Translate

Showing posts with label gag orders. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gag orders. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 07, 2025

Testifying Through Midnight: Standing for Higher Ed and Academic Freedom in Texas: SB 37 Left Pending, But Our Commitment Is Not

 

A Long Day, A Powerful Stand: Testifying Against SB 37

I’m so proud of all of us who testified last night in opposition to Senate Bill 37. We signed up between 7:30 and 8:30 AM and didn’t finish until around 1:15 AM—that’s when this photo was taken. It was a marathon day, but a meaningful one.

SB 37 proposes a sweeping, bureaucratic overhaul that strips faculty of their rightful role in shaping curriculum. It transfers decision-making power away from those who know the content best—our educators—and places it in the hands of politically appointed regents. It aims to intimidate faculty from teaching about race, gender, religion, politics, or sexuality. It's a glorified gag order.

Under this bill, anyone can anonymously report a faculty member to an ombudsman, who would then escalate the case to the Legislature. Each public college and university in Texas would be required to establish an internal mechanism to manage these complaints—effectively creating a statewide surveillance system. 

Someone likened this to Nazi Germany in their testimony.  "Thought police," they said. Some are calling it the "Death Star," because it will so horribly harm higher education should it pass. Yes, our expertise, autonomy, and inclusive education are under attack, but we're pushing back as we speak. 

For a helpful breakdown, I encourage you to read this excellent blog post by the Texas AAUP: SB 37: Undue Big-Government Intrusion into Public Higher Ed.

Someone at the hearing noted—and I agree—that the very filing of this bill, especially following last session’s SB 17, has already inflicted serious damage on Texas higher education. Faculty are leaving in droves, and their replacements are nowhere in sight, particularly with stories of failing search committees. We're having difficulty recruiting doctoral students right now at UT, especially when they have other, better options. 

I tell prospective students that now is the time to come to UT. Join the movement! I've never seen so much youth engagement in the legislature in the 25 years of my own involvement. Many of us are literally harvesting the fruits of our labor. Gen Z is changing the world, but they need us. We're in this together.

Frankly, SB 37 would be laughable if it weren’t so dangerous. This bill is not just ridiculous; it’s harmful. And the fact that it’s even under consideration speaks volumes about where we are politically.

Still, in the face of this, I feel immense gratitude. I’m honored to be part of the beautiful, resilient community that has come together around this fight. Deep thanks to AAUP President Brian Evans and Texas AFT’s Amanda Garcia for their tireless leadership, and to all the students and faculty who traveled from across the state to testify.

SB 37 was left pending, which means the fight isn’t over.

My dear friends and colleagues, we can win this. We just can't let our guard down. 📢 Take action: Please reach out to your representatives and urge them to oppose this harmful bill. Here's a resource to help you do just that:

👉 ACTION LINK

Then we'll party! 😊😊😊

In solidarity,

-Angela Valenzuela

Saturday, March 15, 2025

These Words Are Disappearing in the New Trump Administration, New York Times, March 7, 2025

Friends:

It's good to know the exact words that are disappearing so that they can come back once we have new leadership. It's a weird list, by the way—and very lengthy. Either Trump and DOGE are taking cues from Texas or the other way around, as an earlier published piece that I wrote titled "Monopoly Tycoons in a Game of Jenga: The Censorship of Bodies, Protest, and Speech at UT-Austin" suggests.


Whether UT-Austin or the U.S. government, no list like this should exist to begin with in the "free" world—or any other world, for that matter. And yes, we should be outraged by this since we can't transform reality unless we can name it. I love this appropriate quote by Nisargadatta Maharaj that links our very humanity to the ability to name:

"The mind craves for formulations and definitions, always eager to squeeze reality into a verbal shape."

I know that Trump's list is upsetting for a democratic (lowercase "d") mindset that respects free speech and decries censorship. It upsets me, too. However, the minute I feel my blood pressure rise, I readily take heart in the power of culture itself to overcome this trying moment.

According to cultural theorists like Gloria Anzaldúa, Emma Perez, and Homi Bhabha, culture is powerful. It can and will overcome censoriousness by emphasizing resistance, hybridity,  and the subversive potential of marginalized voices. To understand this, one must first know that, like race, ethnicity, or gender, cultures are neither fixed nor monolithic, no matter how hard one might wish this to be. Rather, they are continuously reshaped through interaction and negotiation, such as when we see this in the continual "re-mixing" of dance, music, food, and artistic expression.

