona and others that the DPS is perpetrating some kind of political cover-up is off-base. Bernstein said he believes the department is convinced that giving up the tapes will set a precedent that will leave security vulnerable to increasingly intrusive open records requests.
The case for the Observer has become far less about Leininger's whereabouts and much more about the DPS abusing homeland security law at considerable expense to taxpayers, Bernstein said. When the Observer made an open records request to obtain invoices for its legal fees, the DPS complied, and the newspaper posted them on its Web site in late September.
"Beyond this being a frivolous lawsuit, what I find a little depressing is the DPS is proceeding like there is this bottomless bag of money from which to draw," Bernstein said. "It just never occurred to us that they would carry this as far as they have."
Should the department lose its appeal, Angelo said, he expects to take and supports taking the case before the Texas Supreme Court. Not only could taxpayer-funded legal fees double by then, but attorneys for the Observer could demand reimbursement from the state if the Supreme Court were to side with the newspaper.
So far, Kator, Parks & Weiser, an Austin law firm, has represented the Observer for no charge, in sympathy with the newspaper's open records argument, said Jeremy Wright, the lawyer assigned to the case. The firm will have rung up more than $75,000 in fees by the time the appeal is completed and could easily top $100,000 if the case reaches the state Supreme Court, he said.
"Their argument has been the same from the beginning," Wright said. "What you have is the government using the Homeland Security Act as an excuse to keep from the public basic information they are entitled to."
Carona said he is impatient with an increasing tendency of state agencies to go to court rather than give up materials the attorney general deems public. The number of lawsuits filed challenging an attorney general's ruling that records be made public was 88 in 2006, up from 76 in 2005 and 64 in 2004, according to the attorney general's records.
Whether the Public Safety Commission will continue to support the legal blockade cannot be determined because the commission lacks a quorum. Last session, the Legislature approved adding two seats to the three-member commission. Angelo continues as chairman, and Perry recently appointed San Antonio attorney Allan Polunsky to replace Louis Sturns, who stepped down to take an appointment as judge in Tarrant County District Court. The three other commission appointments remain unfilled.
The DPS position continues to have support from the top. "I'm a taxpayer too, but with the importance of homeland security, I think we have an obligation to follow this case to the end," Angelo said. "A lot of cases don't get resolved until you take them to the top."
mlisheron@statesman.com; 445-3663
Find this article at:
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/region/legislature/stories/10/14/1014tape.html
Failing Schools Strain to Meet U.S. Standard
Axel Koester for The New York TimesMartha Sanchez, who has three children in Los Angeles schools, picking up her daughter, Catherine, a third grader. Ms. Sanchez said that as students grew older, the schools seemed to give up.
This account reveals the prevailing need that our nation has to invest in our schools. This punishing approach adds insult to injury. -Angela
October 16, 2007
Failing Schools Strain to Meet U.S. Standard
By DIANA JEAN SCHEMO
LOS ANGELES — As the director of high schools in the gang-infested neighborhoods of the East Side of Los Angeles, Guadalupe Paramo struggles every day with educational dysfunction.
For the past half-dozen years, not even one in five students at her district’s teeming high schools has been able to do grade-level math or English. At Abraham Lincoln High School this year, only 7 in 100 students could. At Woodrow Wilson High, only 4 in 100 could.
For chronically failing schools like these, the No Child Left Behind law, now up for renewal in Congress, prescribes drastic measures: firing teachers and principals, shutting schools and turning them over to a private firm, a charter operator or the state itself, or a major overhaul in governance.
But more than 1,000 of California’s 9,500 schools are branded chronic failures, and the numbers are growing. Barring revisions in the law, state officials predict that all 6,063 public schools serving poor students will be declared in need of restructuring by 2014, when the law requires universal proficiency in math and reading.
“What are we supposed to do?” Ms. Paramo asked. “Shut down every school?”
With the education law now in its fifth year — the one in which its more severe penalties are supposed to come into wide play — California is not the only state overwhelmed by growing numbers of schools that cannot satisfy the law’s escalating demands.
In Florida, 441 schools could be candidates for closing. In Maryland, some 49 schools in Baltimore alone have fallen short of achievement targets for five years or more. In New York State, 77 schools were candidates for restructuring as of last year.
Some districts, like those in New York City, have moved forcefully to shut large failing high schools and break them into small schools. Los Angeles, too, is trying small schools, along with other innovations, and David L. Brewer III, its schools superintendent, has just announced plans to create a “high priority district” under his direct control made up of 40 problem schools.
Yet so far, education experts say they are unaware of a single state that has taken over a failing school in response to the law. Instead, most allow school districts to seek other ways to improve.
“When you have a state like California with so many schools up for restructuring,” said Heinrich Mintrop, an education professor at the University of California, Berkeley, “that taxes the capacity of the whole school change industry.”
As a result, the law is branding numerous schools as failing, but not producing radical change — leaving angry parents demanding redress. California citizens’ groups have sued the state and federal government for failing to deliver on the law’s promises.
“They’re so busy fighting No Child Left Behind,” said Mary Johnson, president of Parent U-Turn, a civic group. “If they would use some of that energy to implement the law, we would go farther.”
Ray Simon, the deputy federal secretary of education, said states that ignored the law’s demands risked losing federal money or facing restrictions on grants. For now, Mr. Simon said, the department is more interested in helping states figure out what works than in punishment. “Even a state has to struggle if it takes over a school,” he said.
A federal survey last year showed that in 87 percent of the cases of persistently failing schools, states and school districts avoided wholesale changes in staff or leadership. That is why, Mr. Simon said, the Bush administration is proposing that Congress force more action by limiting districts’ options in responding to hard-core failure.
In California, Jack O’Connell, the state superintendent of schools, calls the law’s demands unreasonable. Under the federal law, 700 schools that California believed were getting substantially better were counted last year as failing. A state takeover of schools, Mr. O’Connell said, would be a “last option.”
“To have a successful program,” he said, “it really has to come from the community.”
Under the No Child law, a school declared low-performing for three years in a row must offer students free tutoring and the option to transfer. After five years, such schools are essentially treated as irredeemable, with the law prescribing starting over with a new structure, new leadership or new teachers. But it also gives schools the option of less sweeping changes, like reducing school size or changing who is in charge of hiring.
Those in charge of troubled schools in Los Angeles admit that the absence of serious penalties coupled with the growing number of schools branded as low-performing is breeding bitterness. But they are not sure what to do.
Carmen Schroeder, the superintendent of District 5 — and Ms. Paramo’s boss — has taken over hiring decisions and keeps a close watch on the lowest performing schools. Ms. Schroeder said she would like to go further and shut some down if there were any place to transfer the students.
That is not so easy when 59 of the 91 schools in her district, the largest of eight in this sprawling city, consistently fall short of standards.
Beyond that, the federal law does not trump contract agreements, and so teachers have generally not lost their jobs or faced transfer when schools stagnate.
In Los Angeles, as the law’s 2014 deadline draws nearer, the promised land of universal high achievement seems more distant than ever.
Schools that serve low-income students are packed, despite new construction. In poor neighborhoods, students are on staggered schedules, starting school in different months and scattering what was once summer vacation into smaller breaks.
Students lose momentum, forget lessons and come out with 17 fewer days of instruction a year. “That’s why our kids are not passing the high school exit exams,” said Ms. Johnson of Parent U-Turn.
Not all states are facing huge numbers of failing schools. Some were late establishing testing systems, and so lack results over five or more years. Others may have small poor populations, better teaching or easier exams.
But the tensions voiced here are echoed by parents elsewhere, as well as by school officials.
At Woodrow Wilson High one recent morning, teachers broke into small groups over coffee studying test scores for areas of weakness. But there were limits to what they would learn.
The teachers analyzed results for the entire school, not for their own students. Roberto Martinez, the principal, said he had not given teachers the scores of their own students because their union objects, saying the scores were being used to evaluate teachers.
“And who suffers?” asked Veronica Garcia, an English teacher at Wilson. “The kids suffer, because the teacher never gets feedback.”
A. J. Duffy, president of United Teachers of Los Angeles, said the union supported test score reviews provided they did not affect teachers’ jobs. Mr. Duffy said the federal law glossed over the travails of teaching students living in poverty. “Everyone agrees that urban education needs a shot in the arm, but it is not as bleak as the naysayers would have it,” he said.
That is not a view shared by many parents. Martha Sanchez, whose three children attend public schools here, said that as students grew older, the schools seemed to give up.
Her eldest, Gonzalo, attends eighth grade at John Adams Middle School, where only 22 percent of students passed the state exams in English and math this year. It is not hard for Ms. Sanchez to see why.
When Gonzalo struggled over equations, she said, his teacher called him slow rather than going over the material again. Ms. Sanchez said that she had complained, but that the teacher had denied the comment. It was only through the private tutoring, available under No Child Left Behind that he managed to pass seventh grade math, she said.
The principal, Joseph P. Santana, said he did not recall Ms. Sanchez’s complaining, but could not rule it out. “There are 1,600 of them,” he said, referring to the students, “and only one of me.”
Still, Ms. Sanchez is not a big fan of the law. Just weeks into the school year, she said, teachers are focusing almost solely on material likely to appear on state exams. Forget about igniting a passion in children, she said.
“Maybe the system is not designed for people like us,” she said.
Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/16/education/16child.html?_r=1&th&emc=th&oref=slogin
Gloria Padilla: 'Community' helps students excel at community colleges
Gloria Padilla | San Antonio Express-News
10/12/2007
I did not realize just how small a minority I belong to as a graduate of a community college.
The number of students who graduate from community colleges, transfer to a four-year university and get a degree pales by comparison to the number of students who are enrolling in community colleges across the country.
Each fall, there are news releases touting the great strides in enrollment, but there are never media alerts about how many students failed to successfully complete the school year — or even first semester. Perhaps it's time to focus on that.
Spending 12 months at Texas Southmost College in Brownsville — now a part of the University of Texas at Brownsville — before transferring to the University of Texas at Austin as a junior was a matter of economics for me. Placement tests helped me fulfill requirements for an associate degree quickly and signing up to participate in the community college graduation ceremony was an excuse to party with friends afterwards.
Not graduating after two years in Austin was not an option for me and the close-knit circle of women with whom I transferred to UT. Many of us were first generation college students; some were first generation high school graduates, for whom English was a second language.
There was a lot riding on us; many of us had younger siblings who were counting on us.
Perhaps a major factor in our success was that we all moved into the same small apartment complex. The living and learning community we developed away from home provided the support we needed to succeed.
Some community colleges are now working on something similar to help their students. They are investing in establishing small learning communities to help students succeed; studies show it works. My college friends Letty, Abby, Olivia, Diana, Duck, Lissy, Hilda, Elsa, Sylvia and Mayra would be surprised to learn we were ahead of our time.
Much has changed since I went to college. Great progress has been made to provide access to higher education through the community college system, but more focus is needed on ensuring student success.
For many first-time college students, a community college is where they have to go to get ready for college courses.
Many new college students, an estimated 38 percent of community college students in the state and 24 percent of student in public four-year universities, spend their first few semesters on campus taking remedial courses in math, reading and writing, according to the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board.
Success for students taking developmental math class often falls into single digits.
Research indicates that the chances of success decrease if a student has to take a remedial course more than once. Unfortunately, repeating a remedial course happens more than some community college officials are willing to discuss.
Any way you add up the numbers, they don't look good in the effort to build a college-educated work force.
National statistics indicate that, on average, only 70 percent of high school students in the country graduate with a regular diploma.
