Translate

Showing posts with label San Juan Puerto Rico. Show all posts
Showing posts with label San Juan Puerto Rico. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 10, 2022

LULAC Blocks Takeover by Pro-Statehood Puerto Ricans, Suspends CEO

Glad to see this article published in Latino Rebels. As expressed again herein, President Domingo Garcia states LULAC's position with respect to statehood. It is one of "neutral respect for the self-determination of the Puerto Rican people." LULAC cannot and should not ever take a partisan position as this is against our constitution. Nonpartisanship has served us well historically as a civil rights organization and will continue to do so going forward. 

-Angela Valenzuela

LULAC Blocks Takeover by Pro-Statehood Puerto Ricans, Suspends CEO

AUG 9, 2022
5:35 PM


2020 Democratic presidential candidate and current Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg on stage at a LULAC Presidential Town Hall with Telemundo news anchor Leticia Castro and LULAC National President Domingo Garcia at the College of Southern Nevada, February 13, 2020, in North Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)

The chief executive officer for the nation’s oldest Latino civil rights organization has been temporarily suspended while a Texas judge put the brakes on its board election.

Domingo García, national president of the League of United Latin American Citizens, told Latino Rebels that CEO Sindy Benavides has been “temporarily suspended pending an investigation by the personnel committee of LULAC.”

Benavides could not be immediately reached for comment.

García confirmed the tip received by Latino Rebels after a judge in Texas ordered the organization to put its election on pause. The order from the Dallas judge came after five leaders of LULAC councils filed a lawsuit against board members the night before hundreds of delegates from across the U.S. were expected to vote in-person for 12 national positions, including the organization’s next president.

The LULAC council leaders filed the lawsuit to prevent the New Progressive Party (PNP in Spanish), a pro-statehood political party in Puerto Rico, from rigging the election. The lawsuit called the election “entirely illegitimate” and said the PNP “devised a scheme to take over LULAC’s leadership.”

“The Plaintiffs hope that this action ensures that LULAC has fair elections and that partisan entities will stay out of trying to control LULAC’s officers and affairs,” said Jeffery Tillotson, who is representing the LULAC council leaders in the lawsuit.

In the order halting the election, the judge found that the defendants continued to engage in “a fraudulent and illicit scheme to place LULAC under the irreversible control of a foreign political party in violation of LULAC.”

García is listed among the defendants but does not support the infiltration.

“We will not let the corruption of the Partido Nuevo Progresista, or New Progressive Party, or any partisan political party stain the good name of our organization,” García said in a statement.

“We’re just very concerned that an outside partisan third party appears to have attempted to influence and buy the national leadership of LULAC,” García told Latino Rebels.

After Benavides told The Hill in March that the group was supporting the push for statehood, in June García reiterated LULAC’s position on Puerto Rico’s status as being one of neutral respect for the self-determination of the Puerto Rican people.

The LULAC council leaders that filed the lawsuit alleged that the PNP used illicit political funds to form nearly 300 councils in the last three months, spending over $700,000 to ensure control over the election.

“We are investigating the source of the funds. We’re talking about close to a million dollars that was spent to try to buy an election through outside money, and we’re trying to determine the source and follow the money trail. If it turns out to be illegal or tainted funds, then we need to return them. We don’t want to have anything to do with any campaign that used those funds,” García said.

LULAC council leaders also alleged in their lawsuit that the PNP hopes to elect Juan Carlos Lizardi as LULAC’s next president. Lizardi was slated to run against García in this year’s election.

After the election was postponed, Lizardi, the son of LULAC board member and statehood activist Elsie Valdes. posted a statement on Facebook.

“A strategy was used to influence not having an election by discouraging or preventing members from voting,” Lizardi said. “I look forward to working with all of you on the issues we need to fight, especially to guarantee that voter suppression does not continue. Inside or outside of our beloved organization.”

As LULAC carries out its investigation, LULAC officers are prohibited from participating in any election-related activity until this Friday, unless determined otherwise at the judge’s scheduled hearing for the lawsuit.