This liminal, in-between space that the late Gloria Anzaldúa terms, "Nepantla," allows for new meanings and interpretations to emerge, challenging rigid, censorious policies and guidelines that seek to control discourse. 

A good example of Nepantla is the Mexican American experience that gave rise to "Spanglish," a fluid linguistic practice that blends Spanish and English. Speaking Spanglish has long been an actual skill that only Spanish-Engligh bilingual and bicultural individuals can speak. They acquired this by navigating multiple linguistic and cultural worlds simultaneously. Such adaptations exist for all languages across all contexts inevitably, historically. That's why not only there is no such thing as a "pure" language, by why those that seek it, die (e.g., Latin, Esperanto, Sanskrit, and Coptic).

Glad to see that "Chicana" and "Chicano" didn't make the list despite how progressive these terms are. The bad news is that this is so because they never made it on any website to begin with. The good news is that we never stopped being Chicana nor Chicano—or Chicanx. Not that we don't also have other identities and identifiers, but rather that we were correct in knowing from the very beginning that we Chicanas/os live entire existences in Nepantla—forever between worlds, entremundos.

Living in Nepantla gives us great skills that we should totally rely on in this current political moment. These have helped us to be better border crossers, traversing linguistic, geographical, socioeconomic, sociopolitical, and sociocultural borders—oftentimes all in the same day. And not always with ease, but criss-crossing nevertheless. 

We were made for this moment! 😁

Additionally, culture has an inherent transformative power that enables individuals and communities to reclaim their agency via storytelling, poetry, and multiple forms of artistic expression, and reinterpretation of dominant narratives. 

The larger point for U.S. society and the world is that instead of running away from culture—that is arguably moving at breakneck speed without anyone's permission—our task as the denizens and caretakers of future generations is to embrace ambiguity, irony, and an ongoing subversion of symbolic orders.

We must also be humble and willing to live with uncertainty. It's good for us all that culture resists simplification and censorship. Moreover, the power of culture, combined with the ease of technology we enjoy today is that alternative perspectives and suppressed histories will undoubtedly, if stubbornly, find a voice.

Separately, as researcher and teacher of teachers, future policymakers, and future school leaders, my main concern is that we not forget about decades of research that views teachers as the crucial link between culture and learning, especially for minoritized students. This basic understanding is ever the more important because our nation is only becoming more culturally and linguistically diverse while the teacher workforce is predominantly white.

Regardless of race, ethnicity, or color, the teacher workforce would do well to step back, reflect, and look at how racial and ethnic relations on the campus or school ground are always informed by cultural exchanges and power dynamics that shape not just student, but teacher, experiences, opportunities, and sense of belonging. This is something captured well in Vivian Paley's classic text White Teacher. Acknowledging these influences, educators can foster more diverse, inclusive, and equitable learning environments.

Do heed this core idea: Cultural exchange, reinterpretation, and hybridity weaken the grip of censorship by making it difficult for any single authority to fully control meaning. This dynamic nature of culture creates opportunities for resistance, dialogue, and the continual evolution of thought, which can and will erode the power of censorship over time.

Successful school leaders and teachers adapt their communication styles to align with students' cultural backgrounds. Theirs is ideally also, always, an ongoing project of building trust and community. 

For the rest of us, yes, let's challenge censorship and censorious policies and practices. However, let's all still live our best lives, everybody, no matter what.

Can't let any of this get us down. I know I don't have time for this and imagine you don't either. See you in Nepantla! 🩷

-Angela Valenzuela

References


Anzaldúa, G. (2004). Borderlands/la frontera. Aunt Lute Books.

Bhabha, H. K. (2012). The location of culture. Routledge.

Chávez, M. S. (2015). Let’s meet in Nepantla: The possibility of third space as a place “others” call home. Journal of Latinos and Education, 14(4), 336-344.

Paley, V. G. (2000). White teacher. Harvard University Press.

Pérez, E. (1999). The decolonial imaginary: Writing Chicanas into history. Indiana University Press.