We know all high school graduates don't immediately head off to college. But if we know that one in three of those that do end up at a Texas community college need remedial classes, it does not take a genius to realize the magnitude of the problem facing us.
gpadilla@express-news.net
10/12/2007
I did not realize just how small a minority I belong to as a graduate of a community college.
The number of students who graduate from community colleges, transfer to a four-year university and get a degree pales by comparison to the number of students who are enrolling in community colleges across the country.
Each fall, there are news releases touting the great strides in enrollment, but there are never media alerts about how many students failed to successfully complete the school year — or even first semester. Perhaps it's time to focus on that.
Spending 12 months at Texas Southmost College in Brownsville — now a part of the University of Texas at Brownsville — before transferring to the University of Texas at Austin as a junior was a matter of economics for me. Placement tests helped me fulfill requirements for an associate degree quickly and signing up to participate in the community college graduation ceremony was an excuse to party with friends afterwards.
Not graduating after two years in Austin was not an option for me and the close-knit circle of women with whom I transferred to UT. Many of us were first generation college students; some were first generation high school graduates, for whom English was a second language.
There was a lot riding on us; many of us had younger siblings who were counting on us.
Perhaps a major factor in our success was that we all moved into the same small apartment complex. The living and learning community we developed away from home provided the support we needed to succeed.
Some community colleges are now working on something similar to help their students. They are investing in establishing small learning communities to help students succeed; studies show it works. My college friends Letty, Abby, Olivia, Diana, Duck, Lissy, Hilda, Elsa, Sylvia and Mayra would be surprised to learn we were ahead of our time.
Much has changed since I went to college. Great progress has been made to provide access to higher education through the community college system, but more focus is needed on ensuring student success.
For many first-time college students, a community college is where they have to go to get ready for college courses.
Many new college students, an estimated 38 percent of community college students in the state and 24 percent of student in public four-year universities, spend their first few semesters on campus taking remedial courses in math, reading and writing, according to the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board.
Success for students taking developmental math class often falls into single digits.
Research indicates that the chances of success decrease if a student has to take a remedial course more than once. Unfortunately, repeating a remedial course happens more than some community college officials are willing to discuss.
Any way you add up the numbers, they don't look good in the effort to build a college-educated work force.
National statistics indicate that, on average, only 70 percent of high school students in the country graduate with a regular diploma.
We know all high school graduates don't immediately head off to college. But if we know that one in three of those that do end up at a Texas community college need remedial classes, it does not take a genius to realize the magnitude of the problem facing us.
gpadilla@express-news.net
Noose Case Puts Focus on a Scholar of Race
By ELISSA GOOTMAN
Published: October 12, 2007
In Madonna G. Constantine’s classroom at Columbia University’s Teachers College, emotions can run high. “People have cried in class,” said Dr. Constantine, 44, a professor of psychology and education who specializes in the study of how race and racial prejudice can affect clinical and educational interactions. “Uncovering those issues, students often get to a place where it can be painful.”
In an interview in her office, a suite peppered with academic tomes and mugs from psychology conferences, Dr. Constantine said she remained mystified over who could be responsible for leaving a noose dangling on her office door at Teachers College this week.
“I really don’t have any idea of who could have done that,” she said. “Is there anything that I’ve experienced that’s close? I would say no.”
As she gave a round of interviews yesterday, the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Department of Justice joined the investigation into the noose being conducted by the Hate Crimes Task Force of the New York Police Department.
A police spokesman, Paul J. Browne, said yesterday that there were still no suspects.
College officials and the Police Department sparred publicly yesterday over the department’s request that Teachers College turn over hours of video from a number of security cameras. But college officials said there was no camera in the hallway by Dr. Constantine’s office.
In a separate case, the president of Columbia University, Lee C. Bollinger, reported that an “anti-Semitic smear” had been found yesterday in a bathroom in a campus building, Lewisohn Hall. The police said a swastika and a caricature of a man wearing a yarmulke had been drawn in black ink on a stall door.
In the noose case, Mr. Browne said yesterday that the police were “disappointed and surprised” that Teachers College had refused to turn over its security camera footage without a subpoena. “It is always important to get information as soon as possible,” he said. “You don’t want to give the perp time to concoct a story or cover their tracks.”
But Susan H. Fuhrman, the president of Teachers College, said she was “surprised and distressed” to learn of the police criticism. She said the subpoena policy was standard for educational institutions, adding, “We have students here whose privacy we try to protect.”
She said that the college was committed to cooperating with the police and that by the time the police arrived with the subpoena early yesterday evening, the college had already downloaded the video to hand over to officers.
“There’s been open communication all along with the Police Department,” she said.
As for Dr. Constantine, Dr. Fuhrman said she had heard “nothing but accolades” from her students. “She’s well respected in her field,” she said. “Probably her work engenders passionate debate, but I could name 100 other people here who you can say the same thing about.”
In the interview, Dr. Constantine described growing up in Lafayette, La., the third of five children. Her father works as a bartender at a private club for people in the petroleum industry; her mother was a teacher’s aide working with special education students.
Her parents, who attended college but did not graduate, saved their money to send their children to Catholic schools.
Asked how she became interested in psychology, Dr. Constantine joked about growing up watching “The Bob Newhart Show.” But she also noted, “my personality is naturally one that helps people.”
When Kolone Scanlan, a doctoral student, popped by Dr. Constantine’s office yesterday with a bouquet of flowers and a card, it was Ms. Scanlan who broke out into tears and Dr. Constantine who offered words of comfort.
As an undergraduate and master’s student at Xavier University in New Orleans, Dr. Constantine noticed that psychology textbooks tended to lump women, poor people, black people and disabled people under the umbrella “disadvantaged populations.”
“It was written in a very condescending manner, as in these people do dah dah dah dah dah,” Dr. Constantine said, which made her think, “I want to be able to change some of the text.”
She earned her Ph.D. in counseling psychology at the University of Memphis, and spent five years working in the counseling and mental health center at the University of Texas at Austin before going into academia, first at Temple University. She came to Teachers College in 1998 as an associate professor and earned tenure in 2001, with, she said, more than 30 published articles under her name.
“Most people may go up with 15 or 20,” she said. “I figured as a black woman, I needed to at least double that.”
“Your scholarship is evaluated differently,” she said. “People think that I and other black scholars are studying issues of race because we’re black and because it’s personal. But if I’m studying racism, that’s not about me, right, that’s often about white people, who have certain types of attitudes about people of color, and so forth.”
Dr. Constantine was promoted to a full professor in 2003. But her time at Columbia has not been conflict-free. In May, she filed a defamation lawsuit against another professor in her department.
No detailed complaint has been filed in the case, and Dr. Constantine, who was accompanied during the interview by her lawyer, Paul J. Giacomo Jr., declined to elaborate on the case.
One key concept in Dr. Constantine’s scholarship is “racial microaggression,” which she explained as the often subtle ways in which racial differences can plague relationships between even well-meaning therapists and their clients, or supervisors and their trainees. For Dr. Constantine, colorblindness is neither possible nor desired.
“We have some of the most well-meaning, well-intentioned students I have ever met, and I really enjoy working with them,” she said. “Well-meaning and well-intentioned doesn’t mean effective.” Proclaiming oneself to be colorblind, she added, “is not a helpful perspective in counseling and therapy.”
Does Dr. Constantine think her work could be connected to the noose, hardly a microaggression, but, in her words, “a very, very aggressive act?”
“I haven’t ruled it out that it’s connected,” she said. “I teach courses on racial and cultural issues.” She added, “There are things that I say that have pushed people’s buttons, because it challenges the status quo.”
For now, Dr. Constantine says she is done with the interviews and ready to return to her private life. She was eager to attend her boyfriend’s daughter’s wedding this weekend, she told friends she encountered in the hallway.
And upon arriving at the office door where the noose recently hung, she did not flinch but reached for the doorknob with confidence, saying, “I’m just a nerdy academic who likes to be in her office and do research.”
Published: October 12, 2007
In Madonna G. Constantine’s classroom at Columbia University’s Teachers College, emotions can run high. “People have cried in class,” said Dr. Constantine, 44, a professor of psychology and education who specializes in the study of how race and racial prejudice can affect clinical and educational interactions. “Uncovering those issues, students often get to a place where it can be painful.”
In an interview in her office, a suite peppered with academic tomes and mugs from psychology conferences, Dr. Constantine said she remained mystified over who could be responsible for leaving a noose dangling on her office door at Teachers College this week.
“I really don’t have any idea of who could have done that,” she said. “Is there anything that I’ve experienced that’s close? I would say no.”
As she gave a round of interviews yesterday, the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Department of Justice joined the investigation into the noose being conducted by the Hate Crimes Task Force of the New York Police Department.
A police spokesman, Paul J. Browne, said yesterday that there were still no suspects.
College officials and the Police Department sparred publicly yesterday over the department’s request that Teachers College turn over hours of video from a number of security cameras. But college officials said there was no camera in the hallway by Dr. Constantine’s office.
In a separate case, the president of Columbia University, Lee C. Bollinger, reported that an “anti-Semitic smear” had been found yesterday in a bathroom in a campus building, Lewisohn Hall. The police said a swastika and a caricature of a man wearing a yarmulke had been drawn in black ink on a stall door.
In the noose case, Mr. Browne said yesterday that the police were “disappointed and surprised” that Teachers College had refused to turn over its security camera footage without a subpoena. “It is always important to get information as soon as possible,” he said. “You don’t want to give the perp time to concoct a story or cover their tracks.”
But Susan H. Fuhrman, the president of Teachers College, said she was “surprised and distressed” to learn of the police criticism. She said the subpoena policy was standard for educational institutions, adding, “We have students here whose privacy we try to protect.”
She said that the college was committed to cooperating with the police and that by the time the police arrived with the subpoena early yesterday evening, the college had already downloaded the video to hand over to officers.
“There’s been open communication all along with the Police Department,” she said.
As for Dr. Constantine, Dr. Fuhrman said she had heard “nothing but accolades” from her students. “She’s well respected in her field,” she said. “Probably her work engenders passionate debate, but I could name 100 other people here who you can say the same thing about.”
In the interview, Dr. Constantine described growing up in Lafayette, La., the third of five children. Her father works as a bartender at a private club for people in the petroleum industry; her mother was a teacher’s aide working with special education students.
Her parents, who attended college but did not graduate, saved their money to send their children to Catholic schools.
Asked how she became interested in psychology, Dr. Constantine joked about growing up watching “The Bob Newhart Show.” But she also noted, “my personality is naturally one that helps people.”
When Kolone Scanlan, a doctoral student, popped by Dr. Constantine’s office yesterday with a bouquet of flowers and a card, it was Ms. Scanlan who broke out into tears and Dr. Constantine who offered words of comfort.
As an undergraduate and master’s student at Xavier University in New Orleans, Dr. Constantine noticed that psychology textbooks tended to lump women, poor people, black people and disabled people under the umbrella “disadvantaged populations.”
“It was written in a very condescending manner, as in these people do dah dah dah dah dah,” Dr. Constantine said, which made her think, “I want to be able to change some of the text.”
She earned her Ph.D. in counseling psychology at the University of Memphis, and spent five years working in the counseling and mental health center at the University of Texas at Austin before going into academia, first at Temple University. She came to Teachers College in 1998 as an associate professor and earned tenure in 2001, with, she said, more than 30 published articles under her name.
“Most people may go up with 15 or 20,” she said. “I figured as a black woman, I needed to at least double that.”
