Translate

Showing posts with label cancel culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cancel culture. Show all posts

Sunday, October 11, 2026

All the Things You’re Not Allowed to Say In Texas, by Adam Serwer, The Atlantic, October 11, 2026

Friends:

Hot off the press. Adam Serwer’s disturbing new article in The Atlantic, “All the Things You’re Not Allowed to Say in Texas,” exposes the escalating assault on academic freedom across Texas universities—from AI-driven censorship at Texas Tech to faculty dismissals at Texas A&M and the dismantling of academic programs at UT Austin. Note: Add "AI Censor" to your vocabularies. 

I'm actually very interested in what I now know to be a well-established research finding—and as also mentioned by Serwer—that decades of research shows that college does "not alter students’ political beliefs as much as people assume." Geez, I thought those of us on the left were making a bigger difference than we are. That's okay. We can still use it to challenge this central premise underlying the Christian nationalist agenda to remake higher education. 

I guess they think that if they prescribe a return to the great thinkers and books of Western civilization, students will become Republican or perhaps less leftist when there is so much more that goes into the making of our political beliefs than the teaching of Plato, Ethnic Studies, or so-called "gender ideology." In the wake of this evidence, I find it to be a rather humorous assumption that our universities have become engines of "woke" ideological indoctrination and that restoring a particular conception of the Western canon will somehow "correct" students' political and moral orientations. Yet, what I now know are decades of research that calls this entire premise into question.

On a different note, if our universities like UT-Austin, Texas A&M, and Texas Tech are so great, we should be well past this misguided obsession with policing what students read, think, and believe. We should instead be cultivating their intellectual independence, historical understanding, critical judgment, and capacity to engage seriously with ideas—including those with which they disagree. 

Serwer interviewed me briefly for the article, incorporating my concerns about the narrowing of UT Austin’s curriculum. As I emphasized, the issue is not whether Western civilization should be taught, but whether it should be taught to the exclusion of other histories, cultures, and intellectual traditions. A truly great university does not prescribe what students should think; it equips them to think deeply, critically, and independently. Moreover, including the traditions, histories, and contributions of peoples long excluded from the canon makes us great and confident in our standing. 

At stake is nothing less than students’ right to a broad education, academic freedom, and the democratic mission of our public universities. This is a deeply troubling account that deserves national attention. Abundant thanks to both journalist Adam Serwer and The Atlantic for drawing attention to our plight.

-Angela Valenzuela, Ph.D.



All the Things You’re Not Allowed to Say In Texas

The state now controls what professors can teach.
By Adam Serwer
October 11, 2026, 7:50 AM ET


Sara Spurgeon, an English professor at Texas Tech University in Lubbock, has been teaching literature for 20 years. But May 2025 was the first time she was forced to submit her course materials through a portal to be evaluated by an artificial-intelligence program. It flags anything that might violate new rules laid out by the university chancellor, including a prohibition on the “advocacy/promotion of race or sex-based prejudice,” and a requirement—now Texas state law—that “only two sexes, male and female, are recognized.”

At Texas Tech, medical students no longer learn about racial disparities in medical care. Faculty at the university’s medical center in Lubbock were advised to “refrain from treating transgender patients, for any medical condition, if a medical student was present,” according to a lawsuit filed by the American Association of University Professors. (When asked for comment, a spokesperson said that the university’s “written guidance is publicly available and expressly protects instruction necessary for licensure and patient care.”) According to the same lawsuit, the censorship bot—officially known as the Course Content Review Process—ordered a Tech philosophy professor to remove Plato’s Republic from a syllabus because “it references Plato’s beliefs concerning gender roles and homosexuality.”

Professors in the Texas A&M system have had to strip their syllabi too. According to an ACLU lawsuit, last January, Aaron George, a professor at Tarleton State University, was told by administrators to remove A Gay Manifesto, a Stonewall-era LGBTQ-rights pamphlet, and White Flight, a history of urban segregation, from his American-political-history course. After a student complained that a different class the professor taught violated university policy, George was informed by administrators that it would be canceled if he did not make “necessary” (but unspecified) changes. He cut a reference in the course description to the significance of the Fourteenth Amendment for LGBTQ rights, and the class was allowed to proceed.

