Great analysis of American fascism as embodied in Donald Trump. It's time to read Mussolini's writings on the corporate state, but start with this read by Robert Reich that Bill Moyers endorses. Particularly in light of the violence our nation witnessed this week at Trump rallies, a Trump presidency is a terrifying prospect. And perhaps most damaging over the long term is a cynicism about politics that tears at the heart of democracy.
I always remember Deborah Meier's words that if there is a problem with democracy, the solution is always more democracy.
-Angela
Viewing
Donald Trump in light of the fascists of the first half of the 20th
century helps explain what Trump is doing and how he is succeeding.
Bill Moyers writes: Robert Reich’s essay, “Trump The American Fascist,” reminded me that back in November Reich had posted as his “Quote of the Week” an excerpt from an April 9, 1944, speech by then Vice-President Henry Wallace. Let it sink in:
“The
American fascists are most easily recognized by their deliberate
perversion of truth and fact. Their newspapers and propaganda carefully
cultivate every fissure of disunity… They claim to be super-patriots,
but they would destroy every liberty guaranteed by the Constitution.
They demand free enterprise, but are the spokesmen for monopoly and
vested interest. Their final objective toward which all their deceit is
directed is to capture political power so that, using the power of the
state and the power of the market simultaneously, they may keep the
common man in eternal subjection.”
Now read Reich’s latest:
I’ve been reluctant to use
the “f” word to describe Donald Trump because it’s especially harsh, and
it’s too often used carelessly.
But Trump has finally reached a
point where parallels between his presidential campaign and the fascists
of the first half of the 20th century – lurid figures such as Benito
Mussolini, Joseph Stalin, Adolf Hitler, Oswald Mosley, and Francisco
Franco – are too evident to overlook.
As
did the early 20th-century fascists, Trump is focusing his campaign on
the angers of white working people who have been losing economic ground
for years, and who are easy prey for demagogues seeking to build their
own power by scapegoating others.
It’s not just that Trump
recently quoted Mussolini (he now calls that tweet inadvertent) or that
he’s begun inviting followers at his rallies to raise their right hands
in a manner chillingly similar to the Nazi “Heil” solute (he dismisses
such comparison as “ridiculous.”)
The parallels go deeper.
As
did the early 20th-century fascists, Trump is focusing his campaign on
the angers of white working people who have been losing economic ground
for years, and who are easy prey for demagogues seeking to build their
own power by scapegoating others.
Trump’s electoral gains have
been largest in counties with lower than average incomes, and among
those who report their personal finances have worsened. As the
Washington Post’s Jeff Guo has pointed out, Trump performs best in places where middle-aged whites are dying the fastest.
The
economic stresses almost a century ago that culminated in the Great
Depression were far worse than most of Trump’s followers have
experienced, but they’ve suffered something that in some respects is
more painful – failed expectations.
Many grew up during the 1950s
and 1960s, during a postwar prosperity that lifted all boats. That
prosperity gave their parents a better life. Trump’s followers naturally
expected that they and their children would also experience economic
gains. They have not.
Add fears and uncertainties about terrorists
who may be living among us, or may want to sneak through our borders,
and this vulnerability and powerlessness is magnified.
Trump’s
incendiary verbal attacks on Mexican immigrants and Muslims – even his
reluctance to distance himself from David Duke and the Ku Klux Klan –
follow the older fascist script.
That older generation of fascists
didn’t bother with policy prescriptions or logical argument, either.
They presented themselves as strongmen whose personal power would remedy
all ills.
They created around themselves cults of personality in
which they took on the trappings of strength, confidence, and
invulnerability – all of which served as substitutes for rational
argument or thought.
Trump’s entire campaign similarly revolves
around his assumed strength and confidence. He tells his followers not
to worry; he’ll take care of them. “If you get laid off … I still want
your vote,” he told workers in Michigan last week. “I’ll get you a new
job; don’t worry about it.”
The old fascists intimidated and
threatened opponents. Trump is not above a similar strategy. To take one
example, he recently tweeted that Chicago’s Ricketts family, now
spending money to defeat him, “better be careful, they have a lot to
hide.”
Donald
Trump is seen in a television camera’s viewfinder during a press
conference at
the Trump National Golf Club on March 8, 2016, in Jupiter,
Florida.
(Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
The old fascists incited violence. Trump has not
done so explicitly but Trump supporters have attacked Muslims, the homeless,
and African-Americans – and Trump has all but excused their behavior.
Weeks after Trump began his campaign by falsely
alleging that Mexican immigrants are “bringing crime. They’re rapists,” two
brothers
in Boston beat with a metal poll and urinated on a 58-year-old
homeless Mexican national. They subsequently told the police “Donald
Trump was
right, all these illegals need to be deported.”
Instead of condemning that brutality, Trump
excused it by saying “people who are following me are very passionate. They
love this
country and they want this country to be great again.”
After a handful of white supporters punched and
attempted to choke a Black Lives Matter protester at one of his campaign
rallies,
Trump said “maybe he should have been roughed up.”
There are further parallels. Fascists glorified
national power and greatness, fanning xenophobia and war. Trump’s entire
foreign
policy consists of asserting American power against other nations.
Mexico “will” finance a wall. China “will” stop manipulating
its currency.
In pursuit of their nationalistic aims, the
fascists disregarded international law. Trump is the same. He recently proposed
using
torture against terrorists, and punishing their families, both in clear
violation of international law.
Finally, the fascists created their mass
followings directly, without political parties or other intermediaries standing
between them
and their legions of supporters.
Trump’s tweets and rallies similarly circumvent
all filters. The Republican Party is irrelevant to his campaign, and he
considers
the media an enemy. (Reporters covering his rallies are kept behind a
steel barrier.)
Viewing Donald Trump in light of the fascists of
the first half of the 20th century – who used economic stresses to scapegoat
others,
created cults of personality, intimidated opponents, incited violence,
glorified their nations and disregarded international law,
and connected
directly with the masses – helps explain what Trump is doing and how he is
succeeding.
It also suggests why Donald Trump presents such a
profound danger to the future of America and the world.
Robert Reich
Robert B. Reich is the chancellor’s professor of public policy at UC-Berkeley and former secretary of labor under the Clinton administration.
Time Magazine named him one of the 10 most effective cabinet secretaries of the 20th century. He is also a founding editor of the
American Prospect magazine and chairman of Common Cause. His film,
Inequality for All, was released in 2013. You can follow him on Twitter at
@RBReich.