“Your scholarship is evaluated differently,” she said. “People think that I and other black scholars are studying issues of race because we’re black and because it’s personal. But if I’m studying racism, that’s not about me, right, that’s often about white people, who have certain types of attitudes about people of color, and so forth.”
Dr. Constantine was promoted to a full professor in 2003. But her time at Columbia has not been conflict-free. In May, she filed a defamation lawsuit against another professor in her department.
No detailed complaint has been filed in the case, and Dr. Constantine, who was accompanied during the interview by her lawyer, Paul J. Giacomo Jr., declined to elaborate on the case.
One key concept in Dr. Constantine’s scholarship is “racial microaggression,” which she explained as the often subtle ways in which racial differences can plague relationships between even well-meaning therapists and their clients, or supervisors and their trainees. For Dr. Constantine, colorblindness is neither possible nor desired.
“We have some of the most well-meaning, well-intentioned students I have ever met, and I really enjoy working with them,” she said. “Well-meaning and well-intentioned doesn’t mean effective.” Proclaiming oneself to be colorblind, she added, “is not a helpful perspective in counseling and therapy.”
Does Dr. Constantine think her work could be connected to the noose, hardly a microaggression, but, in her words, “a very, very aggressive act?”
“I haven’t ruled it out that it’s connected,” she said. “I teach courses on racial and cultural issues.” She added, “There are things that I say that have pushed people’s buttons, because it challenges the status quo.”
For now, Dr. Constantine says she is done with the interviews and ready to return to her private life. She was eager to attend her boyfriend’s daughter’s wedding this weekend, she told friends she encountered in the hallway.
And upon arriving at the office door where the noose recently hung, she did not flinch but reached for the doorknob with confidence, saying, “I’m just a nerdy academic who likes to be in her office and do research.”
Hispanic University In SJ Aids English Learners
Len Ramirez
CBS5.com
(CBS 5) SAN JOSE High school students whose first language is Spanish sometimes had problems continuing their education. But National Hispanic University along with Latino College Prep are helping English-language learners address those issues.
NHU shares its campus and some of their faculty with Latino College Prep, a charter high school which only serves students whom English is a second language. The president of the University says combining the two schools demystifies college for students, especially those who would be the first in their family to go.
Click here to see video
CBS5.com
(CBS 5) SAN JOSE High school students whose first language is Spanish sometimes had problems continuing their education. But National Hispanic University along with Latino College Prep are helping English-language learners address those issues.
NHU shares its campus and some of their faculty with Latino College Prep, a charter high school which only serves students whom English is a second language. The president of the University says combining the two schools demystifies college for students, especially those who would be the first in their family to go.
Click here to see video
Monday, October 15, 2007
Push to Revamp High Schools Off Track, Scholars Say
The theme-based programs suggested in this article sound similar to the Small Learning Communities used in South Texas (Edcouch-Elsa High School). For anyone who's interested take a look at Llano Grande, the organization who designed the project. www.llanogrande.org -Patricia
Overemphasis seen on ratcheting up standards at expense of broader view of academic ‘rigor.’
By Erik W. Robelen | Ed Week
October 5, 2007
In a new paper arguing that the ongoing national push to dramatically improve American high schools has gotten off course, two Univesity of California education professors take aim at what they see as an overemphasis on states’ adoption of higher standards for graduation and more-rigorous tests.
“The push to enhance rigor and standards behind the high school diploma is seriously flawed,” write W. Norton Grubb, an education professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and Jeannie Oakes, an education professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, in the paper. “Any gains come at the expense of other goals for high school reform, including equity, curricular relevance, and student interest.”
For the rest of this story click here
Overemphasis seen on ratcheting up standards at expense of broader view of academic ‘rigor.’
By Erik W. Robelen | Ed Week
October 5, 2007
In a new paper arguing that the ongoing national push to dramatically improve American high schools has gotten off course, two Univesity of California education professors take aim at what they see as an overemphasis on states’ adoption of higher standards for graduation and more-rigorous tests.
“The push to enhance rigor and standards behind the high school diploma is seriously flawed,” write W. Norton Grubb, an education professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and Jeannie Oakes, an education professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, in the paper. “Any gains come at the expense of other goals for high school reform, including equity, curricular relevance, and student interest.”
For the rest of this story click here
Voucher Program Puts D.C. Kids at Risk, Study Says
Important discussion on evidence pertaining to vouchers in Washington, D.C. Read on. -Angela
Voucher Program Puts D.C. Kids at Risk, Study Says
By Theola Labbé
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, October 11, 2007; A01
A voucher program designed to send low-income children in the District to better-performing private schools has allowed some students to take classes in unsuitable learning environments and from teachers without bachelor's degrees, according to a government report.
The shortcomings are detailed in a draft prepared by the Government Accountability Office about the $12.9 million D.C. Opportunity Scholarship program. The GAO said the program lacks financial controls and has failed to check whether the participating schools were accredited.
The report, obtained by The Washington Post, assesses how the D.C. government, federal education officials and the nonprofit Washington Scholarship Fund have handled the voucher program, which is in its fourth year with 1,900 students and 58 participating private schools.
The findings are likely to stoke debate about the merits of the country's first federally funded K-12 scholarship program and widen the political divide over vouchers, which Republicans favor as a form of school choice. The GAO undertook the study at the request of three Democrats, Sens. Richard J. Durbin (Ill.) and Edward M. Kennedy (Mass.) and District Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton.
The controversial voucher program was passed by Congress in 2004 to give low-income families the option of using $7,500 toward private school tuition. The average D.C. applicant is a single parent who makes $17,000 a year and has four children.
Students in Ohio and Wisconsin are also taking part in similar programs. But in the District, the report says, instead of giving poor children access to better learning environments, program officials put children at risk by failing to certify whether all of the participating schools had the required operating permits.
In a random sample of 18 schools reviewed by the GAO, two lacked occupancy permits, and four lacked permits needed for buildings used for educational purposes. At least seven of the 18 schools were certified as child development centers but not as private schools. In one case, a school was operating in a space designed for a retail store, the report says.
The schools were largely allowed to self-report that they were in compliance with city regulations, the report says, increasing the possibility that students were being ill-served without proper oversight.
"Self-certification without review to verify that the certifications are factual increases the risk that federal funds intended to allow children from low-income families to attend private schools will result in some students attending schools that are not in compliance with the District law," the report says.
The Washington Scholarship Fund, which operates the program under a contract with the U.S. Department of Education, told GAO investigators that it conducted site visits at 42 schools, but the GAO could confirm a visit to only one school.
Some schools told fund officials that they had certain amenities, such as a gymnasium or an auditorium; the report says they did not. Parents might have been misled when they reviewed the list of participating schools and their programs, the report says.
Gregory M. Cork, president and chief executive of the fund, said it has no capacity to enforce whether private schools comply with D.C. laws.
"We're not a government oversight agency," Cork said. "We report the characteristics of schools as they report them to us. Occasionally, a school might fill in the wrong blank. What we do take seriously is to match our families with the schools they choose and the learning environments that are best for their children."
Samara Yudof, a spokeswoman for the Department of Education, said the report could be revised before it becomes final. She also said it "presents an incomplete picture" of the program.
D.C. State Superintendent Deborah A. Gist said in a statement that Mayor Adrian M. Fenty (D) has designated her office to assume oversight of the program. Gist said she will assign staffers to the task.
"We will aggressively move to ensure that our students are adequately served," Gist said in a statement.
Victor Reinoso, deputy mayor for education, said yesterday that the administration is preparing a response to the draft report.
The report also says that the fund had high turnover and weak internal controls for handling the federal grant money. It attributed those issues to a rapid three-year expansion because of high parent demand.
Cork said yesterday that the nonprofit program has improved operations. One example cited was shifting from paper invoices to an electronic system.
A report in May from the Georgetown University Public Policy Institute showed that of 100 parents and students surveyed, most were satisfied with the program, and about 90 percent said they would remain at least another year.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/10/AR2007101002529.html
Voucher Program Puts D.C. Kids at Risk, Study Says
By Theola Labbé
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, October 11, 2007; A01
A voucher program designed to send low-income children in the District to better-performing private schools has allowed some students to take classes in unsuitable learning environments and from teachers without bachelor's degrees, according to a government report.
The shortcomings are detailed in a draft prepared by the Government Accountability Office about the $12.9 million D.C. Opportunity Scholarship program. The GAO said the program lacks financial controls and has failed to check whether the participating schools were accredited.
The report, obtained by The Washington Post, assesses how the D.C. government, federal education officials and the nonprofit Washington Scholarship Fund have handled the voucher program, which is in its fourth year with 1,900 students and 58 participating private schools.
The findings are likely to stoke debate about the merits of the country's first federally funded K-12 scholarship program and widen the political divide over vouchers, which Republicans favor as a form of school choice. The GAO undertook the study at the request of three Democrats, Sens. Richard J. Durbin (Ill.) and Edward M. Kennedy (Mass.) and District Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton.
The controversial voucher program was passed by Congress in 2004 to give low-income families the option of using $7,500 toward private school tuition. The average D.C. applicant is a single parent who makes $17,000 a year and has four children.
Students in Ohio and Wisconsin are also taking part in similar programs. But in the District, the report says, instead of giving poor children access to better learning environments, program officials put children at risk by failing to certify whether all of the participating schools had the required operating permits.
In a random sample of 18 schools reviewed by the GAO, two lacked occupancy permits, and four lacked permits needed for buildings used for educational purposes. At least seven of the 18 schools were certified as child development centers but not as private schools. In one case, a school was operating in a space designed for a retail store, the report says.
The schools were largely allowed to self-report that they were in compliance with city regulations, the report says, increasing the possibility that students were being ill-served without proper oversight.
"Self-certification without review to verify that the certifications are factual increases the risk that federal funds intended to allow children from low-income families to attend private schools will result in some students attending schools that are not in compliance with the District law," the report says.
The Washington Scholarship Fund, which operates the program under a contract with the U.S. Department of Education, told GAO investigators that it conducted site visits at 42 schools, but the GAO could confirm a visit to only one school.
Some schools told fund officials that they had certain amenities, such as a gymnasium or an auditorium; the report says they did not. Parents might have been misled when they reviewed the list of participating schools and their programs, the report says.
Gregory M. Cork, president and chief executive of the fund, said it has no capacity to enforce whether private schools comply with D.C. laws.
"We're not a government oversight agency," Cork said. "We report the characteristics of schools as they report them to us. Occasionally, a school might fill in the wrong blank. What we do take seriously is to match our families with the schools they choose and the learning environments that are best for their children."
Samara Yudof, a spokeswoman for the Department of Education, said the report could be revised before it becomes final. She also said it "presents an incomplete picture" of the program.
D.C. State Superintendent Deborah A. Gist said in a statement that Mayor Adrian M. Fenty (D) has designated her office to assume oversight of the program. Gist said she will assign staffers to the task.
"We will aggressively move to ensure that our students are adequately served," Gist said in a statement.
Victor Reinoso, deputy mayor for education, said yesterday that the administration is preparing a response to the draft report.
The report also says that the fund had high turnover and weak internal controls for handling the federal grant money. It attributed those issues to a rapid three-year expansion because of high parent demand.
Cork said yesterday that the nonprofit program has improved operations. One example cited was shifting from paper invoices to an electronic system.
