Translate

Showing posts with label Amanda Garcia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Amanda Garcia. Show all posts

Monday, May 19, 2025

From Dystopia to Texas: Let's NOT Let Fiction Become Our Reality—Hands Off our Colleges and Universities!

 Friends:

I owe this post—and my refusal to stay silent—to my grandchildren. They are the reason I continue to show up, speak out, join in community, build community-based institutions and resist the authoritarian drift we are witnessing in Texas. Yes, grandma is busy, but she has a special purpose in life and she is living it.

I just saw the movie, 2073, that features a grandmother that the viewer never sees because she was taken up, disappeared, for openly challenging the system. It was her work. It resonated. 

You can watch the movie on Max, Fandango, or Prime. It's definitely a doomsday, dystopian vision of what could be if we do not seriously work together across difference—not just locally, but globally—to address the current climate crisis we're in and the extreme, undue influence of the "Tech Bros"—the billionaire class—on democracy.

This is what we see playing out right now in the Texas legislature. There was a voucher amendment that would have submitted the vote to all Texans and advocates were hoping that seven or so Republicans would vote against, but that what allegedly happened is that they all got a call from President Trump (I heard this from two sources), and except for two Republicans, Dade Phelan and Rep. VanDeaver, they voted this bill to passage. 

After all, they, like the rest of us already knew that if vouchers were submitted to a vote by the public, Greg Abbott and pro-voucher Republicans would lose. Never mind democracy or what should be the democratic purposes of government. These rural Republican representatives, in particular, just sold their communities down the river. 

Now, here we are fighting against censorship, legislative takeover, and the Texas House panel cut us out from testifying!

What the dystopian film 2073 imagines as speculative, futuristic fiction—a regime that silences dissent through surveillance, bureaucratic control, and ideological conformity—is no longer fiction for those of us in Texas fighting for academic freedom. Senate Bill 37 operates with the same chilling logic: it punishes educators for teaching uncomfortable truths, strips faculty of shared governance, and closes public testimony before most people even have a chance to speak. 

In a press conference last Thursday afternoon, many students a faculty spoke up. Texas AFT’s Amanda Garcia, a recent graduate from UT Austin, lays out SB 37’s harm in stark, unequivocal terms: 

“This is not a bill we can risk cleaning up in the next legislative session. It will impact our students and teachers for the worse forever.”

Like the state in 2073, this legislature justifies censorship in the name of order and efficiency, but we know better. These are not neutral decisions—they are calculated efforts to control knowledge, erase histories, and shut down the very conversations that make education meaningful and genuinely helpful to a racial/ethnic and gender-diverse society.

What is happening in Texas is not just an attack on faculty—it is an attack on democracy itself. And we cannot afford to meet this moment with silence. We must name it, challenge it, and refuse to comply with the slow drift into authoritarianism. 

All of this is unfolding at a time when we face overlapping crises—none more urgent than the accelerating climate emergency. Instead of silencing educators and dismantling democratic institutions, our leaders should be confronting the existential threats that endanger all of us, especially our children and grandchildren.

On a positive note, there is still time.

-Angela Valenzuela

Faculty and students blast Texas House panel for limiting testimony on bill that targets state universities

The House's higher education committee closed registration to testify on Senate Bill 37 less than half an hour after the hearing started. About 20 people said they didn't get to address lawmakers.


University students and faculty gather at the Texas Capitol’s outdoor rotunda on May 15, 2025, to speak against Senate Bill 37, which would reshape how schools pick new courses and hire administrators. 
Credit: Lorianne Willett/The Texas Tribune


Pauline Strong wanted to speak to lawmakers last week about how a bill they’re considering would make her think twice when discussing sensitive topics with her anthropology students at the University of Texas at Austin. But she had to drop off her grandchildren at school first.

Despite rushing to the Texas Capitol afterward, she missed the window to register to testify against Senate Bill 37 by a few minutes.

Strong, who testified last session in opposition to a bill banning diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives in higher ed, didn’t expect registration to end so early this time.

“It was disappointing, it was surprising, it was disheartening,” Strong said. “And I’m someone who came from Austin. There were lots of people who were driving from Houston or other parts of the state who left very early in the morning and arrived too late to testify.”

Dozens of students and professors like Strong, who were unable to testify against a bill they fear could limit the free exchange of ideas on college campuses, voiced their frustration on Thursday over losing one of their few chances to address lawmakers directly.

“This is not a bill we can risk cleaning up in the next legislative session. It will impact our students and teachers for the worse forever,” said Amanda Garcia with the Texas American Federation of Teachers.