The University of Texas at Austin, the flagship school of the UT system, announced last month that it was eliminating majors in Africana studies, Mexican American and Latino studies, women’s and gender studies, and race and migration studies. More than 100 courses have been flagged for removal from the core curriculum, primarily ones relating to slavery, race, gender, sexuality, and the environment. Consolidating majors isn’t necessarily nefarious, nor is rethinking a core curriculum (a central group of courses from which students must take a certain number to graduate). But these changes are happening, Lauren Gutterman, an American studies professor at UT, told me, “entirely because of the political context.”

Adam Kirsch: Texas sends Plato back to his cave

Saturday, December 06, 2025

From “Mexican Banditry” to “Woke Ideologues”: The Long History of Blame-Shifting and Controlling the Narrative in Texas, by Angela Valenzuela, Ph.D.

From “Mexican Banditry” to “Woke Ideologues”: The Long History of Blame-Shifting and Controlling the Narrative in Texas

by

Angela Valenzuela, Ph.D.

December 6, 2025

In moments of political crisis, it is often our folklorists, historians, and cultural critics who offer the clearest lens. One of these is the late Américo Paredes,

whose scholarship on the U.S.–Mexico borderlands exposes the deep racial logics that have long shaped Texas politics. Paredes (1958/1990) documented how, as Anglo settlers expanded westward and seized Mexican land through violence, legal maneuvering, and state-sanctioned force, they simultaneously constructed the myth of the “thieving Mexican”—a folkloric trope meant to justify their own actions. The very people having their land stolen were cast as the thieves. 

As a side note, the movie based on Paredes' book, "With His Pistol in His Hand," is one of the most popular posts on this blog. This must-see Western movie is titled, "The Ballad of Gregorio Cortez"

In any case, this rhetorical strategy exemplifies what scholars today term, "reactionary inversion," a political move in which those in power accuse marginalized groups of committing the very harms being inflicted upon them (Romano, 2020; Stanley, 2021). Other equivalent terms noted by scholars are "narrative inversion," "political reversal," or more commonly in public discourse, allegations of “reverse discrimination”—all variations of the same tactic in which perpetrators claim victimhood and victims are recast as the threat.

Once we learn to recognize this move—this insidious abuse of power by political elites—we begin to see it everywhere. 

Paredes further shows that stereotypes of Mexicans as criminal or lawless did not emerge organically from Mexican communities. Rather, they were crafted to rationalize the takeover of land and to authorize the extraordinary violence deployed by state actors such as the Texas Rangers (Locke, 2014; Paredes, 1958/1990). Colonial violence became “order,” and Mexican resistance became “banditry.” The accusation became the alibi.

This same rhetorical script animates contemporary debates surrounding education, diversity, and academic freedom. Calls for equity from DEI practitioners, faculty of color, students, and community advocates have been reframed as dangerous, divisive, or discriminatory. Those seeking redress for long-standing inequities in U.S. society are cast as aggressors, particularly through the language of “cancel culture" (Romano, 2020).

This reframing is reinforced by a broader cultural panic over ‘cancel culture—
one that reframes legitimate public critique as censorship while ignoring or distracting from systemic inequities (Clark, 2020; Romano, 2020). 
—one that reframes legitimate public critique as censorship while ignoring or distracting from systemic inequities (Clark, 2020; Romano, 2020). 

In this discourse, historically marginalized communities are depicted as wielding outsized cultural power, while the actual censorship originates from political actors and state institutions working to restrict what may be taught, researched, supported, or even discussed in public universities (Stanley, 2021; Vogels et al., 2021).

Texas’s SB 17, which dismantles DEI programming and constrains the ability of universities to support historically marginalized communities, is a textbook case of reactionary inversion. DEI programs designed to expand access and belonging are recast as threats to “viewpoint diversity.” Faculty and students of color, long denied equitable treatment, are portrayed as the ones doing the excluding. Efforts to address inequality are reframed as evidence of “ideological coercion,” while state interference in academic freedom is packaged as a defense of free speech. 

In much the same way that Mexican landholders were labeled criminals in order to justify dispossession, DEI advocates are labeled ideologues in order to justify dismantling DEI itself.

This historical continuity matters. Paredes reminds us that myths are not just stories. They are weapons. They shape the public imagination, granting moral authority to those who already hold institutional power, and they normalize forms of domination that would otherwise be indefensible. 