A report in May from the Georgetown University Public Policy Institute showed that of 100 parents and students surveyed, most were satisfied with the program, and about 90 percent said they would remain at least another year.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/10/AR2007101002529.html
Friday, October 12, 2007
Wal-Mart Short-Changes Public Schools
This piece in alternet.org seriously challenges Walmart's claim that they provide benefits to communities. -Angela
Wal-Mart Short-Changes Public Schools
By Phil Mattera, Corporate Research Project
Posted on October 11, 2007, Printed on October 12, 2007
http://www.alternet.org/story/64943/
When Wal-Mart proposes to build another of its giant stores, local residents often raise concerns about increased car and truck traffic, a loss of open space, higher crime rates and other negative impacts that they argue will lower the quality of life in the neighborhood and thus depress property values. The company responds to these concerns by painting a different picture, claiming that its stores provide substantial benefits to communities.
Yet what Wal-Mart does not disclose in site fights--but is revealed for the first time in a new report by Good Jobs First -- is the extent to which the company later in effect concedes the point about reduced property values. Once a store has been in operation for a while, Wal-Mart frequently challenges the assessed value that local officials assign to it for tax purposes. In an effort to cut the property tax it pays to local governments--revenue that pays for public education, police and fire protection and other vital services--Wal-Mart routinely tries to belittle the value of its own facilities.
Good Jobs First discovered this behavior in a labor-intensive, nine-month investigation of Wal-Mart's property tax behavior at more than 500 stores and distribution centers around the United States. We researched local property tax records, looking at assessment appeals on both real property (buildings and land) and business personal property (fixtures and equipment), and found what appears to be a company policy of systematically challenging assessments.
While we did not explore the merits of individual appeals, the high volume of these actions suggests that Wal-Mart, rather than occasionally disagreeing with particular valuations, is engaged in a large-scale effort to roll back its assessments, lower its tax payments and thereby increase its after-tax profits. Our finding that the challenges are handled at the corporate level rather than by individual store managers reinforces this conclusion.
Our key findings:
An examination of a 10 percent random sample of Wal-Mart's 2,833 Supercenters and discount stores in operation as of the beginning of 2005 finds that at least one assessment challenge has been filed at 35 percent, or more than one-third, of the stores. Applying that rate to all Wal-Mart stores, we estimate that the company has brought challenges at more than 1,000 of its retail outlets nationwide.
An examination of all of Wal-Mart's giant distribution centers in operation as of the same date shows that 40 percent have had an assessment challenge--this despite the fact that many of the warehouses had previously been granted property tax abatements (exempting them from property taxes in whole or in part as an economic development subsidy) when they were first built.
At many locations, Wal-Mart has filed challenges in multiple years -- either because it was not initially successful or because it wanted an even bigger tax reduction. We estimate that the company has filed a total of more than 2,100 appeals at its stores and distribution centers nationwide.
Our findings are consistent with Wal-Mart's reputation for relentless cost-cutting; they suggest that the company treats property taxes the same way it treats suppliers and workers. But in this case, entire communities are affected. For only two things can happen when large companies like Wal-Mart reduce their property tax payments: either local public services are cut back or small businesses and homeowners are asked to pay more in taxes. Usually, it is some of both.
Our numbers probably understate the true extent of Wal-Mart's challenges to its assessments, given that they do not include all the informal initiatives taken by the company, which are often not reflected in the local government records we obtained. Our figures also exclude those appeals that were filed but later withdrawn by the company before the hearing date. Finally, our totals are limited by the fact that many local governments keep appeals records for only a limited number of years. The earliest data we were able to obtain were usually from the mid-1990s.
As aggressive and persistent Wal-Mart is in these challenges, the company frequently loses. In fact, when it comes to Supercenters and discount stores, Wal-Mart is denied more assessment reductions than it is granted. Wal-Mart's win rate in appeals at these stores is only 45 percent. The rate at distribution centers is higher (64 percent), but the company still loses more than one-third of those cases. For stores and distribution centers combined, Wal-Mart's win rate is just under 50 percent. There are no comparable statistics available on other companies or on commercial property owners in general.
Wal-Mart's mixed record can be attributed to the worthy efforts of assessors such as those in Johnson County, Arkansas, the company's home state. When Good Jobs First phoned and said we were calling about Wal-Mart, a county official immediately responded: "We just kicked their butt." The company had tried to get the valuation of its distribution center in Clarksville reduced from $33 million to $23 million. The county refused, so Wal-Mart sued. When we contacted the county, a circuit court judge had just ruled in its favor. "Wal-Mart pushes, pushes and pushes," a county official said, "but I'm not bowing down to them."
Thanks to such perseverance by local officials, the total dollar value of tax savings that Wal-Mart has achieved in its appeals has apparently been kept to a moderate level. We found that the cumulative tax savings achieved by Wal-Mart at outlets that have had successful appeals averages $43,000 per store; at distribution centers it is $289,000. We estimate the company's cumulative tax savings nationwide for all Supercenters and discount stores at about $23 million; for all distribution centers the amount is about $6 million. This puts Wal-Mart's total cumulative tax savings in the neighborhood of $30 million, or roughly $3 million a year over the last decade.
Wal-Mart does not disclose how much it pays in annual property taxes nationwide, but a few years ago a company official implied that the amount was about $400 million. If that is still the case, the amount it is recouping through assessment appeals is approaching one percent of its total property tax bill. The amount it seeks through those challenges is much higher, yet the sums involved would still be tiny for a company with $350 billion in revenues and $11 billion in profits. The fact that Wal-Mart goes to such lengths in assessment challenges is another example of its obsession with cost cutting.
The amounts involved in the appeals are also a far cry from the hundreds of millions of dollars Wal-Mart has received in economic development subsidies, which Good Jobs First documented in our 2004 report Shopping for Subsidies, now updated on our website Wal-Mart Subsidy Watch (www.walmartsubsidywatch.org). If local government officials were less vigilant in defending their property valuations from Wal-Mart's appeals, it is likely that the gap between the two sets of numbers would be much smaller. In some cases, the two tax avoidance methods go together. We found 12 cases of Wal-Mart distribution centers with property tax abatements or exemptions that also filed assessment appeals.
There are significant variations in the frequency of assessment challenges from state to state. In Texas, where the challenges are called appraisal protests, Wal-Mart engages in the practice to a much greater degree than we found in other states. In our research, Texas accounts for the largest absolute number of both total appeals and total successful protests. Because of the high numbers for Texas that turned up in our random sample, we did additional research on other Wal-Mart stores in the state. As a result, we documented more than 100 other locations in the Lone Star State with protests that have brought Wal-Mart more than $6 million in total tax savings. (These additional Texas findings are summarized separately from the random sample.)
Here are the top six states in percentage of stores in our random sample that have at least one challenge (limited to those with 5 or more stores in the sample):
Texas.................................................................... 83%
Colorado............................................................... 71%
Kansas.................................................................. 71%
California.............................................................. 67%
New Hampshire..................................................... 60%
Georgia................................................................. 55%
The states with the most frequent appeals are not always those in which Wal-Mart has the most success. While Texas has the most appeals, the company's success rate in the state is only 43 percent, far below the 82 percent success rate in Florida, for example. In California, the state where we found the second largest number of appeals, its success rate is even lower -- 25 percent.
There is no clear relationship between the frequency of Wal-Mart's challenges and the property tax rates in different states. The list above includes Texas, which is considered to have high property taxes (it has no state income tax), and California, which since Proposition 13 has had low property taxes--as well as states that are not necessarily high or low.
Although Wal-Mart's overall campaign to downsize its property tax payments has been blunted in some states, the company has enjoyed substantial gains in certain individual communities. We document more than 20 locations at which Wal-Mart has won total tax savings of more than $100,000. For example:
In 2004 Wal-Mart proposed that the assessment of its distribution center in Tomah, Wisconsin be lowered from $43.6 million to $23 million. The city resisted, but Wal-Mart kept up the pressure. This year the matter was finally settled, with the city agreeing to drop the assessment to $31.4 million and refund the company more than $300,000 for each of three years--a total of $949,000.
Wal-Mart has filed 11 separate challenges at its distribution center in the northern California city of Red Bluff. The company first appealed for the years 1994-1996 but got no change. It then appealed for the years 1997-2002 and reached agreement on changes for each year, achieving total savings of $644,000 -- a substantial amount but much less than what Wal-Mart was seeking. The company returned with appeals for 2005 and 2006 and recouped another $150,000.
Even when local governments defeat a Wal-Mart appeal entirely, there still may be substantial costs for the community. Assessors told us of major cases in which they had to spend tens of thousands of dollars on outside lawyers, appraisers and other consultants to prepare their defense.
Overall, what we found strongly suggests that Wal-Mart approaches assessment appeals -- as with most things -- in a centralized, systematic way. The company apparently sees assessment appeals as another way to improve its bottom line. That may be gratifying to shareholders, but it is another example of how the colossal company pursues policies detrimental to the fiscal health of the communities in which it operates.
The text of this article is drawn from: Philip Mattera, Karla Walter, Julie Farb Blain and Colleen Ruddick, Rolling Back Property Tax Payments: How Wal-Mart Short-Changes Schools and other Public Services by Challenging Its Property Tax Assessments (Washington, DC: Good Jobs First, October 2007); available online at http://www.goodjobsfirst.org/pdf/walmartproptax.pdf.
Phil Mattera is the director of the Corporate Research Project of Good Jobs First.
© 2007 Independent Media Institute. All rights reserved.
View this story online at: http://www.alternet.org/story/64943/
Wal-Mart Short-Changes Public Schools
By Phil Mattera, Corporate Research Project
Posted on October 11, 2007, Printed on October 12, 2007
http://www.alternet.org/story/64943/
When Wal-Mart proposes to build another of its giant stores, local residents often raise concerns about increased car and truck traffic, a loss of open space, higher crime rates and other negative impacts that they argue will lower the quality of life in the neighborhood and thus depress property values. The company responds to these concerns by painting a different picture, claiming that its stores provide substantial benefits to communities.
Yet what Wal-Mart does not disclose in site fights--but is revealed for the first time in a new report by Good Jobs First -- is the extent to which the company later in effect concedes the point about reduced property values. Once a store has been in operation for a while, Wal-Mart frequently challenges the assessed value that local officials assign to it for tax purposes. In an effort to cut the property tax it pays to local governments--revenue that pays for public education, police and fire protection and other vital services--Wal-Mart routinely tries to belittle the value of its own facilities.
Good Jobs First discovered this behavior in a labor-intensive, nine-month investigation of Wal-Mart's property tax behavior at more than 500 stores and distribution centers around the United States. We researched local property tax records, looking at assessment appeals on both real property (buildings and land) and business personal property (fixtures and equipment), and found what appears to be a company policy of systematically challenging assessments.
While we did not explore the merits of individual appeals, the high volume of these actions suggests that Wal-Mart, rather than occasionally disagreeing with particular valuations, is engaged in a large-scale effort to roll back its assessments, lower its tax payments and thereby increase its after-tax profits. Our finding that the challenges are handled at the corporate level rather than by individual store managers reinforces this conclusion.
Our key findings:
An examination of a 10 percent random sample of Wal-Mart's 2,833 Supercenters and discount stores in operation as of the beginning of 2005 finds that at least one assessment challenge has been filed at 35 percent, or more than one-third, of the stores. Applying that rate to all Wal-Mart stores, we estimate that the company has brought challenges at more than 1,000 of its retail outlets nationwide.
An examination of all of Wal-Mart's giant distribution centers in operation as of the same date shows that 40 percent have had an assessment challenge--this despite the fact that many of the warehouses had previously been granted property tax abatements (exempting them from property taxes in whole or in part as an economic development subsidy) when they were first built.