SB 37 would limit faculty’s influence on academic decisions and give university systems’ regents, who are political appointees, more power to decide what curricula are taught, as well as which administrators are hired at the state’s public colleges and universities.

It would also establish another way for universities to be investigated for breaking state law — and potentially lose funding at a time when they are already facing significant financial headwinds.

SB 37, which was passed by the Senate last month, was one of 10 bills scheduled for a public hearing in the House Higher Education Committee on May 6. During committee hearings, lawmakers debate the contents of a bill and invite witnesses to comment on the proposal. They also give the general public an opportunity to share their thoughts on the legislation.

Rep. Terry M. Wilson, the Georgetown Republican who chairs the committee, started the hearing just after 8 a.m. with an announcement — the committee would not accept any more people registering to testify for or against SB 37 after 8:30 a.m.

As chair, Wilson may limit testimony. He didn’t do so with another controversial proposal brought before his committee, House Bill 232, which would make it more difficult for undocumented students to qualify for in-state tuition. When HB 232 was considered on April 30, Wilson allowed people to register to testify until just before the hearing concluded at 1:06 a.m. the following day.

Wilson did not comment Thursday on his decision to close early the witness registration window for SB 37.

To Garcia, limiting testimony on SB 37 was a clear attempt to silence overwhelming dissent. To others, it was typical for a part-time Legislature that hurries to pass new laws in a 140-day window every two years — work that must conclude by June 2.

“They have to hustle in a way that doesn’t always lend itself to having many voices heard,” said Brandon Rottinghaus, a political science professor at the University of Houston.

Texas allows anyone to register to give testimony during committee hearings to go over proposed legislation, but the process can be cumbersome. People must register at kiosks in the Capitol by a deadline that each committee’s chair or clerk has broad discretion to set. The hearings can last all day and have long interruptions whenever members must leave to debate and vote on legislation in their chambers.

This makes it harder to participate for Texans who have jobs they can’t step away from or who don’t live near Austin. This session, farmers from Johnson County waited 18 hours to testify for a bill to limit toxic chemicals in fertilizers, and public school advocates waited 20 hours to testify against a bill to display the Ten Commandments in classrooms.

Sometimes, public testimony can result in more measured legislation, Rottinghaus said. He pointed to Senate Bill 3 as an example. Originally written in the Senate as a ban on THC, the House proposed only tightening regulations after hearing testimony that was both technical and emotional.

“Whether that will ultimately change the bill, I don’t know, but I think just as a general kind of notion that this is really important, that having people make their voice heard and giving legislators more information about what is going on is a big part of the process,” he said.

One of the concerns the professors and students who didn’t get to testify on SB 37 brought up on Thursday was that the proposal could limit the teaching of race and inequality.

Jaime CantĂș, an assistant professor of biology at Austin Community College, said the bill could keep future medical professionals from learning about health disparities. He worried that under SB 37, he could be fired for teaching his students about how Interstate 35 has historically served as a dividing line between those who have access to health care in Austin and those who do not. He said he often mentions this to his students, who are mostly low-income people of color making sacrifices to become nurses.

Aihanuwa Ale-opinion said she’s thankful to have learned about how public health structures have and can perpetuate inequality as a biology student at UH.

“Rather than instill feelings of guilt, this has empowered me with the knowledge necessary to create better structures that are more inclusive and has inspired me to be a better peer, a better professional and a better advocate,” she said.

State Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, who authored SB 37, said faculty have too much control over schools’ curricula, which has led to liberal bias in the classroom and many students taking classes that ultimately don’t serve them in their careers.

State Rep. Matt Shaheen, a Plano Republican carrying the legislation in the House, has proposed a version of the bill that removes some of the most controversial parts, such as a requirement that regents approve the hiring of faculty in certain disciplines and a provision to eliminate degree programs with a low return in students’ investment.

But the bill still has its detractors.

Both versions of the bill limit the number of faculty who can be elected to serve on bodies that advise the university or college administration. Both also contain a provision that says faculty who engage in political advocacy can be immediately removed from these bodies.

On May 6, the House Higher Education committee heard public testimony for about two hours before it recessed at about 10 a.m. They reconvened 11 hours later at 9 p.m. and adjourned at about 1 a.m. the next day. In the end, more than 80 people testified about SB 37.

Although Strong was one of 20 people who missed the deadline to register, she stayed at the Capitol all day, helping her colleagues whittle down their remarks and practice so they could maximize the time allowed to speak: two minutes.