The rhetoric surrounding cancel culture, free speech, and viewpoint diversity is not simply about ideas. It is about who gets to define reality, whose knowledge counts, and whose voices are allowed to shape our public institutions. 

Understanding this pattern reveals that SB 17 and related anti-DEI efforts are not novel disruptions but part of a long-standing historical strategy in which those advancing racial exclusion cast themselves as victims and frame equity as the threat. As Paredes’s work teaches us, when political leaders accuse marginalized communities of the very acts being inflicted upon them, we should look closely at what power is doing—and not merely what it is saying. 

Paredes reminds us that myths reproduce themselves when left unchallenged. Today, educators, researchers, and community advocates face the task of countering new iterations of old narratives—narratives that seek to delegitimize equity work and constrain intellectual freedom. Moving forward requires not only naming these strategies but actively cultivating environments where critical inquiry, historical memory, and community knowledge can flourish despite political headwinds. 

Our institutions—and our democracy—depend on it.

References

Clark, M. D. (2020). Drag them: A brief etymology of so-called “cancel culture." Communication and Media Studies, 66(2), 1–7.

Locke, J. (2014). Teaching Local History as National (and Transnational) History http://www.teachingushistory.co/2014/03/teaching-local-history-as-national-and-transnational-history.html

Paredes, A. (1990). With his pistol in his hand: A border ballad and its hero. University of Texas Press. (Original work published 1958)

Romano, A. (2020, December 30). Why we can’t stop fighting about cancel culture. Vox. https://www.vox.com/ [also at: https://courses.bowdoin.edu/sociology-1101-spring-2020/wp-content/uploads/sites/319/2020/05/What-is-cancel-culture_-Why-we-keep-fighting-about-canceling-people.-Vox.pdf]

Stanley, J. (2021). How fascism works: The politics of us and them. Random House.

Vogels, E. A., Anderson, M., Porteus, M., Baronavski, C., Atske, S., McClain, C., Auxier, B., Perrin, A., & Ramshankar, M. (2021, May 19). Americans and “cancel culture”: Where some see calls for accountability, others see censorship, punishment. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2021/05/19/americans-and-cancel-culture-where-some-see-calls-for-accountability-others-see-censorship-punishment/

Saturday, November 18, 2023

Please indulge me on this day of reflection on "Doing the work: The Protestant ethic and the spirit of wokeness," by Ian Buruma

Friends,

Please indulge me on this day of reflection on "Doing the work: The Protestant ethic and the spirit of wokeness," by Bard College Professor Ian Buruma in this July, 2023 piece in Harper's Magazine that I'm sure will get widely read. He blames Protestantism for ostensibly caving in to "woke culture," more readily than might be found among Catholics or Jews. While an interesting hypothesis, I think it is a somewhat misplaced concern.

What I most appreciate about Buruma's piece is just how deeply it made me think not so much about his sensed correlation between weak-kneed Protestantism capitulating to "wokeness" via cancel culture, engaging in forms of public apology, and virtue signaling, but rather about his simple solution of a return to a more tempered and less puritanical mindset that would benefit progressive causes. While this would clearly help, it's insufficient in light of race/ethnicity and class dynamics that I outline below.

Buruma takes aim at diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) programs, essentially blaming "identity politics" for going too far and forgetting about the white working class. This is a misrepresentation of DEI programs as they have in fact evolved to incorporate students with disability, veterans, and persons of rural origins that may be of any race or ethnicity. Plus, race and ethnicity frequently overlap with class background such that the former is often a proxy for the latter.

As importantly, Buruma fails to acknowledge white's identity politics that we may otherwise term, white supremacy politics that you can learn about in Ashely Jardina's (2019) book titled, White Identity Politics that she also maintains, are bigger than the KKK in her Washington Post piece titled, "White identity politics isn’t just about white supremacy. It’s much bigger."

I also think that Buruma is unfair on not only placing the onus for a lack of solidarity across class on people of color when considering long histories as we have enjoyed in Texas of interracial and interethnic coalitions in politics where we actually consistently advocate on issues like school finance and vouchers that benefit the rich and not the poor (see yesterday's post on vouchers, for example). School finance is another area.