At many locations, Wal-Mart has filed challenges in multiple years -- either because it was not initially successful or because it wanted an even bigger tax reduction. We estimate that the company has filed a total of more than 2,100 appeals at its stores and distribution centers nationwide.
Our findings are consistent with Wal-Mart's reputation for relentless cost-cutting; they suggest that the company treats property taxes the same way it treats suppliers and workers. But in this case, entire communities are affected. For only two things can happen when large companies like Wal-Mart reduce their property tax payments: either local public services are cut back or small businesses and homeowners are asked to pay more in taxes. Usually, it is some of both.
Our numbers probably understate the true extent of Wal-Mart's challenges to its assessments, given that they do not include all the informal initiatives taken by the company, which are often not reflected in the local government records we obtained. Our figures also exclude those appeals that were filed but later withdrawn by the company before the hearing date. Finally, our totals are limited by the fact that many local governments keep appeals records for only a limited number of years. The earliest data we were able to obtain were usually from the mid-1990s.
As aggressive and persistent Wal-Mart is in these challenges, the company frequently loses. In fact, when it comes to Supercenters and discount stores, Wal-Mart is denied more assessment reductions than it is granted. Wal-Mart's win rate in appeals at these stores is only 45 percent. The rate at distribution centers is higher (64 percent), but the company still loses more than one-third of those cases. For stores and distribution centers combined, Wal-Mart's win rate is just under 50 percent. There are no comparable statistics available on other companies or on commercial property owners in general.
Wal-Mart's mixed record can be attributed to the worthy efforts of assessors such as those in Johnson County, Arkansas, the company's home state. When Good Jobs First phoned and said we were calling about Wal-Mart, a county official immediately responded: "We just kicked their butt." The company had tried to get the valuation of its distribution center in Clarksville reduced from $33 million to $23 million. The county refused, so Wal-Mart sued. When we contacted the county, a circuit court judge had just ruled in its favor. "Wal-Mart pushes, pushes and pushes," a county official said, "but I'm not bowing down to them."
Thanks to such perseverance by local officials, the total dollar value of tax savings that Wal-Mart has achieved in its appeals has apparently been kept to a moderate level. We found that the cumulative tax savings achieved by Wal-Mart at outlets that have had successful appeals averages $43,000 per store; at distribution centers it is $289,000. We estimate the company's cumulative tax savings nationwide for all Supercenters and discount stores at about $23 million; for all distribution centers the amount is about $6 million. This puts Wal-Mart's total cumulative tax savings in the neighborhood of $30 million, or roughly $3 million a year over the last decade.
Wal-Mart does not disclose how much it pays in annual property taxes nationwide, but a few years ago a company official implied that the amount was about $400 million. If that is still the case, the amount it is recouping through assessment appeals is approaching one percent of its total property tax bill. The amount it seeks through those challenges is much higher, yet the sums involved would still be tiny for a company with $350 billion in revenues and $11 billion in profits. The fact that Wal-Mart goes to such lengths in assessment challenges is another example of its obsession with cost cutting.
The amounts involved in the appeals are also a far cry from the hundreds of millions of dollars Wal-Mart has received in economic development subsidies, which Good Jobs First documented in our 2004 report Shopping for Subsidies, now updated on our website Wal-Mart Subsidy Watch (www.walmartsubsidywatch.org). If local government officials were less vigilant in defending their property valuations from Wal-Mart's appeals, it is likely that the gap between the two sets of numbers would be much smaller. In some cases, the two tax avoidance methods go together. We found 12 cases of Wal-Mart distribution centers with property tax abatements or exemptions that also filed assessment appeals.
There are significant variations in the frequency of assessment challenges from state to state. In Texas, where the challenges are called appraisal protests, Wal-Mart engages in the practice to a much greater degree than we found in other states. In our research, Texas accounts for the largest absolute number of both total appeals and total successful protests. Because of the high numbers for Texas that turned up in our random sample, we did additional research on other Wal-Mart stores in the state. As a result, we documented more than 100 other locations in the Lone Star State with protests that have brought Wal-Mart more than $6 million in total tax savings. (These additional Texas findings are summarized separately from the random sample.)
Here are the top six states in percentage of stores in our random sample that have at least one challenge (limited to those with 5 or more stores in the sample):
Texas.................................................................... 83%
Colorado............................................................... 71%
Kansas.................................................................. 71%
California.............................................................. 67%
New Hampshire..................................................... 60%
Georgia................................................................. 55%
The states with the most frequent appeals are not always those in which Wal-Mart has the most success. While Texas has the most appeals, the company's success rate in the state is only 43 percent, far below the 82 percent success rate in Florida, for example. In California, the state where we found the second largest number of appeals, its success rate is even lower -- 25 percent.
There is no clear relationship between the frequency of Wal-Mart's challenges and the property tax rates in different states. The list above includes Texas, which is considered to have high property taxes (it has no state income tax), and California, which since Proposition 13 has had low property taxes--as well as states that are not necessarily high or low.
Although Wal-Mart's overall campaign to downsize its property tax payments has been blunted in some states, the company has enjoyed substantial gains in certain individual communities. We document more than 20 locations at which Wal-Mart has won total tax savings of more than $100,000. For example:
In 2004 Wal-Mart proposed that the assessment of its distribution center in Tomah, Wisconsin be lowered from $43.6 million to $23 million. The city resisted, but Wal-Mart kept up the pressure. This year the matter was finally settled, with the city agreeing to drop the assessment to $31.4 million and refund the company more than $300,000 for each of three years--a total of $949,000.
Wal-Mart has filed 11 separate challenges at its distribution center in the northern California city of Red Bluff. The company first appealed for the years 1994-1996 but got no change. It then appealed for the years 1997-2002 and reached agreement on changes for each year, achieving total savings of $644,000 -- a substantial amount but much less than what Wal-Mart was seeking. The company returned with appeals for 2005 and 2006 and recouped another $150,000.
Even when local governments defeat a Wal-Mart appeal entirely, there still may be substantial costs for the community. Assessors told us of major cases in which they had to spend tens of thousands of dollars on outside lawyers, appraisers and other consultants to prepare their defense.
Overall, what we found strongly suggests that Wal-Mart approaches assessment appeals -- as with most things -- in a centralized, systematic way. The company apparently sees assessment appeals as another way to improve its bottom line. That may be gratifying to shareholders, but it is another example of how the colossal company pursues policies detrimental to the fiscal health of the communities in which it operates.
The text of this article is drawn from: Philip Mattera, Karla Walter, Julie Farb Blain and Colleen Ruddick, Rolling Back Property Tax Payments: How Wal-Mart Short-Changes Schools and other Public Services by Challenging Its Property Tax Assessments (Washington, DC: Good Jobs First, October 2007); available online at http://www.goodjobsfirst.org/pdf/walmartproptax.pdf.
Phil Mattera is the director of the Corporate Research Project of Good Jobs First.
© 2007 Independent Media Institute. All rights reserved.
View this story online at: http://www.alternet.org/story/64943/
Thursday, October 11, 2007
Academies help at-risk students succeed
I'd argue that in most cases the schools lost interest in the students, rather than believing that "these students lost interest in school" -Patricia
By KATHERINE CROMER BROCK
Star-Telegram Staff Writer
October 9, 2007
GRAPEVINE -- English teacher Melissa Little stood in the back of her Grapevine High School classroom, monitoring 13 students who were studying independently with laptop computers or huddled in groups of two or three.
She recalled how a teacher affected her life when she was a high school sophomore -- and not for the better.
"He asked me why wasn't I reading fast enough; was I just stupid?" said Little, 32. "I've never in my life felt so worthless. And therefore I struggled academically."
Little believes that all students need someone to believe in their potential.
That's a big part of Grapevine-Colleyville's new high school academies.
The Panther Academy at Colleyville Heritage High and the HOPE Academy at Grapevine High offer extra help to students who lack credits or need tutoring to pass the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills. Fifth-year seniors -- students who did not have enough credits to graduate last year with their class -- were recruited to attend the academies at the beginning of the year.
"We have a real special opportunity to find out what we can do to make them successful," Little said.
School within a school
Grapevine High's Harnessing Opportunities for Personal Education, or HOPE, Academy meets in a quiet room near the back corner of the school library.
On Thursday morning, six students sat with Little, discussing the components of writing a personal narrative. Three teens gathered at a table, chatting while they took a break. Four others were scattered throughout the room, working on biology, English and government assignments on laptops.
Seventeen students are in the academy at Grapevine, with more joining the class every week, said Lorimer Arendse, associate principal of academics.
Each student has an individual lesson plan. There are four teachers -- one each for English, math, science and social studies -- who rotate between Grapevine and Colleyville Heritage, which has 24 students in the program.
Academy students are kids who were chronically absent, and those who didn't succeed in a traditional classroom. Now, they have one-on-one attention and a flexible schedule. If a student only needs English credit, she can attend for one period, and then leave. Students who need TAKS help will come in for tutoring closer to test time.
"At some point, these students lost interest in school," Arendse said. "Now we want to get them interested again."
Small goals
Eighteen-year-old Jacob Brown of Colleyville admits it freely. He skipped class. He wasn't interested, so he didn't go. Then when he tried to go, he was overwhelmed with how far behind he was.
"In class, it seems like you're not getting anywhere," Brown said.
With only 18 of the 26 credits he needed to graduate, Brown had two options: drop out or keep working.
Most of his classes are freshman- and sophomore-level, but the teachers in the academy break the tasks into small, manageable goals. When Brown reaches a goal, he is rewarded with a snack or the chance to listen to music.
And if he skips, he knows that school officials will "hunt you down," Brown said.
"I never thought about school until now," he said. "And they don't make it seem like it's too hard for us to achieve."
Teachers are the difference between struggling in regular school and succeeding in the academy, said Francisco Guevara, 18, of Colleyville.
Guevara should be a senior, but he lacks the credits. He works full time at Metro Cinema to help support his family. The academy teachers understand his situation, but they don't let him slide on schoolwork.
"Before, if you skipped, they really didn't say anything," Guevara said. "These are probably the first teachers I've ever met that care about us and want us to succeed."
Little said the academy students are her "kind of kids."
"It's a privilege for me to get to know them one-on-one, and to find out where their skills are and recognize where their potential is, and watch them realize that they've had it all along," Little said. "So many teachers just give up on them, and that's heartbreaking for me. It's our job to make sure that they leave here knowing that they're loved, they're cared for, and they're worth something."
Big rewards
Most academy students are upperclassmen, but in the future, some freshmen or sophomores could benefit from the small-school atmosphere.
Students may catch up enough in an academy to rejoin their peers. Others may be able to transfer to Bridges, the district's alternative school.
Student completion rates will be part of the state's accountability system this year, so the district stands to benefit from students sticking it out and graduating.
Ninety-five percent of students must graduate or stay in school for a school to be rated exemplary.
But the greatest benefit is to the students who earn their diplomas, the students said.
"I made too many bad decisions while I was here," said Eduardo Perez, 18, of Grapevine, a fifth-year senior who last year turned himself in for participating in burglary and vandalism at the high school. "I didn't really have a goal."
Then Perez spent the summer doing landscaping work. It was hot, hard and not where he saw himself ending up. He re-evaluated his priorities.
"Working for my uncle in the yards was not fun," he said. "I got poison ivy and sunburn. I don't want that. You just don't give up and quit."