***


By Karen Yourish, Annie Daniel, Saurabh Datar, Isaac White and Lazaro Gamio 

March 7, 2025

As President Trump seeks to purge the federal government of “woke” initiatives, agencies have flagged hundreds of words to limit or avoid, according to a compilation of government documents.

Reporting was contributed by Julian Barnes, Christopher Flavelle, Dylan Freedman, Apoorva Mandavilli, Katrina Miller and Nicholas Nehamas. See more on: U.S. Politics, Donald Trump



Notes: Some terms listed with a plus sign represent combinations of words that, when used together, acknowledge transgender people, which is not in keeping with the current federal government’s position that there are only two, immutable sexes. Any term collected above was included on at least one agency’s list, which does not necessarily imply that other agencies are also discouraged from using it.

The above terms appeared in government memos, in official and unofficial agency guidance and in other documents viewed by The New York Times. Some ordered the removal of these words from public-facing websites, or ordered the elimination of other materials (including school curricula) in which they might be included.

In other cases, federal agency managers advised caution in the terms’ usage without instituting an outright ban. Additionally, the presence of some terms was used to automatically flag for review some grant proposals and contracts that could conflict with Mr. Trump’s executive orders.

The list is most likely incomplete. More agency memos may exist than those seen by New York Times reporters, and some directives are vague or suggest what language might be impermissible without flatly stating it.

All presidential administrations change the language used in official communications to reflect their own policies. It is within their prerogative, as are amendments to or the removal of web pages, which The Times has found has already happened thousands of times in this administration.

Still, the words and phrases listed here represent a marked — and remarkable — shift in the corpus of language being used both in the federal government’s corridors of power and among its rank and file. They are an unmistakable reflection of this administration’s priorities.

For example, the Trump administration has frequently framed diversity, equity and inclusion efforts as being inherently at odds with what it has identified as “merit,” and it has argued that these initiatives have resulted in the elevation of unqualified or undeserving people. That rhetorical strategy — with its baked-in assumption of a lack of capacity in people of color, women, the disabled and other marginalized groups — has been criticized as discriminatory.

Indeed, in some cases, guidance against a term’s usage has arrived alongside directives intended to eliminate the concept itself. Federal diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives are one example; the Gulf of Mexico is a very different one.

That shift is already apparent on hundreds of federal government websites. A New York Times analysis of pages on federal agency websites, before and after Mr. Trump took office, found that more than 250 contained evidence of deletions or amendments to words included in the above list.

Here are some notable examples. Words that have been removed are shown in red with strikethroughs, and words that have been added are in green with underlines.

Federal Aviation Administration’s job page



National Park Service’s Stonewall National Monument web page




2021 Head Start memo



Key topics page of State Department’s Office of Global Change



The total number of web pages identified by The Times as having changed is an undercount. The analysis involved searching for changes on more than 5,000 total pages, but it did not capture the entire universe of the federal government’s web presence. In addition, the pages were captured for comparison in early February, and more changes may have been made between then and now.

The president and some of his closest advisers, including Elon Musk, have frequently portrayed themselves as champions of free speech. One of the executive orders Mr. Trump signed on his first day back in office decried what it described as a pressure campaign by the Biden administration to stifle First Amendment rights “in a manner that advanced the Government’s preferred narrative about significant matters of public debate,” by way of putting pressure on tech platforms. “Government censorship of speech is intolerable in a free society,” it continued.

Indeed, the office of the presidency carries with it a tremendous power to drive the discourse. But the pattern of vanishing words established here suggests Mr. Trump and his administration may be more interested in chilling the national conversation — at least when it comes to their own disfavored topics — than in expanding it.

Are you a federal worker? We want to hear from you.

The Times would like to hear about your experience as a federal worker under the second Trump administration. We may reach out about your submission, but we will not publish any part of your response without contacting you first.


NOTE: PLEASE GO TO THIS ARTICLE TO TELL YOUR STORY TO THE NY TIMES 

The Trump Administration’s First 100 Days

Related Content







Thursday, June 08, 2023

History Is a Human Right, by Jesse Hagopian



Great piece by Jesse Hagopian. This quote connects well to the earlier piece on fascism that I just posted:

"We now live in an era defined by the rise of anti-truth and anti-history laws. The outlawing of an honest education represents a sharp turn toward authoritarianism in the United States — what historian Barbara Ransby has called proto-fascism — where now almost half of students are subjected to some form of banning of the truth about systemic racism and oppression.