Consider, as well, the decades-long work of one of our state's most significant education coalitions of our day, namely, he Texas Legislative Education Equity Coalition headed by Dr. Chloe Sikes, a former student of ours in the UT-Education Policy and Planning doctoral program. Consider, as well the storied Texas Organizing Project that is featured in Steve Phillip's national best-seller, How We Win the Civil War: Securing a Multiracial Democracy and Ending White Supremacy for Good.

There are also incredible stories and histories of in Krochmal and Moye's masterful anthology on this very subject titled, Civil rights in black and brown: Histories of resistance and struggle in Texas.

Consider, as well, the divide and conquer techniques that have worked to fracture the working class across time consisting, for example, of a lack of pay equity and wage gaps within the working class. This creates resentment and competition, fostering divisions at work. When inflected by race, this oftentimes doesn't address underlying dynamics of workers' exploitation, but rather gets addressed as a racial, as opposed to both a race and class issue related to working conditions, salaries, and opportunities for promotion. These dynamics play out within the professional occupations, as well, as exemplified by the Independent Equity Committee in their widely-read, highly impactful report recently at the University of Texas at Austin.

We must, in the same breath, be mindful of how as a consequence of the inter-ethnic competition that exists as a result of historic divide-and-conquer strategies, coalition-building is really hard work and often manifest internally via racial power dynamics within both the U.S. working and professional classes, respectively.

Omi and Winant (2014) similarly note in their seminal text, Racial Formation in the United States, that throughout history, the white working class that has historically either broken ranks with the Black and Brown members of the working class or in instances of cooperation, including unionization, still often seeks to rule over their Black and Brown segments.

Context is king, as well. Do note that according to Wilson (2016), by 2032, individuals from diverse ethnic backgrounds will constitute the majority of the American working class. Eliminating our understandings of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) policies as currently getting legislated in states like Texas, Florida and North Carolina, ill-prepare us for an inexorably diverse future.

Last, but not least, I am very proud of our work in Black Brown Dialogues on Policy in promoting awareness of this vitally important work of building interracial and interethnic coalitions of conscience. I encourage you to view our recorded Facebook live event last week at the Texas State Capitol that I also announced on this blog.







I also encourage you to hear the student voices who reflected on their own experiences, as well as on what was shared throughout the day.





The testimonies were awe-inspiring. The students melt my heart.

My friends, this is the precise political work motivates community solidarity across struggles. It is exactly this coalitional work—of the kind that defeated vouchers yesterday—that holds enormous promise for a brighter future in our state and nation.

Sí se puede! Yes we can!

-Angela Valenzuela


References


Jardina, A. (2019). White identity politics. Cambridge University Press.

Jardina, A. (2017). White Identity Politics Isn’t Just about White Supremacy: It’s Much Bigger, WashingtonPost. com, August, 16(2).

Krochmal, M., & Moye, T. (Eds.). (2021). Civil rights in black and brown: Histories of resistance and struggle in Texas. University of Texas Press.

Omi, M., & Winant, H. (2014). Racial formation in the United States. Routledge.

Phillips, S. (2022). How We Win the Civil War: Securing a Multiracial Democracy and Ending White Supremacy for Good. The New Press.

Wilson, V. (2016, June 9). People of color will be a majority of the American working class in 2032: What this means for the effort to grow wages and reduce inequality, Economic Policy Institute.


Doing the Work: The Protestant ethic and the spirit of wokeness

by Ian Buruma | July 2023 | Harpers

Writing about “Woke” has at least two pitfalls. One is that any criticism of its excesses provokes accusations of racism, xenophobia, transphobia, misogyny, or white supremacy. The other problem is the word itself, which has been a term of abuse employed by the far right, a battle cry for the progressive left, and an embarrassment to many liberals.

No one can agree on what woke is supposed to mean. The right has blamed it for everything from the spike in school shootings to the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, while many who are described as woke on the left see themselves as fighting a long-overdue battle for social and racial justice. These disagreements are not just political. In fact, they sometimes seem to be antipolitical. Arguments over wokeness are often tests, as the word indicates, of moral and spiritual enlightenment.

This is why John McWhorter, the author of Woke Racism, decided to drop woke as a descriptor of antiracism evangelists and instead call them “the Elect.” This has the right religious and class connotations. The Elect, he writes, are people who “see themselves as having been chosen . . . as understanding something most do not.” Like pre-modern Christians, the Elect must either convert or punish those who have not seen the light.