Katherine Cromer Brock, 817-685-3813
By KATHERINE CROMER BROCK
Star-Telegram Staff Writer
October 9, 2007
GRAPEVINE -- English teacher Melissa Little stood in the back of her Grapevine High School classroom, monitoring 13 students who were studying independently with laptop computers or huddled in groups of two or three.
She recalled how a teacher affected her life when she was a high school sophomore -- and not for the better.
"He asked me why wasn't I reading fast enough; was I just stupid?" said Little, 32. "I've never in my life felt so worthless. And therefore I struggled academically."
Little believes that all students need someone to believe in their potential.
That's a big part of Grapevine-Colleyville's new high school academies.
The Panther Academy at Colleyville Heritage High and the HOPE Academy at Grapevine High offer extra help to students who lack credits or need tutoring to pass the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills. Fifth-year seniors -- students who did not have enough credits to graduate last year with their class -- were recruited to attend the academies at the beginning of the year.
"We have a real special opportunity to find out what we can do to make them successful," Little said.
School within a school
Grapevine High's Harnessing Opportunities for Personal Education, or HOPE, Academy meets in a quiet room near the back corner of the school library.
On Thursday morning, six students sat with Little, discussing the components of writing a personal narrative. Three teens gathered at a table, chatting while they took a break. Four others were scattered throughout the room, working on biology, English and government assignments on laptops.
Seventeen students are in the academy at Grapevine, with more joining the class every week, said Lorimer Arendse, associate principal of academics.
Each student has an individual lesson plan. There are four teachers -- one each for English, math, science and social studies -- who rotate between Grapevine and Colleyville Heritage, which has 24 students in the program.
Academy students are kids who were chronically absent, and those who didn't succeed in a traditional classroom. Now, they have one-on-one attention and a flexible schedule. If a student only needs English credit, she can attend for one period, and then leave. Students who need TAKS help will come in for tutoring closer to test time.
"At some point, these students lost interest in school," Arendse said. "Now we want to get them interested again."
Small goals
Eighteen-year-old Jacob Brown of Colleyville admits it freely. He skipped class. He wasn't interested, so he didn't go. Then when he tried to go, he was overwhelmed with how far behind he was.
"In class, it seems like you're not getting anywhere," Brown said.
With only 18 of the 26 credits he needed to graduate, Brown had two options: drop out or keep working.
Most of his classes are freshman- and sophomore-level, but the teachers in the academy break the tasks into small, manageable goals. When Brown reaches a goal, he is rewarded with a snack or the chance to listen to music.
And if he skips, he knows that school officials will "hunt you down," Brown said.
"I never thought about school until now," he said. "And they don't make it seem like it's too hard for us to achieve."
Teachers are the difference between struggling in regular school and succeeding in the academy, said Francisco Guevara, 18, of Colleyville.
Guevara should be a senior, but he lacks the credits. He works full time at Metro Cinema to help support his family. The academy teachers understand his situation, but they don't let him slide on schoolwork.
"Before, if you skipped, they really didn't say anything," Guevara said. "These are probably the first teachers I've ever met that care about us and want us to succeed."
Little said the academy students are her "kind of kids."
"It's a privilege for me to get to know them one-on-one, and to find out where their skills are and recognize where their potential is, and watch them realize that they've had it all along," Little said. "So many teachers just give up on them, and that's heartbreaking for me. It's our job to make sure that they leave here knowing that they're loved, they're cared for, and they're worth something."
Big rewards
Most academy students are upperclassmen, but in the future, some freshmen or sophomores could benefit from the small-school atmosphere.
Students may catch up enough in an academy to rejoin their peers. Others may be able to transfer to Bridges, the district's alternative school.
Student completion rates will be part of the state's accountability system this year, so the district stands to benefit from students sticking it out and graduating.
Ninety-five percent of students must graduate or stay in school for a school to be rated exemplary.
But the greatest benefit is to the students who earn their diplomas, the students said.
"I made too many bad decisions while I was here," said Eduardo Perez, 18, of Grapevine, a fifth-year senior who last year turned himself in for participating in burglary and vandalism at the high school. "I didn't really have a goal."
Then Perez spent the summer doing landscaping work. It was hot, hard and not where he saw himself ending up. He re-evaluated his priorities.
"Working for my uncle in the yards was not fun," he said. "I got poison ivy and sunburn. I don't want that. You just don't give up and quit."
Katherine Cromer Brock, 817-685-3813
Noose on Door at Columbia Prompts Campus Protest
By ELISSA GOOTMAN and AL BAKER
NY Times
October 11, 2007
A day after a noose was found hanging on a black professor’s office door at Columbia University’s Teachers College, protesting students chanted “no diversity, no university” and confronted university officials at two emotional meetings. The police said that their hate crimes unit had mounted a full investigation, including testing the rope for DNA.
The professor, Madonna G. Constantine, whose specialty is race, racial identity and multiculturalism, stood before protesters at midday and thanked her supporters.
“I am upset that the Teachers College community has been exposed to such an unbelievably vile incident,” she said, “and I would like us to stay strong in the face of such a blatant act of racism.”
Baffled and anguished students and professors wondered how this could happen at Teachers College, which cherishes its image as a bastion of liberalism and multiculturalism.
“I think we are all pretty much mystified as to why it happened,” said George A. Bonanno, a professor of psychology. “This is an institution that prides itself on having open dialogue about race and fairly progressive ideas.”
At an afternoon news conference, Deputy Inspector Michael Osgood, commander of the New York Police Department’s Hate Crimes Task Force, said, “Right now we have no suspects, but we will go down all investigative pathways.” He ruled out any possibility that Professor Constantine had hung the rope herself.
“Our victim is a victim,” he said at police headquarters.
Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg said yesterday, “I think the noose thing is despicable and disgraceful.” A white Queens woman was arrested recently for throwing a noose around a tree and threatening to hang her black neighbor’s children from it.
Dr. Constantine, a professor of psychology and education, counts as her scholarly interests topics that include mental health issues of people of color and immigrants. She is a director of a yearly conference that brings together leaders in education and psychology.
Those who know Dr. Constantine say that she has had a rivalry with another professor, and in May filed a lawsuit charging her with defamation.
The other professor said yesterday that she was on sabbatical, found the noose incident “utterly reprehensible,” and denied she had anything to do with it.
For Columbia students, the incident had particular resonance coming so soon after demonstrations against the Jena Six case in Louisiana, in which white students hung nooses outside a high school and were not prosecuted. A white student was later beaten and six black students were initially charged with attempted murder; thousands have protested the case.
Columbia was also the site recently of demonstrations against Jim Gilchrist, a founder of the Minuteman Project, a group opposed to illegal immigration, and an appearance by the Iranian president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, that left students divided over the boundaries of free speech.
“It’s like throwing a match on a haystack,” said Christien Tompkins, 21, a senior who is co-chairman of the United Students of Color Council. “This obviously really touched a nerve for a lot of folks.”
Mr. Tompkins was one of about two dozen students who met with Columbia’s president, Lee C. Bollinger, to discuss the case yesterday afternoon.
At that meeting, Mr. Tompkins said, students have used the noose as a point of departure to talk about other issues, including Columbia’s plans to expand into adjacent neighborhoods.
“It’s the latest and maybe most visible and extreme case of a climate of racism that we face in our entire society but of course is manifested at Columbia as well,” he said.
Mr. Bollinger, in an e-mail message sent to students and faculty, wrote, “An attack on the dignity of any member of our community is an assault on all of us.”
At a separate meeting, 600 Teachers College students and faculty members gathered to air their own grievances before Susan H. Fuhrman, the president of Teachers College, and other administrators.
“I came here from Virginia,” said one black doctoral student, who did not identify herself. “I’ve been here since 2003 and there has been incident after incident. It’s not so different from the South.”
Earlier in the day, more than 100 students rallied outside Teachers College and marched in Professor Constantine’s support. Her colleagues said it seemed particularly jolting that this had happened to a professor whose work is devoted to issues of race.
Professor Derald Wing Sue, who has collaborated with Professor Constantine on such work as a book called “Addressing Racism,” said, “That’s her area of expertise, so in some sense I think it’s personally devastating and upsetting to her.”
“It could be a discontented student, it could be conflicts with colleagues, it could be the type of work that Professor Constantine does on racism that pushes buttons,” he said. “Teachers College is very devoted to a social justice agenda, but it’s a microcosm of a larger society when issues of race and racism are discussed.”
Dr. Fuhrman said yesterday that she would work to retain and recruit more minority faculty members, and offer students more scholarships.
“There’s nothing good about this incident, this is horrible,” she said. “But we should be doing this talking, and if it takes this thing to make us do this, so be it.”
Elizabeth Dwoskin and Elias E. Lopez contributed reporting
NY Times
October 11, 2007
A day after a noose was found hanging on a black professor’s office door at Columbia University’s Teachers College, protesting students chanted “no diversity, no university” and confronted university officials at two emotional meetings. The police said that their hate crimes unit had mounted a full investigation, including testing the rope for DNA.
The professor, Madonna G. Constantine, whose specialty is race, racial identity and multiculturalism, stood before protesters at midday and thanked her supporters.
“I am upset that the Teachers College community has been exposed to such an unbelievably vile incident,” she said, “and I would like us to stay strong in the face of such a blatant act of racism.”
Baffled and anguished students and professors wondered how this could happen at Teachers College, which cherishes its image as a bastion of liberalism and multiculturalism.
“I think we are all pretty much mystified as to why it happened,” said George A. Bonanno, a professor of psychology. “This is an institution that prides itself on having open dialogue about race and fairly progressive ideas.”
At an afternoon news conference, Deputy Inspector Michael Osgood, commander of the New York Police Department’s Hate Crimes Task Force, said, “Right now we have no suspects, but we will go down all investigative pathways.” He ruled out any possibility that Professor Constantine had hung the rope herself.
“Our victim is a victim,” he said at police headquarters.
Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg said yesterday, “I think the noose thing is despicable and disgraceful.” A white Queens woman was arrested recently for throwing a noose around a tree and threatening to hang her black neighbor’s children from it.
Dr. Constantine, a professor of psychology and education, counts as her scholarly interests topics that include mental health issues of people of color and immigrants. She is a director of a yearly conference that brings together leaders in education and psychology.
Those who know Dr. Constantine say that she has had a rivalry with another professor, and in May filed a lawsuit charging her with defamation.
The other professor said yesterday that she was on sabbatical, found the noose incident “utterly reprehensible,” and denied she had anything to do with it.
For Columbia students, the incident had particular resonance coming so soon after demonstrations against the Jena Six case in Louisiana, in which white students hung nooses outside a high school and were not prosecuted. A white student was later beaten and six black students were initially charged with attempted murder; thousands have protested the case.
Columbia was also the site recently of demonstrations against Jim Gilchrist, a founder of the Minuteman Project, a group opposed to illegal immigration, and an appearance by the Iranian president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, that left students divided over the boundaries of free speech.
“It’s like throwing a match on a haystack,” said Christien Tompkins, 21, a senior who is co-chairman of the United Students of Color Council. “This obviously really touched a nerve for a lot of folks.”
Mr. Tompkins was one of about two dozen students who met with Columbia’s president, Lee C. Bollinger, to discuss the case yesterday afternoon.
At that meeting, Mr. Tompkins said, students have used the noose as a point of departure to talk about other issues, including Columbia’s plans to expand into adjacent neighborhoods.
“It’s the latest and maybe most visible and extreme case of a climate of racism that we face in our entire society but of course is manifested at Columbia as well,” he said.
Mr. Bollinger, in an e-mail message sent to students and faculty, wrote, “An attack on the dignity of any member of our community is an assault on all of us.”