“LULAC has always fought against corruption and for the civil rights of all Latinos, and we are doing this with this attempt by an outside party to try and take over LULAC,” García said.

***

Chantal Vaca is a summer correspondent for Futuro Media based in New York City and a graduate of the Columbia University School of Journalism. Twitter: @VacaChantal

Dear LULAC of Iowa members, By Hola Iowa -August 8, 2022

Just came across this letter from HolaAmericaNews. It's a letter to LULAC of Iowa. I post it because it captures well the gist of what played out recently in San Juan, Puerto Rico where we nearly experienced a coup, a takeover, of our organization by the Island Puerto Rican Republican Party, which is clearly misnamed the Partido Nuevo Progresista (PNP), meaning the New Progressive Party. They seek statehood for Puerto Rico which is not necessarily a progressive stance. Even less progressive is their decision to attempt to railroad their agenda by voting a former board member's son, Juan Carlos Lizardi, into the presidency of LULAC to enforce this agenda for statehood over the wishes of others on the Island. I really encourage everyone to read the Dallas federal judge's Temporary Restraining Order that I've already posted to this blog and that gets mentioned in the Hola Iowa piece below. 

I am in total agreement that Iowa LULAC's state director, Nicholas Salazar, who expresses that LULAC's voting process and constitutional loopholes need updating. We, in fact, need a constitutional convention at some point once this legal debacle is behind us. And I would add that this could be a great opportunity to not just update the organization, but to invigorate it for the current generations who might get cynical if we fail to do so. LULAC needs to be a big tent that welcomes class, racial/ethnic, and gender diversity while being multigenerational itself. 

An interesting irony is that we may be better poised for this than ever. In Spanish, we have the expression, No hay mal que por bien no venga, meaning that out of bad things, good things come. I have practically lived my life by this. Much good can come of this moment. 

Que viva LULAC! Long live LULAC!

-Angela Valenzuela

Dear LULAC of Iowa members


I am reaching out to report back on behalf of our delegation to the 2022 LULAC National Convention in San Juan, Puerto Rico last week.  Overall it was a productive trip but we did have an issue with the elections at the National Assembly.

The national elections were suspended due to a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) that was issued to LULAC and its National Board by a District Court in Texas that prevented the assembly from holding elections.  To put it broadly – the TRO which was petitioned by a LULAC Council in Dallas, Texas, alleges that a partisan organization in Puerto Rico called the New Popular Party (NPP) devised a plan to take over LULAC and its leadership by funneling hundreds of thousands of dollars to LULAC operatives and leadership on the mainland and island.  This allegedly involved creating hundreds of “paper councils” on the island to create illegitimate delegates, paying transportation and hotels for votes, and influencing LULAC operatives to run for LULAC National Board.

The Iowa delegation received the TRO the morning of the assembly so we did not attend.  Unfortunately, since it’s one of the main reasons to go and represent our membership and have our voice heard as a state charter.  However, an illegitimate election still took place that was mostly led by LULAC operatives and leadership involved in the alleged scheme – breaching the TRO that was issued.  This action of holding an illegitimate election and the ongoing investigation has so far resulted in the suspension of several LULAC National Officers and the immediate discharge of former LULAC CEO Sindy Benavides.  These types of actions can also result in expulsion from the league, fines, lawsuits, and jail time.

I am sharing this to make sure our leaders and members are aware of what is going on at the national level in case we are not receiving press releases or hearing the news.  We do not want outside partisan groups to influence LULAC.  This is also the result of LULAC leadership over the years ignoring calls to update the draconian voting process and close constitutional loopholes to avoid situations like this.  

LULAC National who promotes democracy and champions voting should not have issues in their own house. 

LULAC of Iowa will continue to focus on state and local issues.  Please let me know if you have any questions, comments, or action items on this topic.  I will keep our leaders/members up-to-date.