Thursday, September 22, 2022

What if Instead of Calling People Out, We Called Them In? Words of wisdom from Prof. Loretta J. Ross

Kudos to Professor Loretta J. Ross for calling out the "calling out culture" in our country that's so toxic. Instead of taking this path, she suggests that we "call in" people with whom we disagree.  Moreover, we do this with love and respect. She elaborates further:

"Calling out assumes the worst. Calling in involves conversation, compassion and context. It doesn’t mean a person should ignore harm, slight or damage, but nor should she, he or they exaggerate it."

So we should be able to have uncomfortable conversations without publicly shaming people. For this to happen, we must be both aware and intentional of this stubborn cultural pattern of calling out that has to get un-learned, on the one hand, while nurturing a practice of calling in, on the other.

More nuance is merited with respect to people like Colin Kapernick who took a knee. This is not a calling out or a "punching down" in the sense she describes, but rather is a "punching up" when this involves an unequal power relationship such as with the NFL. 

Thanks to Colette Phillips for recommending this very insightful, much-needed piece in today's increasingly hostile cancel culture. Those of us in the college classroom can make great use of this wisdom. It's also important to policy studies and the need we have of "talking across the aisle."

-Angela Valenzuela

Prof. Loretta J. Ross is combating cancel culture with a popular class at Smith College.

What if Instead of Calling People Out, We Called Them In? 

Prof. Loretta J. Ross is combating cancel culture with a popular class at Smith College.

By Jessica Bennett | New York Times | Nov. 19, 2020 Updated Feb. 24, 2021

Nyla Conaway, 19, remembers being “called out” for changing her profile picture on Instagram in solidarity for … something. She can’t quite remember what for, only that an older student she didn’t know told her it was a scam. “It just made me feel really embarrassed, like a ton of people had seen it and now I just looked really stupid,” she said.

Katie Wehrman, 18, still feels guilty for calling out a boy in her high school for something he said about a local politician and L.G.B.T.Q. rights — schooling him in an all-class Snapchat group.

Sophia Hanna, 18, has never been called out herself, but has spent more time than she’d like to admit during this pandemic watching two beauty bloggers call each other out.

“It just fires something emotionally,” she said, noting that she doesn’t even like makeup tutorials. “There’s like a dopamine trigger that makes me keep scrolling.”

The women are students in a class taught by Loretta J. Ross, a visiting professor at Smith College who is challenging them to identify the characteristics, and limits, of call-out culture: the act of publicly shaming another person for behavior deemed unacceptable. Calling out may be described as a sister to dragging, cousin to problematic, and one of the many things that can add up to cancellation.

“I am challenging the call-out culture,” Professor Ross said from her home in Atlanta, where she was lecturing on Zoom to students on a recent evening, in a blue muumuu from Ghana. “I think you can understand how calling out is toxic. It really does alienate people, and makes them fearful of speaking up.”

‘Uncomfortable Conversations’

That perspective has made Professor Ross, 67, an unlikely figure in the culture wars. A radical Black feminist who has been doing human rights work for four decades, she was one of the signatories of a widely denounced letter in Harper’s Magazine, for which she herself was called out. “There’s such an irony for being called out for calling out the calling-out culture,” she said. “It really was amusing.”

Professor Ross has been an activist for more than 40 years, and she helped organize a delegation of women of color at the March for Women’s Lives in 1989.

Credit...Sophia Smith Collection of Women’s History, Smith College Special Collections

At Smith College, Professor Ross teaches courses called White Supremacy in the Age of Trump, of which the “calling in” module is part, and Reproductive Justice. Yet she tells students when they enroll: “If you need a trigger warning or a safe space, I urge you to drop this class.”

“I think we overuse that word ‘trigger’ when really we mean discomfort,” she said. “And we should be able to have uncomfortable conversations.”

She doesn’t believe people should be publicly shamed for accidentally misgendering a classmate, which she once did, leading to a Title IX complaint that was later dismissed; for sending a stupid tweet they now regret; or for, say, admitting they once liked a piece of pop culture now viewed in a different light, such as “The Cosby Show.”

“If it were on TV right now, I’d watch the reruns,” she said.