At a separate meeting, 600 Teachers College students and faculty members gathered to air their own grievances before Susan H. Fuhrman, the president of Teachers College, and other administrators.
“I came here from Virginia,” said one black doctoral student, who did not identify herself. “I’ve been here since 2003 and there has been incident after incident. It’s not so different from the South.”
Earlier in the day, more than 100 students rallied outside Teachers College and marched in Professor Constantine’s support. Her colleagues said it seemed particularly jolting that this had happened to a professor whose work is devoted to issues of race.
Professor Derald Wing Sue, who has collaborated with Professor Constantine on such work as a book called “Addressing Racism,” said, “That’s her area of expertise, so in some sense I think it’s personally devastating and upsetting to her.”
“It could be a discontented student, it could be conflicts with colleagues, it could be the type of work that Professor Constantine does on racism that pushes buttons,” he said. “Teachers College is very devoted to a social justice agenda, but it’s a microcosm of a larger society when issues of race and racism are discussed.”
Dr. Fuhrman said yesterday that she would work to retain and recruit more minority faculty members, and offer students more scholarships.
“There’s nothing good about this incident, this is horrible,” she said. “But we should be doing this talking, and if it takes this thing to make us do this, so be it.”
Elizabeth Dwoskin and Elias E. Lopez contributed reporting
UT unveils Cesar Chavez statue [VIDEO]
Tuesday, October 9, 2007
KVUE.com
The University of Texas unveiled a new statue Tuesday depicting civil rights leader Cesar Chavez.
The statue, which was unveiled in a celebration to honor Chavez' legacy for social justice, was placed on the university's West Mall between Battle Hall and the West Mall Office building.
It is the first statue of a Hispanic person on the UT campus.
Chavez, who died in 1993, co-founded the National Farm Workers Association and fought for the rights of farm laborers and minorities.
"What he did-- the fact that he didn't use large corporations to start a movement-- but invidvidual people-- getting at the initial person, using a person to move people," said Stacey Torres, Cesar Chavez statue committee.
Students voted for a statue depicting Chavez in 2003 with a referendum election and the proposal was approved by university regents. The Texas Legislature had to pass a bill allowing the university to collect student fees to fund the statue.
"We are proud of the students of The University of Texas at Austin for conceiving and bringing this concept to fruition on the campus," said Dr. Juan Gonzalez, vice president for student affairs, in a news release. "We also want to recognize the significant achievement of the committee in the realization of this long-time dream of the students."
Workers were preparing the site and foundation for the statue over the summer.
Student fees paid for the statue. Leftover money was to be put into a scholarship fund.
KVUE.com
The University of Texas unveiled a new statue Tuesday depicting civil rights leader Cesar Chavez.
The statue, which was unveiled in a celebration to honor Chavez' legacy for social justice, was placed on the university's West Mall between Battle Hall and the West Mall Office building.
It is the first statue of a Hispanic person on the UT campus.
Chavez, who died in 1993, co-founded the National Farm Workers Association and fought for the rights of farm laborers and minorities.
"What he did-- the fact that he didn't use large corporations to start a movement-- but invidvidual people-- getting at the initial person, using a person to move people," said Stacey Torres, Cesar Chavez statue committee.
Students voted for a statue depicting Chavez in 2003 with a referendum election and the proposal was approved by university regents. The Texas Legislature had to pass a bill allowing the university to collect student fees to fund the statue.
"We are proud of the students of The University of Texas at Austin for conceiving and bringing this concept to fruition on the campus," said Dr. Juan Gonzalez, vice president for student affairs, in a news release. "We also want to recognize the significant achievement of the committee in the realization of this long-time dream of the students."
Workers were preparing the site and foundation for the statue over the summer.
Student fees paid for the statue. Leftover money was to be put into a scholarship fund.
Latinos Unite Across Classes Against Curbs on Immigration
By Pamela Constable
Washington Post Staff Writer
Tuesday, October 9, 2007; Page A01
José Marinay wears tailored suits, plays racquetball twice a week and displays photos of family-owned racehorses in his Annandale office. For years, the Colombian-born businessman thought he had little in common with the area's illegal immigrants, often villagers from Mexico and Central America who sleep 10 to a house and push lawn mowers or scrub pots for a living.
But the battle in Prince William County, where a measure to curb illegal immigration has thrown the Latino community into turmoil, changed his mind.
"This situation has brought together people who never would have sat in one room before," said Marinay, 50, who owns a real estate settlement company that has offices across Northern Virginia and a mainly Latino clientele. Since the measure was passed in July, he said, business has fallen 80 percent at his Manassas office, and he will probably close it. He also said a sense of growing hostility toward Latino immigrants has affected him.
"I dress well, and I drive a nice car. But on the weekends, when I am in shorts and sandals and I haven't shaved, I look Latino enough to scare a few folks," Marinay said. "There is a definite chill in the air. We may be a fragmented community, we may eat or celebrate in different places, but now they are looking at us in the same way. If we don't unite and work together, we will all sink."
Although not yet enacted into law, the resolution passed by the Prince William Board of County Supervisors has created a sense of siege and solidarity throughout the county's wider Latino community of about 30,000. Rumors circulate that people will be arrested if they board buses or drop off their children at school. Some legal residents, who bought homes and opened businesses, expecting to stay for years, say they are thinking of leaving.
"When we came to Manassas 20 years ago, it was a beautiful place. We were full of enthusiasm and optimism. But in the last three months, that has all gone away," said Carlos Alvarado, 45, a Salvadoran immigrant whose variety store sells fresh corn tamales, pi¿atas and frilly girls' dresses. Many customers are too broke or scared to shop, he said. "Everyone is talking about moving to Maryland or North Carolina, and I am almost bankrupt."
Sponsors and advocates of the resolution assert it is neither anti-Latino nor anti-immigrant. They insist it is aimed at stopping the steady influx of illegal immigrants during the past decade, who they complain are crowding neighborhoods and burdening schools. The measure would deny some services to illegal immigrants and allow local police to turn them over to federal officials.
At first, the region's Latino community was conflicted in its response, reflecting differences in class, education levels, immigration status, national origin and ideological roots. Within the business community, potential allies saw each other as economic rivals first.
The split was exacerbated by the confrontational actions of a group in Virginia, Mexicans Without Borders, that staged a number of protests against the measure, including a one-week store boycott in August. The group has called for a one-day countywide work stoppage today. Last month, the group put up a huge Liberty Wall in Manassas with a sign that condemns "racism against Hispanics." The sign was half torn down by vandals last weekend.
Many established Latino immigrants in Northern Virginia said they disapproved of such tactics, saying they feared the efforts would turn community goodwill against them, too. But as the firestorm over illegal immigration has spread, more affluent Latinos in the area, including entrepreneurs from Colombia and Venezuela, have come to realize they have a personal and economic stake in resolving the issue.
In August, a regional Latino business coalition was formed to seek subtler ways to fight anti-immigration measures, such as through personal lobbying and economic power. Coalition leaders said that it was hard to get some entrepreneurs involved but that more are being spurred to action by a mixture of self-interest, guilt and sympathy for those they once considered a lower class of immigrant.
"This is definitely not business as usual. If people can't buy groceries, they can't buy cars or houses," said Marinay, a coalition official. Other members work in real estate, banking, entertainment and insurance. "We are a wealthy group, and we have invested millions in this region," he said. "Why can't we get these people off our backs? It's our own fault for not being united."
Ricardo Juarez, a leader of Mexicans Without Borders, said that despite their tactical differences, he has come to appreciate the efforts of Marinay's committee. At a county hearing last Tuesday, Juarez and several Latino business owners testified against the resolution, using nearly identical arguments and similarly polite tones.
"We can march. They can lobby. We are each doing our part," Juarez said later. "We all want to solve the problem, and we all have to coexist in the community."
Ruben Andrade, who owns several cafes and clubs in Prince William, embodies the contradictions that have pulled successful Latinos in several directions on illegal immigration. A war refugee who came to the United States 25 years ago, he worked menial jobs and faced his share of discrimination. Now, he prides himself on running stylish establishments and criticizes Latino laborers who pick fights in bars and throw trash in the streets.
"We need to educate our people," Andrade said. "If your neighbor asks you to pick up your garbage, you don't tell them to go to hell. You need to learn English and respect the rules." On the other hand, he said, "this law will hurt the entire community. It is not against illegal immigrants; it is against all Latinos, and we must fight it together."
In Maryland, where attitudes toward immigrants have been more relaxed, at least one measure similar to Prince William's has been proposed in the city of Frederick, and Latino leaders throughout the state's suburbs are increasingly worried that the illegal immigration controversy will engulf the region.
A handful of Latino businessmen in Montgomery and Prince George's counties have joined meetings of the Virginia coalition. Gilbert Mejia, a Salvadoran restaurant owner, was the host of a recent meeting at his La Frontera restaurant in Gaithersburg. He said the fear of arrest and harassment among Latino immigrants has become so widespread that business at his restaurant has fallen sharply this summer.
"Look at this place. Normally, we would be full for lunch," said Mejia, gesturing around a room full of empty tables. "People are afraid the attitude from Prince William will drift here, that Maryland will be the next target. I have been in this country 27 years, and I've invested hundreds of thousands of dollars. We need to know what's coming our way."
In Prince William, many immigrants who have never joined a protest or a committee, but have spent years quietly securing a niche for their families, find themselves drawn to the unfamiliar fray of public debate. Last Tuesday, about 200 Latinos filled an overflow room outside a supervisors meeting in which the July resolution was being discussed, although a final vote was postponed.
One was Jesus Calva, 40, who lives with his wife and two children in Lake Ridge, a woodsy townhouse community. Calva entered the United States illegally as a teenager and started working as a tree trimmer for $3 an hour. Today, he makes $27 an hour with a large construction company, and he helped rebuild the Pentagon after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attack. On his living room wall is a certificate of thanks signed by former defense secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld.
"I have always appreciated this country, and it really upsets me to hear about this law," said Calva, who spoke briefly at last Tuesday's hearing. Afterward, he strode outside, sat down on a curb and began to weep in frustration. "Even when I was illegal, I worked hard for everything I got, and I paid a lot of taxes," he said. "If they don't like us, why don't they just say so? I love my home, but I don't want to live in a place where I am hated."
Washington Post Staff Writer
Tuesday, October 9, 2007; Page A01
José Marinay wears tailored suits, plays racquetball twice a week and displays photos of family-owned racehorses in his Annandale office. For years, the Colombian-born businessman thought he had little in common with the area's illegal immigrants, often villagers from Mexico and Central America who sleep 10 to a house and push lawn mowers or scrub pots for a living.
But the battle in Prince William County, where a measure to curb illegal immigration has thrown the Latino community into turmoil, changed his mind.
"This situation has brought together people who never would have sat in one room before," said Marinay, 50, who owns a real estate settlement company that has offices across Northern Virginia and a mainly Latino clientele. Since the measure was passed in July, he said, business has fallen 80 percent at his Manassas office, and he will probably close it. He also said a sense of growing hostility toward Latino immigrants has affected him.
"I dress well, and I drive a nice car. But on the weekends, when I am in shorts and sandals and I haven't shaved, I look Latino enough to scare a few folks," Marinay said. "There is a definite chill in the air. We may be a fragmented community, we may eat or celebrate in different places, but now they are looking at us in the same way. If we don't unite and work together, we will all sink."