Thank you,

Nicholas Salazar – State Director

League of United Latin American Citizens of Iowa


Wednesday, August 03, 2022

Signed Affidavit: Eye-opening and Shocking Detail of the Behind-The-Scenes Politics in National LULAC

Friends:

Emotions are understandably high in the wake of the attempted coup of National LULAC by Republican Party Puerto Rican Islander leadership at the National Convention in San Juan Puerto Rico last Saturday, July 30, 2022. There is also a lot of misinformation going out. I hope to lend clarity with this post.

Specifically, I would urge anyone that wants to offer any criticism against LULAC right now to not do so without reading this sworn account by Bethzaida Olivera Vazquez that is downloadable here [pdf]. 

She provides an eye-opening, if not shocking, account of what has been happening behind the scenes in National LULAC over the years. 

Read for yourself. I cannot exaggerate this.

As per my July 30, 2022 post to this blog, this should be read alongside the Temporary Restraining Order issued by a Dallas, Texas, federal judge that was supposed to have halted last Saturday's election [downloadable here [pdf]. 

In violation of this injunction, the election happened anyway. It's curious that instead of "lawyering up," in response to the injunction, some of the LULAC leadership chose this route instead. Those that did not attend or participate in the election—which was most of the board—are fine. Those that did not will have to answer to the court. 

Do read, as well, this encouraging press release posted below by LULAC President Domingo Garcia that went out on Monday, August 1st. Out of bad things come good things, for sure. I love the tone of brighter days to come. We should all be heartened that these shenanigans are getting exposed to the light of day.

The hearing before the Dallas judge is coming up soon, as well, so stay tuned. 

-Angela Valenzuela

Follow LULAC on Twitter: @LULAC






 

Saturday, July 30, 2022

LULAC Was Served A Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), Averting a Hostile Takeover by Members of the Partido Nuevo Progresista (PNP)


Geez, what a week here in San Juan Puerto Rico! Our ancestors were surely crying out from their graves that LULAC is neither a partisan organization, nor is it up for sale.

What a terrible idea to seek to submit our organization to the rancorous politics over statehood in Puerto Rico.

Do read yesterday's post by journalist Suzanne Gamboa and the entirety of this message to gain a fuller understanding. The first is the message, including the Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), that we all received this morning putting us on notice that the election had been stopped and the second is a more elaborate statement by LULAC President Domingo Garcia from this evening in both English and Spanish. 

The short of it is that yesterday evening's issuance of the TRO brought the election to a screeching halt and that election fraud will get investigated. 
Today is a proud day for National LULAC. 

Thanks to President Garcia and our LULAC leaders for their competent leadership and loyalty to our constitution in these troubled times. 

For now, we can all breathe a sigh of relief. 

-Angela Valenzuela


Dear LULAC Members in Puerto Rico,

 

LULAC was served tonight with a temporary restraining order (TRO) that enjoins or prevents us from having a national election in San Juan, Puerto Rico, on Saturday, July 30, 2022. The members of the national board are named as defendants in the matter, and as such, any actions by them or anyone else that violates the TRO can and will have serious consequences up to and including monetary fines and jail time.

 

In light of this legal action, I am informing you that the national assembly meeting scheduled for Saturday, July 30, 2022, is in recess until the matter has been heard in court, as mandated by the TRO. You are advised not to go to the assembly hall as no lawful meeting is allowed. Please continue your visit and other travel plans while in San Juan, and I will keep you informed on the next steps in this matter.

 

Sincerely,

 

Domingo

Domingo Garcia, LULAC National President


Thursday, July 28, 2022

Latino civil rights group could see bigger push for Puerto Rico statehood: Puerto Rican LULAC members are growing their ranks and could change the leadership and makeup of the historically Mexican American organization

Here at the National LULAC Convention in San Juan, Puerto Rico, where this will get decided. Just being here on the island and talking to regular folks, this is a very emotional issue. It cuts hard three ways. Some want statehood; others independence, and others, the status quo which is commonwealth status with sizeable numbers in each category. 

It's not looking good for President Domingo Garcia. If he loses the election, this will definitely be a game changer. We'll see what happens at Saturday's business meeting. Whatever happens, I sense that this dynamic will be playing out for a long time, not just within LULAC, but for folks on island, as well. More to come.