“What I’m really impatient with is calling people out for something they said when they were a teenager when they’re now 55. I mean, we all at some point did some unbelievably stupid stuff as teenagers, right?”

Professor Ross thinks call-out culture has taken conversations that could have once been learning opportunities and turned them into mud wrestling on message boards, YouTube comments, Twitter and at colleges like Smith, where proving one’s commitment to social justice has become something of a varsity sport.

“I think this is also related to something I just discovered called doom scrolling,” Professor Ross told the students. “I think we actually sabotage our own happiness with this unrestrained anger. And I have to honestly ask: Why are you making choices to make the world crueler than it needs to be and calling that being ‘woke’?”

The antidote to that outrage cycle, Professor Ross believes, is “calling in.” Calling in is like calling out, but done privately and with respect. “It’s a call out done with love,” she said. That may mean simply sending someone a private message, or even ringing them on the telephone (!) to discuss the matter, or simply taking a breath before commenting, screen-shotting or demanding one “do better” without explaining how.

Calling out assumes the worst. Calling in involves conversation, compassion and context. It doesn’t mean a person should ignore harm, slight or damage, but nor should she, he or they exaggerate it. “Every time somebody disagrees with me it’s not ‘verbal violence.’” Professor Ross said. “I’m not getting ‘re-raped.’ Overstatement of harm is not helpful when you’re trying to create a culture of compassion.”

There was call-out culture when Professor Ross was young. “We called it ‘trashing,’” she said, referring to a term used by Jo Freeman, in an essay in Ms., to describe infighting within the women’s movement.

“It used to be you’d be calling someone out to a duel. This is how Alexander Hamilton got shot!” Professor Ross said. “What’s new is the virality and the speed and the anonymity.”









Ms. Ross spoke on behalf of the D.C. Rape Crisis Center in 1979. Credit...Sophia Smith Collection of Women’s History, Smith College Special Collections

Civil conversation between parties who disagree has also been part of activism, including her own, for quite some time.

As executive director of the D.C. Rape Crisis Center from 1979 to 1982, she used her own story of sexual assault to facilitate a conversation with incarcerated rapists, teaching them Black feminist theory.

She worked to improve the participation of women of color as a program director at the National Organization for Women and is credited, along with 11 others, as having coined the term “reproductive justice” — a combination of “reproductive rights” and “social justice” in response to what they believed was missing from Bill Clinton’s 1994 health care reform plan.

Later, as the program and research director for the Center for Democratic Renewal, which monitored hate groups, she found herself on a mountaintop in rural Tennessee, teaching antiracism to women whose families were members of the Ku Klux Klan.

She thought of what her organization’s founder, the Rev. C.T. Vivian — who had been Martin Luther King’s field general — told her when she started her job: “When you ask people to give up hate, you have to be there for them when they do.”

And so she was.

In the early 1990s, Professor Ross accompanied Floyd Cochran, once the national spokesman for the Aryan Nations, on a national atonement tour.

“Here’s a guy who had never done anything but be a Nazi since he was 14 years old, and now he was 35 with no job, no education, no hope. And we helped people like them,” she said. After The Los Angeles Times wrote an article about their unlikely friendship, in 1997, Professor Ross and Mr. Cochran were each paid $10,000 for a Hollywood adaptation option of their story. But when the script came back, there was a fatal flaw: It ended with the two falling in love.

“Floyd was married, and I don’t fall in love with Nazis,” Professor Ross said.

Sometime in those years, Professor Ross found herself on a street corner in Janesville, Wis., in the dead of winter, watching as Ken Peterson — a defector from the K.K.K. — filmed an interview with “The Geraldo Rivera Show.” Mr. Peterson and his wife, Carol, had to flee their home quickly, and Ms. Peterson was shivering in the cold.

“I stood there for the first half-hour watching her, and at some point I made the decision to share my coat with her,” Professor Ross said. “I just couldn’t maintain that anger, I couldn’t maintain that posture.”

The idea of “calling in” occurred to Professor Ross at a speech she was organizing at Smith in 2015 to honor Gloria Steinem. What was up with all the nastiness she saw on Twitter, she asked a young woman.

“Oh, you mean ‘calling out’?’’ the woman said.

“You-all named it?’” Professor Ross said in surprise.