The goal of these laws is to deny young people access to the lessons of history that could aid in building struggles against inequity."

Let's not reproduce the nonsensical statement that we live in a
"post-truth" world when it's really fascism that's at play.

History absolutely is a human right—and it's essential to the fight against book bans and for trans rights, Ethnic Studies, women and genders studies, and so on. and youth and community empowerment. Go to this link by the Zinn Education Project if you want to connect to the June 10th national Teach The Truth mobilization happening on Saturday.

Great job, Jesse!

-Angela Valenzuela

#TeachTheTruth


From Stone Mountain to the Stonewall Inn, the #TeachTruth National Day of Action fights back against anti-history legislation. 

Jesse Hagopian 
May 24, 2023
Word in Black 

Pasadena MD at Banned Books Photo Booth, June 2022, Photograph courtesy of Lynda Davis, Zinn Education Project

With almost half of all students in the United States attending a school whose educators have been given educational gag orders to prohibit them from teaching honestly about the history of systemic racism, a grassroots network of educators, parents, and students across the country are organizing a #TeachTruth National Day of Action on June 10, 2023, to fight back.

Research from the CRT Forward Tracking Project out of the UCLA Law School reveals that measures attacking truthful teaching about race have been passed at either the federal, state, or local level in every state except Vermont — laws that impact “over 22 million public school children, almost half of the country’s 50.8 million public school students.”

The impact of these anti-history laws is difficult to overstate. In Iowa, high school teacher Greg Wickenkamp asked his superintendent, “Knowing that I should stick to the facts, and knowing that to say ‘slavery was wrong,’ that’s not a fact, that’s a stance, is it acceptable for me to teach students that slavery was wrong?” Instead of giving the only morally acceptable answer—”Yes! Slavery was wrong” — Noll replied: “We had people that were slaves within our state. We’re not supposed to say to [students], ‘How does that make you feel?’ We can’t — or, ‘Does that make you feel bad?’ We’re not to do that part of it.”

Wickenkamp described another attack on an Iowa educator that highlights that the worst attacks have been perpetrated against women of color: “I had a colleague who was a Latina teacher. She was pushed out because of hostile treatment. The strain and hostility she faced was much worse than anything I faced. I don’t know if she’ll return to teaching or not, but she was the first generation in her family to go to college — her case is markedly more challenging because of systemic factors.”

Experiences such as those in Iowa have been all too common around the country as attacks on truthful teaching about race, gender, and sexuality are being used as a campaign strategy for the Republican Party. Chris Guerrieri, a 22-year veteran teacher from Duval County, Florida, explained to local media, “An admin of the district recently told the media specialist that if you’re teaching slavery, make sure you’re teaching the positive sides of it as well.”

An admin of the district recently told the media specialist that if you’re teaching slavery, make sure you’re teaching the positive sides of it as well.

Chris Guerrieri, 22-year veteran teacher in Florida

Another educator — in Florida, where a bill was recently passed to make it a third-degree felony (carrying up to five years in jail and a $5,000 fine) to be caught with verboten books on race, gender, or sexuality — responded to a survey by the Zinn Education Project (ZEP), saying, “I’m terrified to say anything about enslavement because it might make students ‘uncomfortable.’ I also can’t recommend ANY books because a parent might not like it and then I could be charged with a felony.”

Another spoke to the way these laws are discouraging many educators from engaging in antiracist lessons: “It is creating a chilling effect on education. We continue to teach the truth, but with much less certainty what the consequences will be for doing so.” As of June 2022, The Washington Post had identified at least 160 educators who lost their job or resigned because they taught about race or LGBTQ+ issues — and there are undoubtedly scores more charged with violating anti-truth laws who have been pushed out of the classroom that have gone unreported.

Faced with this assault on the truth, educators around the country are turning the world into their classroom on June 10 and defying the billionaires funding the attack on antiracist education with public pedagogy at an array of creative events. In Lansing, Michigan, organizers are gathering at the corner where Earl Little — father of Malcolm X — was almost certainly lynched by being thrown in front of a streetcar. They’re walking to the hospital where he died to deliver banned children’s books to the kids in their care. Along the way, they plan to chalk the sidewalks with historical information about the Black Freedom Struggle.