-Angela Valenzuela

Puerto Rican LULAC members are growing their ranks and could change the leadership and makeup of the historically Mexican American organization.

Puerto Rican members of the country’s oldest Latino civil rights organization are rapidly growing their ranks to potentially tilt the group’s coming elections and escalate its lobbying for statehood.

The League of United Latin American Citizens, or LULAC, founded in 1929 by Mexican Americans in Texas, is scheduled to hold its elections this summer at its national convention in San Juan, Puerto Rico — its first conference since 2019 because of the coronavirus pandemic.

LULAC’s president, Domingo García, faces a challenge from Juan Carlos Lizardi, president of a LULAC council in New York and the son of one of LULAC’s board members, Elsie Valdés, who is Puerto Rican and a statehood activist.

The contest is pushing LULAC further into the fight over Puerto Rico’s status, worrying some members that if Lizardi wins, the issue will dominate over others for which LULAC advocates.

It also stands to shift the leadership of the organization, which has always been Mexican American. LULAC was formed Feb. 17, 1929, in Corpus Christi, Texas, by Mexican Americans in the state, some of them business leaders and professionals.

As the election plays out, the divisive issue of Puerto Rico’s status is also creating some fractures within LULAC.

Puerto Rico is a U.S. territory. Although all Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens, those who live on the island cannot vote in U.S. congressional or presidential elections. The territory’s representative in Congress — called a resident commissioner — cannot vote on legislation on the floor.

Puerto Ricans are divided among those who want statehood and those who prefer the current territorial status; a smaller percentage want Puerto Rico to be independent. Previous votes on the issue in Puerto Rico have been rife with controversy.

Although LULAC's CEO recently said the organization is taking a stand in support of statehood, based on a 2018 resolution, its president said otherwise.

“I support Puerto Ricans’ right to self-determination and a fair election,” García told NBC News. “But LULAC is bigger than that. We’re dealing with immigration and education and funding for that. I just met with the chief of police in Los Angeles regarding criminal justice reform.”

Lizardi and his supporters hold an advantage in the election because LULAC’s constitution allows only those who show up at the conference to vote.

Some LULAC members are forgoing the trip to Puerto Rico for the July conference because of cost concerns. In a close vote, the LULAC board rejected proposals to cancel this year’s conference.  

Meanwhile, members on the island are rapidly escalating the number of “councils” — LULAC’s local entities — in Puerto Rico and New York. Most have been formed in the past three months.

Last year, Puerto Rico had 54 councils. As of this month it has 170 — having added 116 in the last two months. Texas, because it is where LULAC was founded and because of its size, has tended to have the most councils; it had 206 last year.

Lizardi did not respond to email or phone messages requesting comment.

In a phone interview, Valdés said councils are often created at election time when there is more interest in the leadership races, which motivates involvement. Other candidates have formed councils in Puerto Rico, more than this year, to increase their votes, she said.

"All presidents elected since Belen Robles up to Domingo Garcia have been elected thanks to Puerto Ricans’ votes," said Valdés, a 32-year LULAC member and the organization's national VP of the Women's Commission.

Hilda Duarte, the president of a Dallas LULAC council, said she may not be able to afford to attend the convention unless other members help pay her costs.

She said she is concerned about the sudden growth in LULAC councils in Puerto Rico and how it might shift LULAC's priorities.

“The Puerto Ricans want statehood. That’s something they have to decide. They are the ones who have to vote and get excited and once and for all settle their future. … We’ll support whatever they do,” Duarte said.

Two bipartisan bills addressing Puerto Rico's status are competing in Congress, both sponsored by Puerto Rican members of Congress. One is pushing for statehood and the other would create a process for deciding Puerto Rico's status.

'This is a Latino issue'

This month, LULAC CEO Sindy Benavides refocused attention on LULAC's 2018 resolution supporting statehood, resurfacing it in a recent interview in The Hill.

Until the interview, the nearly four-year-old resolution has gotten little attention since its passage by LULAC members who attended its 2018 Phoenix convention.