In her 32 years at UT-Austin, Strong has developed curriculum and been on search committees to hire deans. She said she wanted to tell lawmakers that the bill’s premise is faulty.

Faculty who take on these responsibilities don’t do so lightly, and their goal is not to indoctrinate students, she said. In fact, she added, those students serve as one of several checks on faculty. They fill out surveys after every course, and any complaints they make are investigated and addressed through mentoring and discipline, which can include termination, Strong said.

“Faculty are not getting away with teaching that is shoddy, out-of-date, or ideologically narrow,” she said. “Our colleagues, administrators and students make sure of that.”

The Texas Tribune partners with Open Campus on higher education coverage.

Friday, April 04, 2025

April 3, 2025 Update on the Crucial Work of Texas AAUP and Texas AFT in the Texas Legislature

Friends,

I can't say enough about the excellent leadership we have in Texas fighting the good fight for higher education, meaning the right to learn, teach, and conduct research. C'mon folks it's not hard to see why we need this freedom in Texas higher education.

It is shady, by the way, that the legislature didn't livestream their voucher hearing today in the Texas State Legislature as they always do. It's crazy that folks watched the hearing on Twitter instead of the full light of day. Glad that the Twitter work-around allowed it to get covered regardless.

In any case, take a few minutes to listen to this April 3rd update on various bills under consideration at the Texas State Capitol. Thanks to Patty Quinzi, Amanda Garcia, and Brian Evans for all their incredible advocacy this session. AAUP and Texas AFT together constitute a formidable partnership. If your any one you know needs academic freedom and protection, please join AAUP here: https://connect.aft.org/app/memberforms/8041A/JoinTheFight

Happy to share.

-Angela Valenzuela



Monday, March 24, 2025

SB 37 – Faculty Senates & Curriculum—Texas AFT Bill Summary & Talking Points

Here is another analysis of SB 37 from Texas AFT. Numerous groups are engaged in this struggle, with Amanda Garcia emerging as a powerhouse organizer, leading the charge with remarkable skill and unwavering dedication. 

She works closely with AAUP President Brian Evan on the numerous bills targeting higher education, including those by Senators Bettencourt and Middleton, SB 1489, and SB 452, respectively, that are mentioned at the end of this AFT Summary below.

I applaud the numerous organizations involved, including Texas Students for DEI that Amanda and her peers formed during the 2023 session in response to Senate Bill 17, Texas' anti-DEI bill.

You can follow them on Instagram @txstudentsfordei

I re-post herein their most recent posts on these bad bills. Go to tinyurl.com/legetoolkit to their super helpful toolkit to learn of what you can do to combat these terrible proposals.

-Angela Valenzuela

SB 37 – Faculty Senates & Curriculum

Texas AFT Bill Summary & Talking Points

Contact agarcia@texasaft.org 

Broad Overview: SB 37 restructures the governance of public institutions of higher education by establishing oversight committees, increasing the power of governing boards, and limiting the autonomy of faculty councils to advisory roles. It mandates comprehensive evaluations of curricula and administrative decisions, tying state funding to compliance with new procedural standards. These changes constrain academic freedom, centralize excessive control in governing bodies, and burden institutions with bureaucratic processes that will hinder their educational mission and innovation.

SECTION 1: General Education Review Committees (Sec. 51.315) 

  • A new section, Section 51.315, is added to the Education Code establishing a "General Education Review Committee" for each institution of higher education.
  • Each institution must form a review committee to annually "maintain or eliminate” courses in the core curriculum and check for workforce alignment.
    • Shall ensure courses in the curriculum “do not endorse specific public policies, ideologies, or legislation” 
    • Composition: Committees may include tenured faculty and local industry partners.
    • Duties: The committee ensures courses are foundational, prepare students for civic and professional life, and are free from ideological endorsements.
    • Recommendations: Committees make recommendations on course retention or elimination, and institutions must publicly post these before board consideration.

    • Compliance Reporting: Institutions must certify compliance annually to the Office of Excellence and provide reports to continue receiving state funds. 
    • Institutions may not spend appropriated funds until the governing board submits to the legislature and THECB certifies compliance.