In Boston, the Ethnic Studies Organizing Committee is meeting at the former headquarters of the city’s Black Panther Party chapter to help educate people about history that often gets left out of corporate textbooks.

In New York City, there are multiple gatherings, including one at the Stonewall Inn, where legendary Black transgender activist Marsha P. Johnson helped lead a rebellion against a police raid that became the inspiration for the annual Pride demonstrations around the country.

“At Stonewall, we will discuss what took place within those historic walls in 1969, and what action we can take to support LGBTQIA+ rights today,” organizers wrote. “We will share stories about LGBTQIA+ history that often go overlooked.”

In Stone Mountain, Georgia, the Stone Mountain Action Coalition, and other groups are organizing a rally at Stone Mountain Park, site of the largest Confederate monument in the world. The engraving on the side of Stone Mountain depicts Confederate President Jefferson Davis and Confederate Generals Robert E. Lee and Thomas J. “Stonewall” Jackson.

Organizers will read aloud the picture book, “That Flag” (by Tameka Fryer Brown, illustrated by Nikkolas Smith), a story about two young girls — one Black, one white — whose friendship is tested when the white girl’s family displays the Confederate flag and they learn the truth about its racist history.

It is creating a chilling effect on education. We continue to teach the truth, but with much less certainty what the consequences will be for doing so.

In Harmony, Mississippi, organizers are planning an event to highlight the rich contributions to the Black Freedom Struggle that people from their town have made. During the summer of 1964, members of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee organized a Freedom School site in the Harmony community.

The Teach Truth Day of Action events respond to right-wing attacks that have deep roots. During the late 1940s and 50s, the second Red Scare (characterized by the attacks led by Sen. Joseph McCarthy and others on anyone they wanted to discredit by labeling them communists) was accompanied by the Lavender Scare — the repression of LGBTQ+ people and their mass firing from government service. The combination of the Red Scare and the Lavender Scare led to the firing of thousands of teachers around the country.

Just as the Red Scare and Lavender Scare were used to purge teachers and prohibit discussion of social and racial justice in school, the attacks on what history deniers have labeled “critical race theory” and “gender ideology” are used today to fire educators and exclude discussions about structural racism, sexism, transphobia, and homophobia.

We now live in an era defined by the rise of anti-truth and anti-history laws. The outlawing of an honest education represents a sharp turn toward authoritarianism in the United States — what historian Barbara Ransby has called proto-fascism — where now almost half of students are subjected to some form of banning of the truth about systemic racism and oppression.

The goal of these laws is to deny young people access to the lessons of history that could aid in building struggles against inequity.

The goal of these laws is to deny young people access to the lessons of history that could aid in building struggles against inequity.

History is a human right. The struggle for social justice is many things. However, especially in this era, it must include the recognition of the right to learn honest history — particularly about social movements that have challenged injustice. Without truthful accounts of history and the truthful transmission of that history to the next generations, young people are robbed of the first condition of a democratic society — access to the knowledge needed to shape the future.

You, too, can join the #TeachTruth National Day of Action on June 10. Find an event near you. Or, organize your own. An increasing number of communities refuse to repeat the scapegoating and paranoia of the McCarthy era; we won’t let them use race, gender, and sexuality to divide and conquer us.

Tyler Walker, a high school language arts teacher from Austin, Texas, drove this point home when he signed the Zinn Education Project’s “Pledge to Teach the Truth” and wrote “Students need to know the wonderful stories of the brave folks that fought against systems of oppression and sparked hope and solidarity for the creation of a freer, kinder world.”

Get Word In Black directly in your inbox. Subscribe here today

Jesse Hagopian is a high school teacher in Seattle, an editor for Rethinking Schools magazine, an organizer with Black Lives Matter at School, and serves on the leadership team of the Zinn Education Project. Jesse is the author of the forthcoming book from Haymarket Books, Teach Truth: The Attack on Critical Race Theory and the Struggle for Antiracist Education, and the co-editor of the books, Teaching for Black Lives, Black Lives Matter at School, and Teachers Unions and Social Justice. You can connect with Jesse on Twitter, @jessedhagopian, or IG, @jessehagopian.