She soon assembled a group of students to practice the techniques of “calling in” and took the message on the road. During quarantine this summer, she began offering an online course called Calling In the Calling Out Culture, and is working on a book of the same name.

She has also been hired by nonprofits and women’s organizations to help them grapple with their own reckonings around race and gender. “I wouldn’t call myself a mediator,” she said. “I’m like a one-time consultant, rearranging relationships. ‘We’re on Indian land,’ ‘we’ve got trans students,’ ‘we’ve got buildings named after slave owners.’” The hardest part, she said, is “to convince them is that they aren’t each other’s enemies.”


Professor Ross, pictured at her home in Atlanta, believes calling out has become a kind of “woke competition” in some circles.Credit...Peyton Fulford for The New York Times

‘Should I Be Concerned?’

Not that Professor Ross is conflict averse. “I have no problem calling out politicians who aren’t living up to the oaths that they swore to,” she said. She cited Colin Kaepernick, someone who quite effectively called out a powerful organization, the N.F.L. “The thing I am sharply critical of is punching down, calling out people who have less power than you simply because you can get away with it. But there is a very strategic use of punching up.”

Indeed, after the #MeToo movement and global protests of police violence in response to the killings of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, employees have called out bosses, consumers have called out corporations, students have called out peers, and victims have called out abusers.

“Folks have figured out that social media shaming and attention makes things happen,” said Meredith Clark, an assistant professor of media studies at the University of Virginia who recently published a study of call-out culture called “Drag Them.” “It evokes apology from things and places that wouldn’t normally enter into that sort of dialogue, and it allows people who otherwise would have no recourse to influence their own experiences.”

More troublesome, Professor Ross and others agree, is when small infractions become big infractions; when context gets lost and facts are distorted, or it becomes difficult to discern between the two.

“These algorithms can’t distinguish between outrage and shaming that is proportionate and outrage and shaming that is disproportionate to the original transgression,” said Molly Crockett, an assistant professor of psychology at Yale University who studies moral outrage online.

Back on her Zoom call, Professor Ross pulled up another slide, this one with a photo of Natalie Wynn, a popular YouTuber who has put together a kind of taxonomy of call-out culture after being “canceled” multiple times.

Its characteristics include presumption of guilt (without facts or nuance getting in the way); essentialism (when criticism of bad behavior becomes criticism of a bad person); pseudo-intellectualism (proclaiming one’s moral high ground); unforgivability (no apology is good enough); and, of course, contamination, or guilt by association.

“This happened to me with the Harper’s letter,” Professor Ross said, referring to the last point. “Just the fact that my name appeared on the same letter with J.K. Rowling. I mean, give me a break. I wish I knew her and I wish she knew me, but that’s not the truth.”

As it turns out, all of that shaming may be counterproductive. Multiple studies, Ms. Crockett said, have found that shaming can make people more resistant to change.

And, as anyone who has partaken in a game of casual doom scrolling knows, it can also be bad for health — physical and mental.

When Professor Ross’s students were asked to describe how thinking about a call out made them feel, they used descriptions like “pit in stomach,” “nauseous” and “sweating through all my clothes.”

Some said later that the prospect of call outs had made them hesitant to speak up or ask questions in classes, or endlessly planning for the arguments that might ensue.

“I had this weird moment recently where I was, like, ‘Oh man, J.K. Rowling is saying some real bad stuff. It’s too bad that I once supported Harry Potter,’” said Ms. Hanna, a first-year student from Nebraska, referring to comments about transgender people made by the author. “And then I took five seconds to be, like, ‘I am concerned about someone finding out that I, until quite recently a child, liked a children’s series?’ Should I be concerned about this? This feels like it’s no great thing to be concerned about.”

Katherine Albert-Aranovich, a sophomore from Los Angeles, said she has deleted all of her social profiles, to try to be “removed from that negativity.”

Rebecca Alvara, of Phoenix, described the mental gymnastics of trying to buy herself a hoodie with the image of a band she liked. “I was, like, ‘but what if they’ve done something terrible? And I just don’t know about it yet? Should I not buy this?’ And so I panicked and I was, like, ‘No, it’s fine. I don’t need it anyway.’”

The students are eager to practice calling in, or least trying. But they have questions.