SECTION 2: Governing Board Powers and Duties (Sec. 51.352) 

    • New Responsibilities for Governing Boards: Boards will now have the authority to approve or deny the hiring of individuals for specific leadership positions (vice president, provost, dean, etc.) and must regularly evaluate the chief executive officer to assist them in achieving performance goals such as student retention and graduation rates.
    • “Maintaining or increasing student retention and graduation rates, the amount of money available for research, and making efforts to ensure a variety of perspectives are represented among administration and faculty”
    • Decision-Making Authority: Governing boards can now overturn decisions made by campus administrations and must post notices on their websites about meetings where finalists for leadership positions will be considered, along with the curriculum vitae of those candidates.
    • Annual Reporting: The governing board must annually report to the governor, the lieutenant governor, the speaker of the house, and each member of the legislature a report regarding decisions made by the board for the academic year on:
      • The hiring of administration and faculty, curriculum, any review and evaluation of the institution’s administration


SECTION 3: Faculty Council or Senate (Sec. 51.3522) 

      • Sec. 51.3522 Defines a faculty council or senate, and only the governing board may establish a faculty council/senate that adopts the policies:
    • Members must be tenured.
    • For each college or school: one member appointed by the institution president, one member elected by faculty vote.
    • A faculty senate is advisory only, and “may not publish a report directly related to the council’s duties.”
    • Each proposal from faculty senates must be reviewed by the governing board, institution administration, and system administration. 
    • A member serves a one-year term and may only be a member again after four years.
    • Notices/business must be made public:
    • Agendas “with sufficient detail to indicate the items on which final action is contemplated”
    • Votes must also be public when pertaining to a vote of no confidence and policies related to curriculum and academic standards.
    • Advertisements for tenured faculty positions except STEM fields

SECTION 4: Minor Degree and Certificate Programs Review (Sec. 51.989) 

    • Sec. 51.989 is added to specify the review process for minor degree and certificate programs
    • đŸš©Review Criteria: The president and provost must develop a process for reviewing minor and certificate programs and identify programs with low enrollment, leading to consolidation or elimination. 
    • To avoid consolidation or elimination, undergraduate programs must have graduated at least 10 students in the preceding two years, OR at least 5 students enrolled at the time of review; graduate programs must have at least 3 students enrolled at the time of review and 3 students graduated in the preceding two years.
    • Must show industry data demonstrating workforce demand for the program.
    • Periodic Review: Presidents and provosts conduct reviews every four years, subject to board approval for any changes. 

SECTION 5: Governing Board Member Training (Sec. 61.084)

    • Training Content: Focuses on roles, duties, governance topics like ethics, policy development, and budgeting.
    • Topics covered: audit procedures, legislation that creates higher education institutions, the role of governing boards including its disciplinary and investigative authorities, faculty council/senate policies, the Legislature and state budget.
    • Affirmation: Board members must affirm understanding of their responsibilities upon completing training. 

SECTION 6: Faculty Evaluation (Sec. 51.942) 

    • Evaluation Process: New requirement for comprehensive performance evaluations for tenured faculty members to occur at least once every six years and no more than once every yea
    • Performance evaluation is based on teaching, research, service, patient care, administration, and peer review. It should also be directed toward professional development. The performance evaluation will incorporate “commonly recognized” due process rights. For those receiving unsatisfactory ratings, a short-term development plan with performance benchmarks must be established.
    • đŸš© “A faculty member is subject to revocation of tenure or disciplinary action for incompetency, neglect of duty, or other good cause; a faculty member may not be involved in decision-making in a grievance review process or faculty discipline process.”

SECTION 7: Office of Excellence in Higher Education (Ch. 454, Government Code)

    • Establishment: The Office of Excellence in Higher Education, administratively attached to the THECB. The director of the office will be appointed by the governor with approval by the senate.
    • “Serves at the pleasure of the governor.”
    • Mandates the creation of General Education Review Committees within each institution to annually assess the core curriculum and provide recommendations on coursework, ensuring that these courses meet foundational educational standards while maintaining neutrality regarding public policies.
    • Role: Acts as an intermediary between the legislature, the public, and institutions. The office is responsible for investigating noncompliance by institutions with state law or institution policy. An institution must respond to the office’s information request within 30 days. Findings will be submitted to the attorney general and the governing board and is subject to investigation. 
    • Annual Report: The office will submit an annual report to the governor, lieutenant governor, the attorney general, and the chair of each standing committee the number of reports of noncompliance, the number of investigations, and a summary of investigations results.


SECTION 8-11: Implementation and Transition 

    • Timelines: Implementation begins in the 2025-2026 academic year, with initial recommendations due by 2027. 
    • Existing Councils: Current faculty councils must be reconstituted or ratified by October 1, 2025, to comply with new standards. These sections collectively aim to increase oversight and standardize processes across Texas public higher education institutions, with significant implications for governance, academic freedom, and administrative operations.