Although not yet enacted into law, the resolution passed by the Prince William Board of County Supervisors has created a sense of siege and solidarity throughout the county's wider Latino community of about 30,000. Rumors circulate that people will be arrested if they board buses or drop off their children at school. Some legal residents, who bought homes and opened businesses, expecting to stay for years, say they are thinking of leaving.
"When we came to Manassas 20 years ago, it was a beautiful place. We were full of enthusiasm and optimism. But in the last three months, that has all gone away," said Carlos Alvarado, 45, a Salvadoran immigrant whose variety store sells fresh corn tamales, pi¿atas and frilly girls' dresses. Many customers are too broke or scared to shop, he said. "Everyone is talking about moving to Maryland or North Carolina, and I am almost bankrupt."
Sponsors and advocates of the resolution assert it is neither anti-Latino nor anti-immigrant. They insist it is aimed at stopping the steady influx of illegal immigrants during the past decade, who they complain are crowding neighborhoods and burdening schools. The measure would deny some services to illegal immigrants and allow local police to turn them over to federal officials.
At first, the region's Latino community was conflicted in its response, reflecting differences in class, education levels, immigration status, national origin and ideological roots. Within the business community, potential allies saw each other as economic rivals first.
The split was exacerbated by the confrontational actions of a group in Virginia, Mexicans Without Borders, that staged a number of protests against the measure, including a one-week store boycott in August. The group has called for a one-day countywide work stoppage today. Last month, the group put up a huge Liberty Wall in Manassas with a sign that condemns "racism against Hispanics." The sign was half torn down by vandals last weekend.
Many established Latino immigrants in Northern Virginia said they disapproved of such tactics, saying they feared the efforts would turn community goodwill against them, too. But as the firestorm over illegal immigration has spread, more affluent Latinos in the area, including entrepreneurs from Colombia and Venezuela, have come to realize they have a personal and economic stake in resolving the issue.
In August, a regional Latino business coalition was formed to seek subtler ways to fight anti-immigration measures, such as through personal lobbying and economic power. Coalition leaders said that it was hard to get some entrepreneurs involved but that more are being spurred to action by a mixture of self-interest, guilt and sympathy for those they once considered a lower class of immigrant.
"This is definitely not business as usual. If people can't buy groceries, they can't buy cars or houses," said Marinay, a coalition official. Other members work in real estate, banking, entertainment and insurance. "We are a wealthy group, and we have invested millions in this region," he said. "Why can't we get these people off our backs? It's our own fault for not being united."
Ricardo Juarez, a leader of Mexicans Without Borders, said that despite their tactical differences, he has come to appreciate the efforts of Marinay's committee. At a county hearing last Tuesday, Juarez and several Latino business owners testified against the resolution, using nearly identical arguments and similarly polite tones.
"We can march. They can lobby. We are each doing our part," Juarez said later. "We all want to solve the problem, and we all have to coexist in the community."
Ruben Andrade, who owns several cafes and clubs in Prince William, embodies the contradictions that have pulled successful Latinos in several directions on illegal immigration. A war refugee who came to the United States 25 years ago, he worked menial jobs and faced his share of discrimination. Now, he prides himself on running stylish establishments and criticizes Latino laborers who pick fights in bars and throw trash in the streets.
"We need to educate our people," Andrade said. "If your neighbor asks you to pick up your garbage, you don't tell them to go to hell. You need to learn English and respect the rules." On the other hand, he said, "this law will hurt the entire community. It is not against illegal immigrants; it is against all Latinos, and we must fight it together."
In Maryland, where attitudes toward immigrants have been more relaxed, at least one measure similar to Prince William's has been proposed in the city of Frederick, and Latino leaders throughout the state's suburbs are increasingly worried that the illegal immigration controversy will engulf the region.
A handful of Latino businessmen in Montgomery and Prince George's counties have joined meetings of the Virginia coalition. Gilbert Mejia, a Salvadoran restaurant owner, was the host of a recent meeting at his La Frontera restaurant in Gaithersburg. He said the fear of arrest and harassment among Latino immigrants has become so widespread that business at his restaurant has fallen sharply this summer.
"Look at this place. Normally, we would be full for lunch," said Mejia, gesturing around a room full of empty tables. "People are afraid the attitude from Prince William will drift here, that Maryland will be the next target. I have been in this country 27 years, and I've invested hundreds of thousands of dollars. We need to know what's coming our way."
In Prince William, many immigrants who have never joined a protest or a committee, but have spent years quietly securing a niche for their families, find themselves drawn to the unfamiliar fray of public debate. Last Tuesday, about 200 Latinos filled an overflow room outside a supervisors meeting in which the July resolution was being discussed, although a final vote was postponed.
One was Jesus Calva, 40, who lives with his wife and two children in Lake Ridge, a woodsy townhouse community. Calva entered the United States illegally as a teenager and started working as a tree trimmer for $3 an hour. Today, he makes $27 an hour with a large construction company, and he helped rebuild the Pentagon after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attack. On his living room wall is a certificate of thanks signed by former defense secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld.
"I have always appreciated this country, and it really upsets me to hear about this law," said Calva, who spoke briefly at last Tuesday's hearing. Afterward, he strode outside, sat down on a curb and began to weep in frustration. "Even when I was illegal, I worked hard for everything I got, and I paid a lot of taxes," he said. "If they don't like us, why don't they just say so? I love my home, but I don't want to live in a place where I am hated."
Despite difficulty attaining elite status, universities forge ahead
By Brandi Grissom / Austin Bureau
El Paso Times
10/08/2007
Austin -- A report to Gov. Rick Perry about higher education found some disturbing trends.
The Governor's Business Council, a group of Texas business leaders that advise the governor, report that 25 to 34 year olds in Texas were less educated than the two preceding generations. And minorities, whose populations are increasing fastest, were getting the fewest degrees.
Among several recommendations in the report, the business leaders said Texas should emphasize both teaching undergraduates, especially minorities and those with low incomes, and increasing research capabilities.
The report stops short of specifically outlining how the state should realign universities but calls for reorganization where there is population growth and focusing on regional economic needs.
Texas has not handled the challenge of building top-tier universities well, said University of Texas System Chancellor Mark Yudof.
While Texas has two so-called flagship universities -- typically those with more than $100 million in federal research grants, selective admissions, low student-faculty ratios and competitive salaries -- California has eight such public institutions.
"We're a bit behind," Yudof said.
The seven universities hoping to move that number up for Texas are the University of Texas at El Paso, UT San Antonio, UT Dallas, UT Arlington, Texas Tech University, the University of Houston and the University of North Texas.
The schools are striving for more research dollars and building their academic offerings.
But achieving top-tier status will require more investment from the state so that the schools can hire more faculty, increase salaries and purchase equipment.
"Some would hope there could be a funding mechanism that could elevate more flagships into tier-one status," Texas Tech University regent Rick Francis said. "But that is going to elicit jealousies."
Legislators, he said, often have trouble supporting additional funding for a university in an area other than their own.
They "like to bring home the goodies so to speak," Francis said.
That makes it difficult to find consensus on which universities get the financial boost to achieve top-tier status.
If and when legislators decide to invest in creating more top-tier universities, UTEP President Diana Natalicio said her campus is prepared to take on the challenge.
The research budget at UTEP has increased from about $7 million in 1990 to $45.7 million in 2006.
The number of doctoral programs at UTEP has grown from two in the 1990s to 14 today.
By 2015, Natalicio said she expects that lagging graduation rates at the school will improve and that the research budget will grow to $100 million.
"We're ready to go now," she said.
Yudof said UTEP is a strong competitor for top-tier status and having the new Texas Tech University medical school in El Paso helps.
But, he said, the school also must figure out how to maintain its mission of educating a largely low-income Hispanic population with many first-generation college students while increasing its quality and selectivity.
For any of the top-tier competitors, he said, change won't happen quickly even with an infusion of state dollars. Texas, he said, would be fortunate to create two to four such schools in the next 10 to 20 years.
"If you want to hold the bar that high, you have to be realistic about how much it's going to cost and how long it's going to take to get there," he said.
State Sen. Judith Zaffirini, D-Laredo, leads the Senate Subcommittee on Higher Education.
Legislators, she said, have seemingly little appetite to take on the controversial subject of higher education reorganization.
Those who want to bring to their communities the prestige and economic development that top-tier universities generate should pressure their local lawmakers for more investment in all of the state's institutions and in student financial aid, she said.
Texas, Zaffirini said, cannot have great higher education without both quality undergraduate education and world-class research.
"We have to do both," she said. "That's what excellence is all about."
El Paso Times
10/08/2007
Austin -- A report to Gov. Rick Perry about higher education found some disturbing trends.
The Governor's Business Council, a group of Texas business leaders that advise the governor, report that 25 to 34 year olds in Texas were less educated than the two preceding generations. And minorities, whose populations are increasing fastest, were getting the fewest degrees.
Among several recommendations in the report, the business leaders said Texas should emphasize both teaching undergraduates, especially minorities and those with low incomes, and increasing research capabilities.
The report stops short of specifically outlining how the state should realign universities but calls for reorganization where there is population growth and focusing on regional economic needs.
Texas has not handled the challenge of building top-tier universities well, said University of Texas System Chancellor Mark Yudof.
While Texas has two so-called flagship universities -- typically those with more than $100 million in federal research grants, selective admissions, low student-faculty ratios and competitive salaries -- California has eight such public institutions.
"We're a bit behind," Yudof said.
The seven universities hoping to move that number up for Texas are the University of Texas at El Paso, UT San Antonio, UT Dallas, UT Arlington, Texas Tech University, the University of Houston and the University of North Texas.
The schools are striving for more research dollars and building their academic offerings.
But achieving top-tier status will require more investment from the state so that the schools can hire more faculty, increase salaries and purchase equipment.
"Some would hope there could be a funding mechanism that could elevate more flagships into tier-one status," Texas Tech University regent Rick Francis said. "But that is going to elicit jealousies."
Legislators, he said, often have trouble supporting additional funding for a university in an area other than their own.
They "like to bring home the goodies so to speak," Francis said.
That makes it difficult to find consensus on which universities get the financial boost to achieve top-tier status.
If and when legislators decide to invest in creating more top-tier universities, UTEP President Diana Natalicio said her campus is prepared to take on the challenge.
The research budget at UTEP has increased from about $7 million in 1990 to $45.7 million in 2006.
The number of doctoral programs at UTEP has grown from two in the 1990s to 14 today.
By 2015, Natalicio said she expects that lagging graduation rates at the school will improve and that the research budget will grow to $100 million.
"We're ready to go now," she said.
Yudof said UTEP is a strong competitor for top-tier status and having the new Texas Tech University medical school in El Paso helps.
But, he said, the school also must figure out how to maintain its mission of educating a largely low-income Hispanic population with many first-generation college students while increasing its quality and selectivity.
For any of the top-tier competitors, he said, change won't happen quickly even with an infusion of state dollars. Texas, he said, would be fortunate to create two to four such schools in the next 10 to 20 years.
"If you want to hold the bar that high, you have to be realistic about how much it's going to cost and how long it's going to take to get there," he said.
State Sen. Judith Zaffirini, D-Laredo, leads the Senate Subcommittee on Higher Education.
Legislators, she said, have seemingly little appetite to take on the controversial subject of higher education reorganization.
Those who want to bring to their communities the prestige and economic development that top-tier universities generate should pressure their local lawmakers for more investment in all of the state's institutions and in student financial aid, she said.
Texas, Zaffirini said, cannot have great higher education without both quality undergraduate education and world-class research.
"We have to do both," she said. "That's what excellence is all about."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)