Is interjecting calling in? What’s the difference between calling in and a regular confrontation? What if calling out in fact is the most effective way to seek progress — as with, say, in the case of a public figure? And when is politely trying to “call in” simply no longer effective?

“You can’t be responsible for someone else’s inability to grow,” Professor Ross said. “So take comfort in the fact that you offered a new perspective of information and you did so with love and respect, and then you walk away.

“We have a saying in the movement: Some people you can work with and some people you can work around. But the thing that I want to emphasize is that the calling-in practice means you always keep a seat at the table for them if they come back.”

Jessica Bennett is a Times editor at large, covering personalities, politics, culture and the workplace — through a gender lens. She is the author of “Feminist Fight Club” and “This Is 18.” Previously, she was The Times' gender editor. @jessicabennett • Facebook

A version of this article appears in print on Nov. 19, 2020, Section D, Page 1 of the New York edition with the headline: Don’t Call People Out; Call Them In, She Urges. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe

Wednesday, August 17, 2022

IDRA Testimony before the SBOE on Texas' Censorship, Cancel Culture, "Anti-CRT" Bills, by Dr. Chloe Sikes

Learn here from research conducted at the Intercultural Development Research Association (IDRA) by Dr. Chloe Sikes and her colleagues about the broader impacts of Texas' "anti-CRT" bills, House Bill 3979 and Senate Bill 3, as well as on ensuing book bans. Critical Race Theory, as we know, isn't actually taught in schools, so it's Ethnic Studies, as well as Women and Gender Studies and anything critical, that are the targets of this legislation.

HB 3979 and SB 3 have created a chilling effect, contributing, along with other factors like low teacher salaries and poor working conditions, to exacerbate Texas' epoch-making teacher shortage that lay the groundwork for vouchers and other privatization schemes that are sure to rear their ugly heads in the coming legislative session beginning in January, 2023.

Though predictable, it's sad to read about their impacts on educators’ and students' morale and sense of safety and security. Geez what kind of country are we living in when police interrogate educators on the books that they're reading? 

Plus, how ironic this censorship agenda for a party that decries "cancel  culture!"

As I've been calling out on this blog, this is the rolling out of the fascist, white supremacist, neoliberal state that seeks to disempower our predominantly minority K-12 student population. 

According to 2020-21 state-level data, Hispanic students are the largest group at 52.9% and African American students at 12.7%, such that our schools are overwhelmingly comprised of students of color (65.6 %). The White student population follows at 26.5%, with Asian and multiracial students accounting for the remainder at 4.7% and 2.7%, respectively (Texas Education Agency, 2021).

In this demographic context, it's logical to conclude that HB 3979 and SB 3 are the "racial codes," or Jim Crow laws of today. These are intentionally designed to limit what our minoritized student population can accomplish lest they become empowered and argue for their rights—which is exactly what they should be doing. 

These actions are clearly a reaction to the successes we have had in Ethnic Studies policy that in some instances, have resulted in the cancellation of such courses in schools throughout the state.

Let's vote this administration out of power and let's work toward repealing these bills in the next Texas legislative session. Let's also protect Academic Freedom in higher education, the next battle ground for this kind of cancel culture policy.

Great work, Dr. Sikes and IDRA! Andan asustados. They're scared. We're going to win this. After all, in so many ways, we already have.

Sí se puede! Yes we can!

-Angela Valenzuela


Recent State Policy on Curriculum Leads to Classroom Censorship in Schools 

IDRA Testimony on Interim Charge to Monitor State Policy on Curriculum and Instructional Materials Used in Public Schools, Re: HB 3979 (87R) and SB 3 (87, 2) 


Submitted to the Texas House Public Education Committee, July 26, 2022 


For questions or more information, please contact Chloe Latham Sikes, Ph.D.

IDRA Deputy Director of Policy, at chloe.sikes@idra.org. 


IDRA is an independent, non-partisan education non-profit committed to achieving equal educational opportunity for every child through strong public schools that prepare all students to access and succeed in college. We submit this testimony for your consideration on the implementation to date of HB 3979 (87R) and SB 3 (87, 2), otherwise known as Texas’ classroom censorship policies, and their negative impacts on Texas students, educators and schools. Although SB 3 largely replaced HB 3979, they collectively impacted the last school year as documented by this interim testimony.